Pocket Certificates using Double Encryption: A Survey

Ajay Kumar, Umarani ChellapandyInternational Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes "Pocket Certificates," a secure digital vault for essential documents like passports and birth certificates. By implementing a double-encryption scheme—combining the Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) and Triple DES (3DES)—the authors aim to provide a robust mobile storage solution that protects sensitive personal data from both physical theft and digital hacking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite the digital revolution, over 70% of people still rely heavily on physical documents. This reliance creates significant overhead in terms of storage, manual audits, and the risk of physical loss or forgery. While moving to digital storage solves some of these issues, it introduces new vulnerabilities: digital theft, unauthorized replication, and server-side hacking.

The authors identify a gap in current mobile storage: most users either carry physical copies (risky) or store unencrypted digital copies on their phones (equally risky if the phone is stolen). The "Pocket Certificates" system is designed to bridge this gap by providing a secure, encrypted "pocket" for digital versions of government-issued IDs and certificates.

Methods

The core of the proposed system is a Double Encryption architecture. Instead of relying on a single cryptographic standard, the system layers two distinct algorithms:

  1. AES (Advanced Encryption Standard): Used for its efficiency and high security. The paper details the AES process, including its 128-bit block size and the four-stage rounds (SubBytes, ShiftRows, MixColumns, and AddRoundKeys).
  2. 3DES (Triple Data Encryption Standard): Applied in tandem with AES. While 3DES is slower than AES, its triple-layered Feistel structure adds a significant barrier against brute-force attacks.

Beyond document encryption, the system incorporates several modern web and security practices:

  • bcrypt: A password-hashing function used to securely store user login credentials.
  • Passport Middleware: Utilized for managing specific user authentication needs at different stages of the application.
  • Secure PIN: A secondary layer of authentication required to access the encrypted files, ensuring that even if a device is unlocked, the sensitive documents remain inaccessible.
  • SQL Backend: Used to manage the structured data and user profiles.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As this paper functions primarily as a system proposal and a survey of existing cryptographic techniques, it does not utilize or benchmark against specific external datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Security-Usability Trade-off: The authors acknowledge that adding layers of encryption (like 3DES) can impact system performance and "smooth operation." The insight here is the intentional "trade-off"—accepting a slight decrease in speed to achieve a massive increase in the computational cost for an attacker to crack the files.
  • The CIA Triad: The system is built around the "CIA trinity": Confidentiality (secrecy), Integrity (ensuring data isn't tampered with), and Availability (ensuring the user can access their documents when needed).
  • Internal Memory Storage: To mitigate the risks of server-side hacking, the system is designed to save submitted documents in an encrypted form directly within the device's internal memory rather than relying solely on a vulnerable cloud server.
  • Layered Authentication: By combining a login (password hashed with bcrypt) with a specific "Secure PIN" for file access, the system creates a "defense in depth" strategy.

Key Results

The paper is a conceptual framework and survey rather than an empirical study with quantitative benchmarks. However, the qualitative results include:

  • Enhanced Brute-Force Resistance: By using multiple encryption levels, the authors conclude that assailants would require significantly more storage and time to execute comparison-list or brute-force attacks.
  • System Architecture: The authors successfully mapped out an E-R (Entity-Relationship) diagram for a "Pocket Certificates" application that manages citizens, their documents, and feedback loops.
  • Verification of Identity: The integration of the "passport" function and "crypt" functions ensures that user identity is verified and passwords are never stored in plain text.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors candidly note that multiple encryptions may slow down the system's speed. This performance hit is the primary technical hurdle for the proposed double-encryption model.

For future iterations, the authors suggest:

  • Demand Balancing: Restricting server load to administrative access periods to ensure stability.
  • UI/UX Improvements: Making the website and application more "user-friendly" to encourage adoption among non-technical users.
  • Maintenance Optimization: Refining the code to ensure the "Pocket Certificates" system remains simple to maintain without high overhead costs.
  • Eliminating Physical Records: The ultimate goal is to reach a point where storing data in physical record books or unencrypted spreadsheets becomes obsolete.

Summary updated

Abstract

Documents are items that convey information, can be used to certify someone, or can constitute a legal report. Theft of such crucial documents/certificates can obstruct or hinder an individual's or organization's ability to execute their work effectively, as well as result in the loss of personal belongings. "Pocket Certificates" - a traditional document archive with the possibility of securely preserving such papers - is provided in this text. The answer is to utilise a Double Encryption system that combines the AES and 3DES encryption standards. The use of improved security can be considered of as a tradeoff in a system's stability and smooth operation, however there are specific limitations that must be imposed so that the Encryption/Decryption process does not obstruct usability. This work considers such characteristics and strikes a balance between them all. Other Hashing methods are also used, such as bycrypt for securely storing user login data and passport middleware for each application stage's specific user authentication needs. The paper comprises of a comprehensive online application for the safe archiving of essential documents or data. Keywords: 3DES, AES, Cryptography, Decryption, Encryption
BibTeX
@article{kumar2022pocket,
  author = {Ajay Kumar and Umarani Chellapandy},
  title = {{Pocket Certificates using Double Encryption: A Survey}},
  journal = {International Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.22214/ijraset.2022.41090},
}
Figure