Plug-and-play and coordinated control for bus-connected AC islanded microgrids

Stefano Riverso, Michele Tucci, Juan C. Vasquez, Josep M. Guerrero, Giancarlo Ferrari-TrecatearXiv 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel distributed control architecture for AC islanded microgrids that allows for seamless "plug-and-play" integration and removal of distributed generation units while maintaining grid stability. The system enhances existing plug-and-play methods with virtual impedance and coordinated secondary control to ensure voltage tracking and reactive power sharing, validated through extensive experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Islanded microgrids (ImGs) are crucial for reliable power supply in remote areas or as a backup for the main grid. A key challenge in ImGs is scalability: how to add or remove distributed generation units (like solar panels or wind turbines) without disrupting the grid's voltage and frequency stability. Traditional control methods often require a global model of the entire microgrid, which is impractical for dynamic systems. Furthermore, existing plug-and-play (PnP) approaches were primarily designed for "load-connected" topologies, where each generator has its own dedicated load. However, many real-world microgrids use "bus-connected" topologies, where multiple generators supply a common load bus. This paper addresses the need for a robust, decentralized PnP control strategy that works for bus-connected microgrids and also incorporates advanced features for better performance.

Methods

The paper builds upon a previously developed PnP control framework that uses convex optimization to design local controllers. This approach ensures stability by only requiring knowledge of local parameters and neighboring line impedances, avoiding the need for a global microgrid model.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Bus-Connected Topology Adaptation: The authors devise a method to map bus-connected microgrid topologies into equivalent load-connected ones, allowing the existing PnP control design to be applied.
  • Virtual Impedance Loops: Local virtual impedance loops are integrated into the primary PnP controllers. This technique helps to mitigate circulating currents between generators and allows for better control over the output impedance of the voltage-source converters (VSCs).
  • Distributed Secondary Control: A distributed secondary control layer is introduced. This layer focuses on two main objectives:
  • Voltage Tracking at the Point of Common Coupling (PCC): It ensures the voltage at the common load bus is maintained at a desired reference level, even with varying loads.
  • Reactive Power Sharing: It coordinates the reactive power injection from each generator to ensure equitable distribution.
  • Convex Optimization for PnP: The core of the PnP design relies on solving Linear Matrix Inequality (LMI) optimization problems. When a unit wants to connect or disconnect, its local controller and those of its neighbors are re-tuned by solving these problems, ensuring stability is preserved.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental validation using a custom-built microgrid testbed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decentralization is Key for Scalability: The paper strongly advocates for decentralized control, where each generator has its own controller, as the most practical approach for achieving plug-and-play capabilities in microgrids.
  • Topology Transformation is Feasible: The ability to transform a bus-connected topology into an equivalent load-connected one is a significant enabler for applying existing PnP control strategies to a wider range of microgrid configurations.
  • Virtual Impedance Enhances Robustness: Adding virtual impedance to the primary control layer is shown to be effective in improving the performance and robustness of the microgrid, particularly in managing interactions between generators.
  • Secondary Control Complements Primary Control: The research demonstrates that a distributed secondary control layer can effectively enhance the primary PnP control by providing voltage tracking and reactive power sharing, without compromising the stability achieved by the primary layer.
  • PnP is Inertia-less: Unlike traditional droop controllers that rely on inertia, the PnP approach allows for faster transient responses when loads change or generators are added/removed.

Key Results

The paper presents extensive experimental validation on a three-generator bus-connected microgrid testbed. Key results include:

  • Stable Plug-and-Play Operation: The system successfully demonstrated the addition and removal of generators without causing significant disturbances to voltage or frequency. Transients during these events were minimal.
  • Effective Voltage Regulation: The primary PnP controllers, enhanced with virtual impedance, showed good voltage regulation at the PCCs under various load conditions, including linear, unbalanced, and nonlinear loads.
  • Successful Secondary Control Implementation: The coordinated secondary control layer effectively achieved voltage tracking at the load bus and balanced reactive power sharing among the generators, as evidenced by experimental results.
  • Harmonic Distortion and Imbalance: Experiments showed that the proposed controllers kept harmonic distortion and imbalance ratios within acceptable limits, even with nonlinear loads.
  • Fast Transient Response: The PnP controllers exhibited faster transient responses compared to inertia-based methods when load conditions changed.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Communication Network: The current implementation of the secondary control layer assumes a fully connected communication network for broadcasting measurements (e.g., voltages and currents) to all DGUs for averaging. This is a limitation for large-scale systems.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest distributing these computations by exploiting only partial communication among DGUs and using consensus-like protocols for estimating global variables. This would make the system more scalable and robust to communication failures. They also mention that the current work focuses on AC microgrids and future research could extend to DC or hybrid AC/DC microgrids.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a distributed control architecture for voltage and frequency stabilization in AC islanded microgrids. In the primary control layer, each generation unit is equipped with a local controller acting on the corresponding voltage-source converter. Following the plug-and-play design approach previously proposed by some of the authors, whenever the addition/removal of a distributed generation unit is required, feasibility of the operation is automatically checked by designing local controllers through convex optimization. The update of the voltage-control layer, when units plug -in/-out, is therefore automatized and stability of the microgrid is always preserved. Moreover, local control design is based only on the knowledge of parameters of power lines and it does not require to store a global microgrid model. In this work, we focus on bus-connected microgrid topologies and enhance the primary plug-and-play layer with local virtual impedance loops and secondary coordinated controllers ensuring bus voltage tracking and reactive power sharing. In particular, the secondary control architecture is distributed, hence mirroring the modularity of the primary control layer. We validate primary and secondary controllers by performing experiments with balanced, unbalanced and nonlinear loads, on a setup composed of three bus-connected distributed generation units. Most importantly, the stability of the microgrid after the addition/removal of distributed generation units is assessed. Overall, the experimental results show the feasibility of the proposed modular control design framework, where generation units can be added/removed on the fly, thus enabling the deployment of virtual power plants that can be resized over time.
BibTeX
@misc{riverso2017plug,
  author = {Stefano Riverso and Michele Tucci and Juan C. Vasquez and Josep M. Guerrero and Giancarlo Ferrari-Trecate},
  title = {{Plug-and-play and coordinated control for bus-connected AC islanded microgrids}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1703.10222},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.10222},
}

Loading related content...

Figure