Policy Gradient Based Semi-Markov Decision Problems: Approximation and Estimation Errors

Ngo Anh Vien, SeungGwan Lee, TaeChoong ChungIEICE Trans. Information and Systems 2010 · OpenReview

Introduction

Semi-Markov Decision Processes (SMDPs) are essential for modeling systems where transitions occur at irregular, random intervals—a common occurrence in telecommunications routing, robotic maintenance, and complex queueing systems. Optimizing the average reward in these continuous-time settings is a significant challenge. While policy gradient methods offer a path forward, they often rely on mathematical approximations to handle long-term average objectives.

Previously, the Gradient-based Semi-Markov Decision Process (GSMDP) algorithm was introduced to estimate these gradients using only a single sample path of data. While the algorithm was proven to converge, its practical reliability depended on two unanswered questions: how much does the approximation deviate from the true gradient, and how much noise is introduced by finite data? This paper provides the theoretical "safety net" for GSMDP by establishing rigorous mathematical bounds for both approximation and estimation errors.

The GSMDP Framework

The GSMDP algorithm simplifies the optimization of average rewards by introducing a discount factor ($\beta$) to make the gradient calculation tractable. This allows the controller to update policies based on a single trajectory of the system without needing frequent restarts or parallel simulations. This paper analyzes the performance of this approach through two distinct lenses:

  1. Approximation Error: The bias introduced by the mathematical shortcut (the discount factor) used to approximate the average reward gradient.
  2. Estimation Error: The variance or noise introduced because the algorithm processes a finite sequence of $T$ steps rather than an infinite data stream.

Theoretical Error Analysis

Approximation Error

The authors utilize spectral analysis—specifically the eigenvalues of the transition matrix—to quantify how the discount factor $\beta$ affects the gradient's accuracy. Theorems 2 and 3 in the paper demonstrate that the approximation error is bounded by a term proportional to $(1 - e^{-\beta\nu})$. This confirms that as $\beta$ approaches zero, the approximation error vanishes at a predictable rate, allowing the estimated gradient to converge toward the true gradient of the average reward.

Estimation Error

To address the limitations of finite data, the authors employ a "k-blocked" version of the algorithm to analyze variance. They provide a "Probably Approximately Correct" (PAC) style bound (Theorem 4). This bound shows that the probability of the estimation error exceeding a specific threshold $\epsilon$ decreases exponentially as the number of iterations ($n_2$) increases. This ensures that with sufficient data, the algorithm's output will reliably stay within a narrow margin of its asymptotic target.

Key Insights: The Bias-Variance Trade-off

A critical contribution of this work is the formalization of the relationship between the discount factor $\beta$ and the system's "mixing time" ($\tau^*$).

  • The $\beta$ Trade-off: A small $\beta$ leads to a highly accurate approximation (low bias) but requires a massive amount of data to overcome high variance (estimation error). Conversely, a larger $\beta$ converges quickly with less data but introduces a larger permanent bias in the gradient direction.
  • Mixing Time: Both error bounds are heavily dependent on the mixing time of the underlying Markov chain. If a system takes a long time to reach a steady state, the errors will be significantly higher, requiring longer sample paths for accurate estimation.
  • Single-Path Reliability: The analysis confirms that a single, sufficiently long trajectory is theoretically sufficient to guarantee a valid policy update, even in Partially Observable SMDPs (POSMDPs) where the controller only sees noisy observations of the state.

Conclusion and Limitations

This paper establishes that the GSMDP algorithm is both predictable and reliable for continuous-time control problems. However, several challenges remain for practical implementation. The derived error bounds rely on constants like mixing times and spectral gaps, which are often difficult to calculate for high-dimensional, real-world systems. Additionally, the current analysis assumes a standard linear parameterization; future research is needed to determine how these bounds behave when integrated with non-linear function approximators like Deep Neural Networks or in non-stationary environments where system dynamics change over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

In [1] and [2] we have presented a simulation-based algorithm for optimizing the average reward in a parameterized continuous-time, finite-state semi-Markov Decision Process (SMDP). We approximated the gradient of the average reward. Then, a simulation-based algorithm was proposed to estimate the approximate gradient of the average reward (called GSMDP), using only a single sample path of the underlying Markov chain. GSMDP was proved to converge with probability 1. In this paper, we give bounds on the approximation and estimation errors for GSMDP algorithm. The approximation error of that approximation is the size of the difference between the true gradient and the approximate gradient. The estimation error, the size of the difference between the output of the algorithm and its asymptotic output, arises because the algorithm sees only a finite data sequence.
BibTeX
@article{vien2010policy,
  author = {Ngo Anh Vien and SeungGwan Lee and TaeChoong Chung},
  title = {{Policy Gradient Based Semi-Markov Decision Problems: Approximation and Estimation Errors}},
  journal = {IEICE Trans. Information and Systems},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=tAZRD8C87O8},
}
Figure