Plasticity in antiparasite behaviours and its suggested role in invasion biology

David Hughes, Sylvia CremerAnimal 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes that the ability of invasive species to "switch off" costly antiparasite behaviors when in a new, parasite-poor environment is a crucial factor in their success. This behavioral plasticity allows them to reallocate resources to growth and reproduction, outcompeting native species.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Invasive species pose a significant threat to biodiversity and economies worldwide. While the "enemy release hypothesis" (ERH) suggests that invaders succeed because they escape their native predators and parasites, this alone doesn't explain why some introduced species become invasive pests while others don't. The authors aim to bridge this gap by exploring the role of behavioral plasticity in antiparasite defense as a key trait contributing to invasion success, particularly in the context of ERH. They question whether the ability to adaptively adjust these behaviors, rather than just the absence of enemies, is the critical factor.

Methods

This paper is primarily a theoretical review and hypothesis-building work, not an empirical study with novel methods. The authors synthesize existing literature on:

  • Antiparasite behaviors: Reviewing the diversity, effectiveness, and costs of various behaviors animals use to avoid or combat parasites (e.g., grooming, habitat shifting, self-medication).
  • Invasion biology: Examining factors contributing to the success of invasive species, particularly the ERH and the concept of "evolution of increased competitive ability" (EICA).
  • Phenotypic plasticity: Discussing the concept of organisms altering their traits in response to environmental changes.

They use these existing bodies of knowledge to formulate and argue for their central hypothesis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical review and does not present new empirical data or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Behavioral plasticity as a "switch": The core idea is that invasive species that can plastically reduce or "switch off" expensive antiparasite behaviors in a new environment (where parasites are scarce) gain a significant competitive advantage.
  • Cost of defense: Antiparasite behaviors are effective but energetically costly. This cost is a crucial element; if the threat (parasites) is removed, maintaining these behaviors is maladaptive.
  • Behavior as the most flexible defense: Among the various defense mechanisms (behavioral, morphological, biochemical, immunological), behavior is the most rapidly and flexibly adjustable, making it a prime candidate for plasticity-driven advantage.
  • Invertebrates as a potential focus: The authors suggest that behavioral plasticity might be particularly important for invertebrate invaders, as they often rely on costly innate immunity, making behavioral adjustments even more critical.
  • "Evolutionary pacemaker": Behavior is described as the "evolutionary pacemaker," implying its rapid adjustability allows for quicker adaptation and potentially drives evolutionary change.

Key Results

This paper does not present quantitative results from new experiments. Instead, it offers a conceptual framework and a testable hypothesis. The "results" are the logical deductions drawn from synthesizing existing research:

  • Antiparasite behaviors are demonstrably effective and costly.
  • Behavioral plasticity in antiparasite defense occurs in native ranges.
  • Behavioral plasticity is a known trait associated with successful invaders (e.g., birds with larger brains, ants with flexible social structures).
  • Therefore, the authors hypothesize that plasticity in antiparasite behavior is a defining trait of successful invaders.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of direct empirical evidence: The authors acknowledge that direct studies testing their hypothesis (comparing antiparasite behavior plasticity in native vs. introduced ranges, or invasive vs. non-invasive species) are scarce.
  • Heritability of plasticity: While they suggest plasticity is key, they note that the heritability of this plasticity is crucial for long-term selection in the new environment. The evolutionary timescale and potential selection against plasticity (if it's too costly) are acknowledged as areas needing further investigation.
  • Generalizability: The authors caution that not all host-parasite interactions are equal, and their hypothesis may not apply universally across all taxa or parasite types.
  • Future Work: The authors strongly advocate for comparative studies that investigate antiparasite behavior plasticity in both native and introduced ranges, and between invasive and non-invasive species. This would help identify taxa prone to invasion and inform management strategies. They also call for more research on the costs and efficacy of antiparasite behaviors across diverse species.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{hughes2007plasticity,
  author = {David Hughes and Sylvia Cremer},
  title = {{Plasticity in antiparasite behaviours and its suggested role in invasion biology}},
  booktitle = {Animal},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1016/j.anbehav.2006.12.025},
}
Figure