PKI-based secure mobile access to electronic health services and data

Georgios Kambourakis, Ilias Maglogiannis, Angelos RouskasTechnology 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) based approach using Attribute Certificates (ACs) to enable secure mobile access to electronic health records. They demonstrate the feasibility of this system through experiments on WLAN and GPRS networks, showing that AC issuance and TLS-protected data transfer are achievable with acceptable performance for mobile healthcare.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing adoption of mobile devices like PDAs and Tablet PCs in healthcare presents a significant opportunity to improve patient care by providing mobile access to electronic health records. However, the sensitive nature of medical data necessitates robust security mechanisms for authentication, authorization, and confidentiality. Existing security solutions often fall short in mobile environments, especially when dealing with the dynamic and distributed nature of healthcare access. This paper addresses the challenge of establishing secure, flexible, and scalable access control for mobile healthcare applications, particularly focusing on how to grant and manage user permissions effectively in a mobile context.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution lies in leveraging Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) and Attribute Certificates (ACs).

  • PKI and ACs: The paper builds upon standard PKI concepts where digital certificates bind public keys to identities. They extend this by using Attribute Certificates (ACs) to carry authorization information, such as roles and permissions, separate from the identity certificate. This allows for more granular and flexible access control.
  • Trust Model Architecture: A four-domain architecture is presented: the client (physician/nurse), the server (service provider like a hospital), the PKI/PMI authorities (issuing certificates), and the administration subsystem (defining roles and policies).
  • TLS Integration: To ensure secure data transfer, the authors integrate the proposed AC-based authorization with the Transport Layer Security (TLS) protocol. This allows for mutually authenticated and encrypted communication channels.
  • Experimental Evaluation: The feasibility and performance of the proposed system were evaluated through experiments conducted on two distinct network architectures:
  • WLAN (IEEE 802.11b): Simulating a controlled healthcare environment like a hospital.
  • GPRS: Simulating a more general mobile scenario, allowing access from various locations.
  • Measurements focused on AC acquisition times and TLS handshake/data transfer times.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental evaluation using simulated network environments and device characteristics rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decoupling Identity and Authorization: The key insight is that separating authorization attributes (roles, permissions) into ACs from identity-based Public Key Certificates (PKCs) offers significant advantages for mobile healthcare. This allows for dynamic updates of permissions without reissuing identity certificates, crucial for the evolving needs of healthcare professionals.
  • ACs as a Flexible Authorization Mechanism: ACs are shown to be a powerful tool for implementing Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) in a distributed and mobile setting. They enable precise representation of user roles and can be managed more flexibly than traditional access control lists.
  • TLS and ACs Synergy: The combination of ACs for authorization and TLS for secure transport provides a robust security framework. The experiments demonstrate that this integration is feasible even over wireless links.
  • Mobile Healthcare is Achievable: The experimental results provide concrete evidence that delivering ACs and securing medical data transfer over mobile networks like WLAN and GPRS is technically viable with current technology.

Key Results

  • AC Issuance and Transfer Times:
    • WLAN: Average total transaction time (AC issuing) was approximately 3.0 seconds.
  • GPRS: Average total transaction time was approximately 4.4 seconds.
  • These times are considered low and comparable to other wireless services.
  • TLS Performance:
    • WLAN: Total handshake time was around 1.175 seconds, with transfer times varying based on DICOM file size.
  • GPRS: Handshake times were significantly higher (around 9.31 seconds), and transfer times were also considerably longer, attributed to the inherent limitations of GPRS.
  • Network Impact: The performance difference between WLAN and GPRS was significant, highlighting the impact of network bandwidth and reliability on the overall user experience. GPRS showed higher latency and standard deviation in service times due to its less stable connection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Security Robustness: The authors acknowledge that the proposed model needs further evaluation in terms of its security robustness and strength, including identifying and mitigating potential threats.
  • Performance Comparison: A future direction is to compare the performance of TLS with other analogous public key enabled security protocols like IPsec and Secure Shell (SSH) for transferring medical data over wireless networks.
  • Battery Consumption: While mentioned as a consideration, the paper does not present detailed results on battery or energy consumption during TLS-protected sessions, suggesting this as an area for future work.
  • 3G and Beyond: The paper notes that future advancements in mobile networks (3G and beyond) will significantly reduce transfer times, making these secure mobile healthcare solutions even more practical.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent research works examine the potential employment of public-key cryptography schemes in e-health environments. In such systems, where a Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) is established beforehand, Attribute Certificates (ACs) and public key enabled protocols like TLS, can provide the appropriate mechanisms to effectively support authentication, authorization and confidentiality services. In other words, mutual trust and secure communications between all the stakeholders, namely physicians, patients and e-health service providers, can be successfully established and maintained. Furthermore, as the recently introduced mobile devices with access to computer-based patient record systems are expanding, the need of physicians and nurses to interact increasingly with such systems arises. Considering public key infrastructure requirements for mobile online health networks, this paper discusses the potential use of Attribute Certificates (ACs) in an anticipated trust model. Typical trust interactions among doctors, patients and e-health providers are presented, indicating that resourceful security mechanisms and trust control can be obtained and implemented. The application of attribute certificates to support medical mobile service provision along with the utilization of the de-facto TLS protocol to offer competent confidentiality and authorization services is also presented and evaluated through experimentation, using both the 802.11 WLAN and General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) networks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kambourakis2005pki,
  author = {Georgios Kambourakis and Ilias Maglogiannis and Angelos Rouskas},
  title = {{PKI-based secure mobile access to electronic health services and data}},
  booktitle = {Technology},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.3233/thc-2005-13606},
}
Figure