Plant and bird diversity in rubber agroforests in the lowlands of Sumatra, Indonesia

Hendrien Beukema, Finn Danielsen, Grégoire Vincent, Suryo Hardiwinoto, Jelte van AndelAgroforestry 2007 · DOI

Abstract

As primary forests in the Sumatran lowlands vanish, "jungle rubber"—a traditional agroforestry system—has emerged as a potential refuge for biodiversity. This study synthesizes multi-taxa data to compare jungle rubber with primary forests and monoculture plantations. While jungle rubber cannot fully replicate the specialist diversity of primary forests, it retains significantly higher richness than monocultures, particularly for birds and terrestrial ferns, making it a critical landscape component for conservation.

Introduction: The Vanishing Lowland Forests

The lowland rainforests of Sumatra have faced massive conversion into industrial monocultures, primarily oil palm and rubber. This transition creates a stark ecological divide. Researchers are increasingly investigating "intermediate" land-use types like jungle rubber. These are low-input systems where rubber trees (Hevea brasiliensis) are integrated into secondary forest growth. The central question is whether these agroforests can effectively conserve "forest specialists"—species that depend on the complex interior conditions of old-growth forests.

Methodology and Data Synthesis

To provide a robust comparison, the study integrated decades of field data across various provinces, primarily Jambi and Riau.

Map of study areas in Sumatra and Jambi province, showing sampling locations.

The researchers utilized Species-Accumulation Curves to standardize comparisons across different sampling efforts and spatial scales. This approach is vital because biodiversity patterns often shift when moving from small plots to landscape-level assessments. Furthermore, species were categorized by ecological niche, distinguishing "forest specialists" from generalists to assess the quality of conservation.

Summary of sampling units and areas for plant and tree datasets integrated into the study.

The synthesis included data on vascular plants, pteridophytes (ferns), trees, and birds from numerous established researchers (e.g., Laumonier, Thiollay, Danielsen & Heegaard).

Key Insights: Diversity vs. Specialization

The study revealed that total species richness can be a deceptive metric. For instance, while total bird richness in jungle rubber often matched primary forest levels, this was frequently due to the arrival of "edge" and "open-land" species. In contrast, forest specialists showed a marked decline.

A "dilution effect" was observed for trees; the high density of planted rubber trees reduces the available niche space for native forest species, leading to roughly 30% relative richness compared to primary forests. Epiphytes, such as orchids, were also highly vulnerable, as they require the stable, long-term architecture of old-growth trees—a feature often missing in agroforests managed on a 40-year replanting cycle.

Results: A Critical Middle Ground

Jungle rubber consistently outperformed monoculture plantations, which functioned as "biological deserts" for forest-associated species. Key findings include:

  • Specialist Retention: Jungle rubber retained approximately 60–70% of the forest specialist species found in primary forests for both birds and terrestrial ferns.
  • Taxonomic Variation: Terrestrial ferns actually thrived in jungle rubber due to increased light, while trees and epiphytes suffered the most significant losses.
  • Landscape Value: The forest-like structure of these agroforests provides a vital buffer and connectivity in landscapes otherwise dominated by sterile monocultures.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While jungle rubber is a biodiversity "win" compared to industrial plantations, its conservation value is capped by the 40-year slash-and-burn replanting cycle. Furthermore, the persistence of species in these systems likely depends on nearby primary forest "source" populations. As economic pressures drive conversion toward more profitable but less diverse oil palm, finding ways to make these biodiverse agroforestry systems economically competitive remains a priority for Sumatran conservation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plant and bird diversity in the Indonesian jungle rubber agroforestry system was compared to that in primary forest and rubber plantations by integrating new and existing data from a lowland rain forest area in Sumatra. Jungle rubber gardens are low-input rubber (Hevea brasiliensis) agroforests that structurally resemble secondary forest and in which wild species are tolerated by the farmer. As primary forests have almost completely disappeared from the lowlands of the Sumatra peneplain, our aim was to assess the contribution of jungle rubber as a land use type to the conservation of plant and bird species, especially those that are associated with the forest interior of primary and old secondary forest. Species-accumulation curves were compiled for terrestrial and epiphytic pteridophytes, trees and birds, and for subsets of ‘forest species’ of terrestrial pteridophytes and birds. Comparing jungle rubber and primary forest, groups differed in relative species richness patterns. Species richness in jungle rubber was slightly higher (terrestrial pteridophytes), similar (birds) or lower (epiphytic pteridophytes, trees, vascular plants as a whole) than in primary forest. For subsets of ‘forest species’ of terrestrial pteridophytes and birds, species richness in jungle rubber was lower than in primary forest. For all groups, species richness in jungle rubber was generally higher than in rubber plantations. Although species conservation in jungle rubber is limited by management practices and by a slash-and-burn cycle for replanting of about 40 years, this forest-like land use does support species diversity in an impoverished landscape increasingly dominated by monoculture plantations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{beukema2007plant,
  author = {Hendrien Beukema and Finn Danielsen and Grégoire Vincent and Suryo Hardiwinoto and Jelte van Andel},
  title = {{Plant and bird diversity in rubber agroforests in the lowlands of Sumatra, Indonesia}},
  booktitle = {Agroforestry},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1007/s10457-007-9037-x},
}
Figure