Political blend: an application designed to bring people together based on political differences

Abraham Doris-Down, Husayn Versee, Eric GilbertC&T 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Political Blend," a mobile application designed to combat political echo chambers by facilitating face-to-face meetings between individuals with differing political beliefs. The study found that people are indeed open to such interactions, suggesting a potential avenue for fostering greater understanding and bridging political divides in a polarized society.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern social media, while connecting people globally, has inadvertently contributed to the formation of "echo chambers." These are environments where individuals primarily consume information that reinforces their existing worldviews, leading to increased political polarization and a decline in constructive civic discourse. The paper highlights how algorithms and user preferences often lead to self-segregation, making it harder for people with different political perspectives to engage with and understand each other. This lack of cross-group discussion hinders the ability of a diverse society to collaborate and solve problems effectively.

Methods

The researchers developed a mobile application called "Political Blend" as a solution. The core of the method involves matching users with differing political beliefs and scheduling them for face-to-face meetings at a neutral location, specifically a local coffee shop. The matching process uses a simplified political leaning assessment, where users select political figures they agree with, rather than requiring detailed self-reporting. The application also incorporates a gamified incentive system (a shared coupon) to encourage interaction and a sense of collaboration. The study then gathered qualitative data through semi-structured interviews and quantitative data through surveys to assess user experiences and the perceived impact of the application.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved participants recruited through flyers, email lists, and class announcements, and the data collected was from their interactions with the Political Blend application and subsequent interviews/surveys.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • People are open to bridging divides: A significant finding is that individuals are willing to meet and interact with those who hold opposing political views, even if they don't agree on everything.
  • Neutral spaces foster dialogue: Meeting in a public, neutral location like a coffee shop, rather than an online political forum, seems to encourage more civil and constructive interactions.
  • Incentives matter, but context is key: While a tangible incentive (like a free pastry) was effective, the way it was presented (requiring collaboration to redeem) was crucial for encouraging interaction.
  • Focus on commonalities, not conversion: The goal of Political Blend isn't to change minds, but to build common ground and foster understanding by highlighting shared perspectives.
  • Technology can be a tool for connection, not just division: The study demonstrates that technology can be intentionally designed to counteract the isolating effects of echo chambers.

Key Results

  • High user engagement: 11 participants engaged in 21 meetings.
  • Positive perception of the problem: All interview participants agreed that political discourse in the US is divisive and combative.
  • Perceived value of Political Blend: 7 out of 7 survey respondents felt Political Blend would help people of different beliefs communicate, and 6 out of 7 felt such applications could improve the political environment.
  • Enjoyment of the experience: 6 out of 7 respondents found Political Blend easy to use and enjoyed the meetings.
  • Meeting duration: Interviews suggested meetings lasted around 20-30 minutes, longer than initially anticipated.
  • No change in core beliefs: No participants felt their political beliefs changed as a result of the meetings, aligning with the study's goal of fostering understanding rather than conversion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited participant pool: The study was conducted with university students, faculty, and staff, which limits the generalizability of findings to the broader population. Future work should explore broader demographics.
  • Self-selection bias: The study relied on self-selected participants, meaning researchers had less control over the study population's characteristics.
  • Need for improved scheduling and communication: Participants found it difficult to locate their matches and suggested features for direct communication (e.g., messaging) to handle lateness or rescheduling.
  • Desire for discussion starters: While initially omitted to avoid confrontation, participants expressed a desire for prompts or discussion starters to facilitate political conversations.
  • Longitudinal study needed: A future study should track participants over time to assess the long-term impact of these interactions on attitudes and understanding.
  • Potential for integration: The authors suggest that Political Blend's approach could be integrated into existing platforms like social media or e-commerce sites to promote cross-group interaction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dorisdown2013political,
  author = {Abraham Doris-Down and Husayn Versee and Eric Gilbert},
  title = {{Political blend: an application designed to bring people together based on political differences}},
  booktitle = {C\&T},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1145/2482991.2483002},
}
Figure