PNP: A Review Framework towards Efficient NeRF Study and Research

Jin Qi Yeo, Aik Beng Ng, Kan Chen, Pallavi Mohan, Frank Guan, Simon SeeAAAI 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Rapid advancements in techniques and applications of NeRF technologies have been seen in both academia and industry recently. It becomes apparent that there is a need to consolidate and organize the theoretical and practical knowledge on the end to end pipeline of using NeRF technology. To facilitate the study and research on NeRF technologies, we propose a novel framework that identifies the key stages for NeRF related technology, namely: Pre-NeRF, NeRF, Post-NeRF, or "PNP" in short. Each stage has four attributes: A description of what and how NeRF technology is adapted at that stage, the common challenges faced, software that is used to handle the tasks, and how it is applicable to the next stage in the framework.

Introduction

Since its debut in 2020, Neural Radiance Fields (NeRF) technology has transitioned rapidly from an academic curiosity to a cornerstone of industry applications in film, gaming, and robotics. However, the ecosystem remains overwhelming for newcomers. While existing surveys focus on mathematical variations of neural networks, there is a distinct lack of literature addressing the practical, end-to-end workflow. The "PNP" framework addresses this gap by organizing the NeRF lifecycle into three logical stages: Pre-NeRF, NeRF, and Post-NeRF.

The PNP Framework

The core contribution of this work is the decomposition of the NeRF process into three sequential stages. Each stage is analyzed through four attributes: Overview, Challenges, Toolkits, and Applications.

Summary of the PNP framework stages, challenges, and toolkits.

Stage 1: Pre-NeRF (Data Acquisition & Preprocessing)

This stage focuses on photogrammetry—the process of capturing 2D images to reconstruct 3D space. The primary goal is to recover 5D coordinates (position and orientation) for each camera pose. Key challenges include determining the optimal number of images and ensuring high image resolution while filtering out blurry captures. The quality of the final 3D scene is often determined before training even begins in this stage.

Stage 2: NeRF (Training & Optimization)

In this stage, a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) learns the scene by predicting color and density along camera rays. Volume rendering is then used to synthesize new views. The main challenge here is accelerating training speed, which has been significantly addressed by modern toolkits like InstantNGP.

Stage 3: Post-NeRF (Rendering & Integration)

Once trained, the NeRF model must be rendered and integrated into production environments. This involves exporting the model into formats like meshes or point clouds for use in external software like Blender or Unreal Engine. Achieving real-time rendering remains a primary hurdle in this phase.

Practical Implementation and Toolkits

The framework highlights specific toolkits that have become industry standards. For Pre-NeRF tasks, tools like COLMAP, KIRI Engine, and Reality Capture are essential for pose estimation. For the training phase, InstantNGP offers unprecedented speed, while NeRFStudio provides a modular environment for research. Finally, Post-NeRF integration is supported by platforms like NVIDIA Omniverse and game engines.

Data Acquisition and Metrics

Beyond standard benchmarks like LLFF and Tanks and Temples, the paper emphasizes custom data collection. Effective NeRF creation requires following specific "rules of thumb," such as maintaining a 2/3 overlap between images and following structured trajectory paths rather than just pivoting the camera from a single point.

To evaluate the resulting quality, the industry relies on the "Big Three" metrics:

  • PSNR (Peak Signal to Noise Ratio): Measures reconstruction quality.
  • SSIM (Structural Similarity Index): Evaluates perceived structural integrity.
  • LPIPS (Learned Perceptual Image Patch Similarity): Uses deep features to judge visual similarity.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite rapid progress, several limitations persist. Most NeRF implementations assume static scenes, struggling with dynamic objects. Additionally, high-quality rendering still demands significant GPU resources, and "floaters" (cloudy artifacts in empty space) remain difficult to eliminate automatically.

Future research is trending toward the integration of text-conditioned diffusion models (Generative AI) to create NeRFs from prompts and developing better appearance embeddings to allow for post-capture lighting and weather adjustments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rapid advancements in techniques and applications of NeRF technologies have been seen in both academia and industry recently. It becomes apparent that there is a need to consolidate and organize the theoretical and practical knowledge on the end to end pipeline of using NeRF technology. To facilitate the study and research on NeRF technologies, we propose a novel framework that identifies the key stages for NeRF related technology, namely: Pre-NeRF, NeRF, Post-NeRF, or ``PNP" in short. Each stage has four attributes: A description of what and how NeRF technology is adapted at that stage, the common challenges faced, software that is used to handle the tasks, and how it is applicable to the next stage in the framework.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yeo2023pnp,
  author = {Jin Qi Yeo and Aik Beng Ng and Kan Chen and Pallavi Mohan and Frank Guan and Simon See},
  title = {{PNP: A Review Framework towards Efficient NeRF Study and Research}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1609/aaaiss.v1i1.27473},
}
Figure