Pollution exacerbates China’s water scarcity and its regional inequality

Ting Ma, Siao Sun, Guangtao Fu, Jim W. Hall, Yong Ni, Lihuan He, Jiawei Yi, Na Zhao, Yunyan Du, Tao Pei, Weiming Cheng, Ci Song, Chuanglin Fang, Chenghu ZhouNature Communications 2020 · DOI

Abstract: Inadequate water quality can mean that water is unsuitable for a variety of human uses, thus exacerbating freshwater scarcity. Previous large-scale water scarcity assessments mostly focused on the availability of sufficient freshwater quantity for providing supplies, but neglected the quality constraints on water usability. Here we report a comprehensive nationwide water scarcity assessment in China, which explicitly includes quality requirements for human water uses. We highlight the necessity of incorporating water scarcity assessment at multiple temporal and geographic scales. Our results show that inadequate water quality exacerbates China's water scarcity, which is unevenly distributed across the country. North China often suffers water scarcity throughout the year, whereas South China, despite sufficient quantities, experiences seasonal water scarcity due to inadequate quality. Over half of the population are affected by water scarcity, pointing to an urgent need for improving freshwater quantity and quality management to cope with water scarcity.

The Multi-Dimensional Crisis of Water Scarcity

Traditional water scarcity assessments often focus solely on physical volume—the "quantity gap." However, water that is too polluted for use is effectively unavailable. This study addresses the "quality gap" by integrating pollution constraints into a nationwide assessment of China. It also tackles the "scale gap" by moving beyond coarse annual averages to seasonal and monthly resolutions, and the "inequality gap" by quantifying how pollution worsens disparities between regions.

A Comprehensive Assessment Framework

The researchers developed a framework to quantify three types of scarcity: Quantity-based ($WS_{qua}$), Pollution-induced ($WS_{pol}$), and Combined ($WS_{com}$). $WS_{pol}$ uses a "dilution approach," calculating the freshwater volume needed to dilute pollutants (COD, Ammonium Nitrogen, and Electrical Conductivity) to meet safety standards. Analysis was conducted across four geographic scales (from $0.25^{\circ}$ grid cells to large basins) and three temporal scales (annual, seasonal, monthly). Data spanned 2012–2016, utilizing 2,630 sampling sites and the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) hydrologic model.

Results: The Hidden Impact of Pollution

The inclusion of water quality fundamentally alters the map of scarcity in China. While North China suffers from a chronic shortage of both quantity and quality, South China—traditionally considered water-abundant—reveals significant seasonal scarcity when pollution is factored in.

Spatial distribution of water scarcity in China. Panel (c) shows quantity-based scarcity, while (b) and (d) illustrate how pollution exacerbates these levels, particularly in the south.

Quantitatively, the land area impacted by scarcity rises from 28.8% (quantity-only) to 32.0% (combined). The population impact is even more stark. On an annual basis, over half of China's population (51.3% to 86.1%, depending on scale) lives under combined water scarcity.

The "Averaging Trap" and Regional Inequality

A critical finding is that annual assessments mask acute monthly crises. When viewed at a monthly resolution, nearly the entire population (94.7% to 100%) faces water scarcity for at least one month of the year.

Population affected by water scarcity. Red outlines indicate combined quantity and quality assessments, showing a significantly higher impact compared to quantity-only (blue outlines) across all geographic scales and durations.

Furthermore, the study used the Theil’s L index to show that pollution is a major driver of regional water inequality. Because the capacity of water bodies to self-purify depends on available volume, water-poor regions are disproportionately burdened by pollution, widening the gap between "water haves" and "water have-nots."

Discussion and Policy Implications

While the study highlights an urgent need for integrated water management, it notes limitations such as the exclusion of groundwater quality data and the complex effects of large-scale infrastructure like the South-to-North Water Transfer. Nonetheless, the results prove that "dirty water is as good as no water," and addressing pollution is as vital as managing volume to ensure water security.

Summary updated

Abstract

Inadequate water quality can mean that water is unsuitable for a variety of human uses, thus exacerbating freshwater scarcity. Previous large-scale water scarcity assessments mostly focused on the availability of sufficient freshwater quantity for providing supplies, but neglected the quality constraints on water usability. Here we report a comprehensive nationwide water scarcity assessment in China, which explicitly includes quality requirements for human water uses. We highlight the necessity of incorporating water scarcity assessment at multiple temporal and geographic scales. Our results show that inadequate water quality exacerbates China's water scarcity, which is unevenly distributed across the country. North China often suffers water scarcity throughout the year, whereas South China, despite sufficient quantities, experiences seasonal water scarcity due to inadequate quality. Over half of the population are affected by water scarcity, pointing to an urgent need for improving freshwater quantity and quality management to cope with water scarcity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2020pollution,
  author = {Ting Ma and Siao Sun and Guangtao Fu and Jim W. Hall and Yong Ni and Lihuan He and Jiawei Yi and Na Zhao and Yunyan Du and Tao Pei and Weiming Cheng and Ci Song and Chuanglin Fang and Chenghu Zhou},
  title = {{Pollution exacerbates China’s water scarcity and its regional inequality}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-14532-5},
}
Figure