Plant diversity stabilizes soil temperature

Yuanyuan Huang, Gideon Stein, Olaf Kolle, Karl Kübler, Ernst‐Detlef Schulze, Hui Dong, David Eichenberg, Gerd Gleixner, Anke Hildebrandt, Markus Lange, Christiane Roscher, Holger Schielzeth, Bernhard Schmid, Alexandra Weigelt, Wolfgang W. Weisser, Maha Shadaydeh, Joachim Denzler, Anne Ebeling, Nico EisenhauerbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that plant diversity acts as a crucial buffer against soil temperature fluctuations, stabilizing it across seasons and years. This effect, which strengthens over time and under extreme weather, is mediated by increased soil organic carbon and leaf area index, suggesting plant diversity is a key nature-based solution for climate change mitigation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soil temperature is a critical factor influencing numerous ecosystem processes, from nutrient uptake and microbial activity to plant growth and carbon cycling. As extreme weather events become more frequent due to climate change, understanding how ecosystems can maintain stability is paramount. While plant diversity is known to enhance ecosystem stability in general, its specific role in buffering soil temperature fluctuations against these climatic extremes remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by investigating whether and how plant diversity can stabilize soil temperature over long periods and under varying environmental conditions.

Methods

The researchers utilized an extensive 18-year dataset from the Jena Experiment, a large-scale grassland biodiversity experiment. They employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • High-resolution data analysis: Soil temperature was measured at 5 cm and 15 cm depths with 1-minute resolution, aggregated to 30-minute and daily intervals for analysis.
  • Buffering effect quantification: The buffering effect of vegetation was calculated by comparing soil temperature in vegetated plots to bare soil plots.
  • Statistical modeling: A Bayesian time series model was used to analyze within-day fluctuations, while linear regression and mixed-effects models were applied to daily and annual data to assess seasonal dynamics, the influence of air temperature, and long-term trends.
  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): SEM was employed to disentangle the underlying mechanisms, specifically investigating the mediating roles of plant leaf area index (LAI) and soil organic carbon (SOC) in the plant diversity-soil temperature stability relationship.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is from the Jena Experiment, a long-term grassland biodiversity experiment in Germany. This experiment provided 18 years (2004-2021) of continuous, high-resolution soil temperature data (1-minute intervals) from plots with varying plant species richness (from 1 to 60 species), along with data on climate variables. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing long-term experimental data was leveraged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Plant diversity as a natural thermostat: The most striking finding is that increasing plant diversity consistently stabilizes soil temperature, acting as a natural buffer against both excessive heating and cooling. This effect is not limited to specific seasons but is present throughout the year.
  • Time and aging matter: The stabilizing effect of plant diversity on soil temperature strengthens over time as experimental communities mature. This suggests that established, diverse ecosystems offer more robust buffering capacity.
  • Extreme conditions amplify the effect: The buffering capacity of plant diversity is particularly pronounced during extreme weather events, such as hot days or dry years, highlighting its importance in mitigating climate change impacts.
  • Underlying mechanisms revealed: The SEM analysis points to soil organic carbon (SOC) as a primary mediator, with a stronger indirect effect than plant leaf area index (LAI). This suggests that increased SOC, driven by plant diversity, plays a critical role in insulating the soil.
  • Nature-based solutions: The findings strongly support the potential of utilizing plant diversity as a nature-based solution for climate change mitigation, by enhancing ecosystem resilience to climatic variability.

Key Results

  • Plant diversity significantly stabilized soil temperature across daily, seasonal, and annual scales.
  • In summer, 60-species communities showed soil temperatures 5.01°C lower than bare soil during peak heat, a stark contrast to monocultures (-2.12°C).
  • In autumn, the same diverse communities were 1.47°C warmer than bare soil, compared to monocultures (+0.32°C).
  • The effect of plant diversity on soil temperature stability increased with time since the experiment's establishment.
  • Plant diversity significantly increased plant LAI and SOC, which in turn stabilized soil temperature. The standardized indirect effect of plant diversity via SOC was 0.41, and via LAI was 0.27.
  • The buffering effect was stronger in drier years (lower SPEI values).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Soil depth attenuation: While effects were observed at 5 cm and 15 cm, the buffering effect of plant diversity was attenuated at 60 cm depth, indicating that deeper soil layers respond less immediately to surface fluctuations.
  • Data gaps: The study acknowledges data gaps, particularly in 2013 due to a flood, which affected summer data representation. Methods were employed to fill these gaps conservatively.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that future climate modeling should incorporate these plant diversity effects on soil to improve predictions of climate impacts on natural ecosystems. They also highlight the potential of using plant diversity as a nature-based solution for climate change mitigation, emphasizing its role in continuous provision of ecosystem functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Extreme weather events are occurring more frequently, and research has shown that plant diversity can help mitigate impacts of climate change by increasing plant productivity and ecosystem stability 1,2 . Although soil temperature and its stability are key determinants of essential ecosystem processes related to water and nutrient uptake 3 as well as soil respiration and microbial activity 4 , no study has yet investigated whether plant diversity can buffer soil temperature fluctuations. Using 18 years of a continuous dataset with a resolution of 1 minute (∼795,312,000 individual measurements) from a large-scale grassland biodiversity experiment, we show that plant diversity buffers soil temperature throughout the year. Plant diversity helped to prevent soil heating in hot weather, and cooling in cold weather. Moreover, this effect of plant diversity increased over the 18-year observation period with the aging of experimental communities and was even stronger under extreme conditions, i.e., on hot days or in dry years. Using structural equation modelling, we found that plant diversity stabilized soil temperature by increasing soil organic carbon concentrations and, to a lesser extent, by increasing the plant leaf area index. We suggest that the diversity-induced stabilization of soil temperature may help to mitigate the negative effects of extreme climatic events such as soil carbon release, thus slow global warming.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2023plant,
  author = {Yuanyuan Huang and Gideon Stein and Olaf Kolle and Karl Kübler and Ernst‐Detlef Schulze and Hui Dong and David Eichenberg and Gerd Gleixner and Anke Hildebrandt and Markus Lange and Christiane Roscher and Holger Schielzeth and Bernhard Schmid and Alexandra Weigelt and Wolfgang W. Weisser and Maha Shadaydeh and Joachim Denzler and Anne Ebeling and Nico Eisenhauer},
  title = {{Plant diversity stabilizes soil temperature}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.03.13.532451},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure