Plasmonic nanostructure design and characterization via Deep Learning

Itzik Malkiel, Michael Mrejen, Achiya Nagler, Uri Arieli, Lior Wolf, Haim SuchowskiLight 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Deep Learning (DL) approach that revolutionizes the design and characterization of plasmonic nanostructures. By training a bidirectional neural network on synthetic data, the authors demonstrate a method that can rapidly predict nanostructure geometries from their optical responses and vice-versa, overcoming the limitations of traditional iterative design processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing nanophotonic structures, particularly plasmonic ones, to achieve specific optical responses has historically been a laborious, iterative process. This involves guessing a structure, simulating its behavior using computationally intensive methods like solving Maxwell's equations, and then refining the guess based on the results. The "inverse problem"—determining the structure needed for a desired optical response—is even more challenging due to the inherent nonlinearity and complexity. This bottleneck hinders the rapid development of advanced optical elements for applications like sensing, imaging, and spectroscopy.

Methods

The core innovation is a bidirectional Deep Neural Network (DNN) architecture. This network comprises two interconnected components:

  • Geometry-Predicting Network (GPN): This network tackles the inverse problem, predicting the nanostructure's geometry (dimensions, angles) based on its far-field optical response (transmission spectra for different polarizations) and material properties.
  • Spectrum-Predicting Network (SPN): This network handles the direct problem, predicting the optical response spectrum given a nanostructure's geometry and material properties.

The key novelty lies in their bidirectional training strategy. The GPN's output (predicted geometry) is fed into the SPN, which then predicts a spectrum. This predicted spectrum is compared to the desired spectrum, allowing for co-adaptation and improved performance compared to training the GPN and SPN independently. The authors also explored network depth and parallelism, finding that a deep network with parallel group layers offered the best performance.

Datasets

The authors generated a large synthetic dataset for training and evaluation. This dataset consists of over 15,000 experiments, where each experiment includes:

  • A plasmonic nanostructure with a defined geometry.
  • Its material properties (e.g., gold, ITO).
  • The optical response spectrum for both horizontal and vertical polarizations of the incoming field.

This synthetic dataset was generated using COMSOL Multiphysics, a finite element method (FEM) simulation software. The geometries explored were based on an "H" form, allowing for variations in length, angle, and the omission of certain features.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Direct and Inverse Problems: The bidirectional architecture is crucial. It allows the network to learn the complex interplay between geometry and optical response more effectively by forcing the predicted geometry to produce the desired spectrum.
  • "Transfer of Knowledge" in a Generalist Network: Unlike previous approaches that might use multiple specialized networks, this single, generalist network can handle diverse geometries and responses. This suggests a powerful form of knowledge transfer within the DL model.
  • Generalization Beyond Training Data: The DNN demonstrated an impressive ability to generalize, accurately predicting the geometry for a "no nanostructure" case (a flat spectrum) that was not explicitly present in the training data. This indicates true learning of underlying physical principles rather than mere interpolation.
  • Speed and Efficiency: Once trained, the DL model can perform design and characterization tasks in milliseconds, a stark contrast to the hours or days required by traditional iterative methods.

Key Results

  • Accurate Geometry Retrieval: The DNN accurately predicted the dimensions of fabricated gold nanostructures based on their measured transmission spectra, showing excellent agreement with SEM characterization.
  • Improved Performance with Bidirectionality: The bidirectional network achieved a significantly lower Mean Squared Error (MSE) of 0.16 compared to a composite approach (0.37), highlighting the benefit of the integrated training.
  • Optimal Network Architecture: The best performing architecture identified was a network with three parallel group layers followed by eight sequential fully connected join layers.
  • Successful Design for Sensing: The DNN successfully designed plasmonic nanostructures for targeted chemical sensing (e.g., dichloromethane and phthalocyanine dimer), achieving specific spectral resonances for different polarizations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Dependency: The performance of the DNN is inherently tied to the quality and diversity of the training dataset. While extensive, it's still a subset of all possible nanostructures.
  • Fabrication Complexity: The current "H" form geometry is chosen for ease of fabrication. Extending this to more complex or arbitrary geometries might require further dataset generation and network adaptation.
  • Material Properties: While the model accounts for material properties like ITO dispersion, extending it to a wider range of materials or dynamic material changes could be a future direction.
  • Future Applications: The authors suggest that this approach can be extended to other physical and optical parameters of host materials and compounds, opening doors for on-demand design in sensing, imaging, and integrated spectroscopy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nanophotonics, the field that merges photonics and nanotechnology, has in recent years revolutionized the field of optics by enabling the manipulation of light-matter interactions with subwavelength structures. However, despite the many advances in this field, the design, fabrication and characterization has remained widely an iterative process in which the designer guesses a structure and solves the Maxwell's equations for it. In contrast, the inverse problem, i.e., obtaining a geometry for a desired electromagnetic response, remains a challenging and time-consuming task within the boundaries of very specific assumptions. Here, we experimentally demonstrate that a novel Deep Neural Network trained with thousands of synthetic experiments is not only able to retrieve subwavelength dimensions from solely far-field measurements but is also capable of directly addressing the inverse problem. Our approach allows the rapid design and characterization of metasurface-based optical elements as well as optimal nanostructures for targeted chemicals and biomolecules, which are critical for sensing, imaging and integrated spectroscopy applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{malkiel2018plasmonic,
  author = {Itzik Malkiel and Michael Mrejen and Achiya Nagler and Uri Arieli and Lior Wolf and Haim Suchowski},
  title = {{Plasmonic nanostructure design and characterization via Deep Learning}},
  booktitle = {Light},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41377-018-0060-7},
}
Figure