Polarization Perspectives on Hercules X-1: Further Constraining the Geometry

Qingchang Zhao, Hancheng Li, Lian Tao, Hua Feng, Shuang‐Nan Zhang, R. Walter, Mingyu Ge, Hao Tong, Long Ji, Liang Zhang, Jin‐Lu Qu, Yue Huang, Xiang Ma, Qian-Qing Yin, H. X. Yin, Ruican Ma, Shujie Zhao, Panping Li, Zi-Xu Yang, Hexin Liu, Wei Yu, Yiming Huang, Zexi Li, Yajun Li, Jingyu Xiao, Kang ZhaoarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the accreting X-ray pulsar, Hercules X-1, utilizing data from IXPE and NuSTAR. IXPE performed five observations of Her X-1, consisting of three in the Main-on state and two in the Short-on state. Our time-resolved analysis uncovers the linear correlations between the flux and polarization degree as well as the pulse fraction and polarization degree. Geometry parameters are rigorously constrained by fitting the phase-resolved modulations of Cyclotron Resonance Scattering Feature and polarization angle with a simple dipole model and Rotating Vector Model respectively, yielding roughly consistent results. The changes of $\chi_{\rm p}$ (the position angle of the pulsar's spin axis on the plane of the sky) between different Main-on observations suggest the possible forced precession of the neutron star crust. Furthermore, a linear association between the energy of Cyclotron Resonance Scattering Feature and polarization angle implies the prevalence of a dominant dipole magnetic field, and their phase-resolved modulations likely arise from viewing angle effects.

Introduction

Hercules X-1 (Her X-1) is a prototypical accreting X-ray pulsar, featuring a neutron star with an intense magnetic field ($\sim 10^{12}$ G) capturing material from its companion, HZ Her. A defining characteristic of this system is its 35-day super-orbital cycle, during which the X-ray flux alternates between "Main-on" and "Short-on" states. The mechanism driving this cycle—whether it be a warped, precessing accretion disk or the free/forced precession of the neutron star itself—has been a subject of long-standing debate. This study leverages the novel capabilities of X-ray polarimetry from the Imaging X-ray Polarimetry Explorer (IXPE) alongside spectroscopy from NuSTAR to provide new geometric constraints and probe the underlying physics of the pulsar's emission.

Methodology

The research team employed a multi-faceted observational approach:

  • X-ray Polarimetry: IXPE data provided measurements of the Polarization Degree (PD) and Polarization Angle (PA). These were analyzed using the Rotating Vector Model (RVM) to determine the orientation of the pulsar’s spin axis and magnetic poles.
  • X-ray Spectroscopy: NuSTAR observations allowed for the characterization of the Cyclotron Resonance Scattering Feature (CRSF), a spectral dip caused by resonant absorption by electrons in the quantized energy levels of the magnetic field.
  • Geometric Modeling: By comparing the geometry derived from RVM fits of the PA with a dipole model fit of the CRSF phase-resolved modulation, the researchers sought a self-consistent picture of the pulsar's orientation.

Key Insights and Correlations

A primary discovery of this work is the significant anti-correlation between the Polarization Degree (PD) and both the X-ray flux and the pulse fraction (PF). As the pulsar enters its brighter Main-on state or as the pulses become more prominent, the observed polarization decreases. This suggests that the core of the emission beam is less polarized, potentially due to vacuum birefringence or complex atmospheric effects within the accretion column.

Correlations between Polarization Degree (PD), Polarization Angle (PA), Flux, and Pulse Fraction (PF) across different observation states.

The study also found a linear relationship between the energy of the CRSF and the polarization angle. This correlation strongly supports a model where the magnetic field is dominated by a clean dipole structure, and the observed phase-dependent variations are primarily viewing angle effects as the pulsar rotates.

Evidence for Forced Precession

The analysis revealed that the position angle of the pulsar’s spin axis on the sky ($\chi_p$) shifted by approximately $5.4^\circ$ between different Main-on observations. Such a variation is a hallmark of forced precession, suggesting that the neutron star's crust is undergoing a "wobble" induced by external torques, likely from the accretion disk.

Polarization states in the Q/I vs U/I plane for the five IXPE observations, showing distinct clusters for Main-on and Short-on states.

Results and Geometric Constraints

The integration of polarimetric and spectral data allowed for tight constraints on the pulsar's geometry:

  • Magnetic Obliquity ($\theta$): Estimated between $10^\circ$ and $14^\circ$.
  • Pulsar Inclination ($i_p$): Constrained to a range of $34^\circ$ to $79^\circ$.
  • Polarization Levels: PD was notably higher during the Short-on state (11–26%) compared to the Main-on state (7–19%).

Conclusion

By combining IXPE’s polarimetric "window" with traditional spectroscopy, this study provides compelling evidence for the forced precession of Hercules X-1 and clarifies its magnetic geometry. While limitations such as non-simultaneous data and low statistics in the Short-on state remain, future missions like eXTP are expected to refine these measurements further, offering even deeper insights into the extreme physics of accreting neutron stars.

Reference: Zhao, Q. C., et al. (2024). "Polarization Perspectives on Hercules X–1: Further Constraining the Geometry." MNRAS. arXiv:2405.00509v1.

Summary updated

Abstract

We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the accreting X-ray pulsar, Hercules X-1, utilizing data from IXPE and NuSTAR. IXPE performed five observations of Her X-1, consisting of three in the Main-on state and two in the Short-on state. Our time-resolved analysis uncovers the linear correlations between the flux and polarization degree as well as the pulse fraction and polarization degree. Geometry parameters are rigorously constrained by fitting the phase-resolved modulations of Cyclotron Resonance Scattering Feature and polarization angle with a simple dipole model and Rotating Vector Model respectively, yielding roughly consistent results. The changes of $χ_{\rm p}$ (the position angle of the pulsar's spin axis on the plane of the sky) between different Main-on observations suggest the possible forced precession of the neutron star crust. Furthermore, a linear association between the energy of Cyclotron Resonance Scattering Feature and polarization angle implies the prevalence of a dominant dipole magnetic field, and their phase-resolved modulations likely arise from viewing angle effects.
BibTeX
@misc{zhao2024polarization,
  author = {Qingchang Zhao and Hancheng Li and Lian Tao and Hua Feng and Shuang‐Nan Zhang and R. Walter and Mingyu Ge and Hao Tong and Long Ji and Liang Zhang and Jin‐Lu Qu and Yue Huang and Xiang Ma and Shu Zhang and Qian-Qing Yin and H. X. Yin and Ruican Ma and Shujie Zhao and Panping Li and Zi-Xu Yang and Hexin Liu and Wei Yu and Yiming Huang and Zexi Li and Yajun Li and Jingyu Xiao and Kang Zhao},
  title = {{Polarization Perspectives on Hercules X-1: Further Constraining the Geometry}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.00509},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00509},
}
Figure