Plating versus elastic stable intramedullary nailing for displaced pediatric midshaft clavicular fractures

Hong Pan, Ruikang Liu, Saroj Rai, Renhao Ze, Xin Tang, Jin LiJournal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology 2022 · DOI

This study, published in the Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, compares two surgical interventions for displaced midshaft clavicle (collarbone) fractures in adolescents: traditional plate fixation and Elastic Stable Intramedullary Nailing (ESIN). While both methods yield excellent functional results, the researchers found that ESIN offers significant advantages in terms of operative efficiency, hospital stay duration, and cosmetic outcomes.

TL;DR

For teenagers requiring surgery for a broken collarbone, flexible internal nails (ESIN) are just as effective as traditional plates but result in significantly shorter surgeries, smaller scars, and easier hardware removal. While conservative treatment remains the gold standard, ESIN is the superior surgical choice for active adolescents needing a fast recovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clavicle fractures are incredibly common in children, representing up to 15% of all pediatric fractures. Historically, these were almost always treated non-operatively (with a sling) because children have immense "remodeling potential"—their bones straighten out as they grow.

However, for older adolescents (ages 10–14) with "displaced" fractures (where the bone ends don't line up), there is a growing trend toward surgery to ensure faster functional recovery and avoid permanent shortening of the bone. The "gold standard" has been plating, which involves a large incision and screws. ESIN is a newer, minimally invasive alternative where a flexible titanium nail is threaded through the center of the bone. This paper seeks to determine if one method is objectively better than the other in this specific age group.

Methods

The authors conducted a retrospective observational study of 73 patients (aged 10–14) treated at a single center between 2014 and 2018.

  • The Groups: 45 patients received ESIN and 28 received plate fixation.
  • The Techniques:
    • Plating: Required a 4–7 cm incision and a plate secured with 6–8 screws.
  • ESIN: Used a "mini-incision" (1.5–3.0 cm) to insert a single flexible nail (2.5–3.5 mm diameter) into the medullary canal.
  • Evaluation: Patients were followed for at least 24 months. Outcomes were measured using the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score for function and the Scar Cosmesis Assessment and Rating (SCAR) scale for aesthetics.

Datasets

The study utilized a retrospective clinical dataset from the hospital database of Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College in Wuhan, China. It included preoperative baseline data, perioperative metrics (surgery time, blood loss), and postoperative follow-up data (complications, functional scores).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Functional Parity: The most important finding is that at the end of the recovery period, there was no statistical difference in shoulder function between the two groups. Both methods work well for fixing the bone.
  • The "Scar Factor": In pediatric surgery, cosmetic outcomes are a major concern for parents and patients. The plate group had a 71.4% rate of "cosmetic concern" compared to just 22.2% in the ESIN group.
  • Surgical Efficiency: ESIN is nearly twice as fast to perform. This reduces anesthesia time, which is a key safety consideration in pediatric populations.
  • Hardware Removal: In children, hardware is almost always removed after the bone heals. The authors noted that removing an ESIN nail is significantly easier and less invasive than removing a large plate and multiple screws.

Key Results

The study found statistically significant ($P < 0.001$) advantages for the ESIN group in several perioperative categories:

  • Operative Time: 31.1 minutes (ESIN) vs. 59.8 minutes (Plate).
  • Hospital Stay: 1.5 days (ESIN) vs. 2.5 days (Plate).
  • Incision Length: 2.4 cm (ESIN) vs. 5.4 cm (Plate).
  • Aesthetics: SCAR scores were significantly lower (better) for ESIN at all time points.
  • Complications: Two patients in the plate group suffered a refracture after the plate was removed; zero refractures occurred in the ESIN group. However, ESIN had a slightly higher (though not statistically significant) rate of "implant prominence," where the end of the nail can be felt under the skin.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Design: This was not a randomized controlled trial; surgeons chose the method based on their own preference, which introduces allocation bias.
  • Sample Size: With only 73 patients, the study may be underpowered to detect rare complications.
  • Radiographic Analysis: Specific details like the exact degree of initial bone angulation or displacement were not analyzed in depth.

The authors conclude that while non-operative care should still be the first choice for most pediatric fractures, ESIN should be the preferred surgical method for displaced midshaft fractures in adolescents due to its minimally invasive nature and superior cosmetic results. Future work should involve larger, multi-center randomized trials to confirm these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

III, retrospective observational study.
BibTeX
@article{pan2022plating,
  author = {Hong Pan and Ruikang Liu and Saroj Rai and Renhao Ze and Xin Tang and Jin Li},
  title = {{Plating versus elastic stable intramedullary nailing for displaced pediatric midshaft clavicular fractures}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s10195-022-00659-2},
}
Figure