Polarizable Water Potential Derived from a Model Electron Density

Joshua A. Rackers, Roseane R. Silva, Zhi Wang, Jay W. PonderJournal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A new empirical potential for efficient, large scale molecular dynamics simulation of water is presented. The HIPPO (Hydrogen-like Intermolecular Polarizable POtential) force field is based upon the model electron density of a hydrogen-like atom. This framework is used to derive and parametrize individual terms describing charge penetration damped permanent electrostatics, damped polarization, charge transfer, anisotropic Pauli repulsion, and damped dispersion interactions. Initial parameter values were fit to Symmetry Adapted Perturbation Theory (SAPT) energy components for ten water dimer configurations, as well as the radial and angular dependence of the canonical dimer. The SAPT-based parameters were then systematically refined to extend the treatment to water bulk phases. The final HIPPO water model provides a balanced representation of a wide variety of properties of gas phase clusters, liquid water, and ice polymorphs, across a range of temperatures and pressures. This water potential yields a rationalization of water structure, dynamics, and thermodynamics explicitly correlated with an ab initio energy decomposition, while providing a level of accuracy comparable or superior to previous polarizable atomic multipole force fields. The HIPPO water model serves as a cornerstone around which similarly detailed physics-based models can be developed for additional molecular species.

Introduction

Simulating water remains a "grand challenge" in computational chemistry. Traditional molecular dynamics (MD) models, such as TIP3P, typically treat atoms as point charges. While computationally efficient, these models rely on significant error cancellation and fail to capture essential short-range physics, most notably charge penetration—the effect where electron clouds overlap at short distances. Consequently, such models often struggle to maintain accuracy across diverse temperatures, pressures, and phases.

Even advanced polarizable models like AMOEBA utilize multipole approximations that remain essentially point-like. To address these limitations, the HIPPO (Hydrogen-like Intermolecular Polarizable POtential) framework was developed to ground empirical force fields in quantum mechanical reality while maintaining the efficiency required for large-scale biological simulations.

The HIPPO Model: A Density-Based Approach

The fundamental innovation of HIPPO is the representation of atoms as overlapping electron densities rather than discrete points. Every atom is modeled with a core point charge and a valence electron density based on a hydrogen-like atom.

The model electron density of a hydrogen-like atom serves as the physical foundation for the HIPPO potential.

From this density-based foundation, four primary energy terms are derived:

  1. Electrostatics: Naturally incorporates charge penetration damping.
  2. Induction: Integrates standard polarization with a pairwise charge-transfer function.
  3. Dispersion: Employs a damped functional form derived directly from the model density.
  4. Pauli Repulsion: Modeled as anisotropic (direction-dependent), utilizing the same multipole moments as the electrostatic term.

The parameterization process involved three rigorous stages: fitting to Symmetry Adapted Perturbation Theory (SAPT) data for dimers, a global genetic algorithm search for bulk liquid properties, and final refinement via ForceBalance to match experimental data across a wide range of thermodynamic states.

Key Physical Insights

A central theme of this work is that "density is destiny." By starting with a continuous electron density, the "charge penetration" problem is resolved by the model's inherent physics rather than ad-hoc damping functions.

Furthermore, the research highlights the critical role of anisotropic repulsion. While most force fields treat atoms as isotropic "hard spheres," HIPPO demonstrates that the directionality of electron density is as vital for repulsion as it is for electrostatics. This insight proved essential for correctly predicting the "flap angle" of the water dimer, a subtle structural detail often missed by simpler models.

Results and Validation

HIPPO demonstrates exceptional accuracy across multiple scales:

  • Gas Phase: For water dimers, the model achieved a root mean square energy difference of only 0.129 kcal/mol compared to "gold standard" CCSD(T) calculations.
  • Bulk Liquid: The model reproduces liquid density with less than 0.1% error and the heat of vaporization within 0.4%.
  • Phase Versatility: HIPPO accurately predicts properties for ten different ice polymorphs, with lattice energies within 3% of experimental values.

Despite its increased physical complexity, HIPPO remains computationally efficient. Optimized implementations are estimated to be up to 25% faster than current industry standards like AMOEBA.

Conclusion

While HIPPO is a classical model and thus does not explicitly account for nuclear quantum effects (leading to slight overestimations in heat capacity), it represents a significant step forward in physics-based modeling. By bridging the gap between first-principles accuracy and empirical efficiency, HIPPO serves as a cornerstone for future force fields encompassing ions, organic molecules, and complex proteins.

Summary updated

Abstract

A new empirical potential for efficient, large scale molecular dynamics simulation of water is presented. The HIPPO (Hydrogen-like Intermolecular Polarizable POtential) force field is based upon the model electron density of a hydrogen-like atom. This framework is used to derive and parametrize individual terms describing charge penetration damped permanent electrostatics, damped polarization, charge transfer, anisotropic Pauli repulsion, and damped dispersion interactions. Initial parameter values were fit to Symmetry Adapted Perturbation Theory (SAPT) energy components for ten water dimer configurations, as well as the radial and angular dependence of the canonical dimer. The SAPT-based parameters were then systematically refined to extend the treatment to water bulk phases. The final HIPPO water model provides a balanced representation of a wide variety of properties of gas phase clusters, liquid water, and ice polymorphs, across a range of temperatures and pressures. This water potential yields a rationalization of water structure, dynamics, and thermodynamics explicitly correlated with an <i>ab initio</i> energy decomposition, while providing a level of accuracy comparable or superior to previous polarizable atomic multipole force fields. The HIPPO water model serves as a cornerstone around which similarly detailed physics-based models can be developed for additional molecular species.
BibTeX
@article{rackers2021polarizable,
  author = {Joshua A. Rackers and Roseane R. Silva and Zhi Wang and Jay W. Ponder},
  title = {{Polarizable Water Potential Derived from a Model Electron Density}},
  journal = {Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jctc.1c00628},
}
Figure