Plants traditionally used to make Cantonese slow-cooked soup in China

Yujing Liu, Qi Liu, Ping Li, Deke Xing, Huagang Hu, Lin Li, Xuechen Hu, Chunlin LongJournal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides the first comprehensive ethnobotanical documentation of plants used in Cantonese slow-cooked soup (CSCS), a popular dish with significant cultural and medicinal importance in Guangdong, China. By interviewing local residents and restaurant owners, researchers identified 97 plant species and their associated uses, highlighting the rich biocultural heritage embedded in this culinary tradition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cantonese slow-cooked soup (CSCS) is more than just a meal; it's a cornerstone of Cantonese culture, deeply intertwined with traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and perceived as a form of food therapy. Despite its popularity and importance, there was a lack of a systematic, collated record of the diverse plant species used in CSCS, their specific roles, and their cultural significance. This gap hinders a deeper understanding of the biocultural context of CSCS, its potential for modern applications, and the conservation needs of the plants involved. The study aims to fill this void by documenting these plants and their ethnobotanical uses.

Methods

The researchers employed a participatory approach, conducting 111 semi-structured interviews with 63 local residents and 48 soup restaurant owners in Guangdong Province between 2014 and 2017. They gathered information on plant names (local, Chinese, and scientific), parts used, flavors, natures (hot, warm, cool, cold, neutral), preparation methods, habitats, and conservation status. To quantify the importance of each plant, they utilized three indices: Mention Index (QI), Frequency of Use Index (FUI), and Economic Index (EI). These indices were calculated based on informant responses regarding plant mentions, frequency of consumption, and market value. Voucher specimens of wild plants were collected for taxonomic identification.

Datasets

The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated its own dataset through extensive fieldwork and interviews. The primary "dataset" is the compiled ethnobotanical information on 97 plant species, including their various attributes and cultural significance indices, as presented in Table 2.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CSCS as a Biocultural Nexus: The study powerfully illustrates how CSCS acts as a living repository of traditional knowledge, bridging culinary practices with medicinal applications and reflecting the rich biodiversity of Guangdong.
  • Plant Diversity and Usage Patterns: The identification of 97 plant species from 46 families underscores the remarkable diversity of ingredients used. Roots and fruits emerged as the most commonly utilized plant parts, suggesting specific functional or textural contributions to the soup.
  • Medicinal Functions are Key: "Clearing heat" was identified as the most prevalent medicinal function among the plants used, aligning with TCM principles and the hot, humid climate of Guangdong.
  • Conservation Concerns: The identification of six plant species listed on China's "red list" (including critically endangered and endangered species) highlights an urgent need for conservation efforts and the development of sustainable cultivation protocols.
  • Cultural Significance Indices: The QI, FUI, and EI provide a quantitative framework for understanding the relative importance of different plants within the CSCS tradition, revealing which species are most familiar, frequently used, and economically significant.

Key Results

  • A total of 97 plant species belonging to 46 families and 90 genera were documented as being used in CSCS.
  • Roots and fruits were the most commonly used plant parts.
  • Clearing heat was the most frequent medicinal function attributed to the plants.
  • Six species are listed on China's "red list" for conservation concern: two critically endangered, one endangered, and one near-threatened.
  • The Mention Index (QI) ranged from 0.09 to 1, with nine species achieving a QI of 100%.
  • The Frequency of Use Index (FUI) varied between 0.23 and 9.95, with 19.6% of species used more than once a month.
  • The Economic Index (EI) ranged from 0.45 to 6.58, with 89 species showing appreciable economic importance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study represents the first attempt to document CSCS plants, implying that further research is needed to fully capture the breadth of this tradition. They explicitly call for future research on the safety and efficacy of CSCS, as well as on ecological and cultural conservation efforts. This is crucial for the sustainable growth of China's botanical and medicinal plant industry. Additionally, while the study provides valuable insights into the relationships between plant nature, flavor, and function, it notes that no definitive corresponding relationship was found, suggesting that a more comprehensive understanding of these complex interactions is still required. The authors also suggest that the "internal law" of herbs cannot be fully revealed by a single characteristic and requires broader analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an important part of Cantonese culture, CSCS has been popularized as a local cuisine with a healthcare function. CSCS also reflects the plant species richness and cultural diversity of Guangdong Province. Future research on the safety and efficacy of CSCS as well as on ecological and cultural conservation efforts is needed for the sustainable growth of China's botanical and medicinal plant industry.
BibTeX
@article{liu2018plants,
  author = {Yujing Liu and Qi Liu and Ping Li and Deke Xing and Huagang Hu and Lin Li and Xuechen Hu and Chunlin Long},
  title = {{Plants traditionally used to make Cantonese slow-cooked soup in China}},
  journal = {Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1186/s13002-018-0206-y},
}
Figure