Pitch-Responsive Cortical Regions in Congenital Amusia

Sam Norman-Haignere, Philippe Albouy, Anne Caclin, Josh H. McDermott, Nancy Kanwisher, Barbara TillmannJournal of Neuroscience 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Congenital amusia is a lifelong deficit in music perception thought to reflect an underlying impairment in the perception and memory of pitch. The neural basis of amusic impairments is actively debated. Some prior studies have suggested that amusia stems from impaired connectivity between auditory and frontal cortex. However, it remains possible that impairments in pitch coding within auditory cortex also contribute to the disorder, in part because prior studies have not measured responses from the cortical regions most implicated in pitch perception in normal individuals. We addressed this question by measuring fMRI responses in 11 subjects with amusia and 11 age- and education-matched controls to a stimulus contrast that reliably identifies pitch-responsive regions in normal individuals: harmonic tones versus frequency-matched noise. Our findings demonstrate that amusic individuals with a substantial pitch perception deficit exhibit clusters of pitch-responsive voxels that are comparable in extent, selectivity, and anatomical location to those of control participants. The ability to identify pitch-responsive regions in individual amusic subjects will make it possible to ask more precise questions about their role in amusia in future work.

Introduction

Congenital amusia, commonly known as tone deafness, is a lifelong impairment in music perception, often characterized by an inability to detect small changes in pitch that are obvious to others. For years, neuroscientists have debated the neural origins of this disorder. One leading theory suggests a "disconnection syndrome," where the auditory cortex encodes pitch correctly, but the information fails to reach frontal brain regions responsible for conscious perception and memory. Alternatively, it has been proposed that the auditory cortex itself lacks the specialized clusters of neurons that respond to pitch. Previous studies were inconclusive because they did not specifically target the "pitch-responsive" regions using stimuli known to drive them most strongly. This study seeks to determine whether the primary sensory "hardware" for pitch processing is intact in the amusic brain.

Methods

The researchers used functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to compare 11 amusic subjects with 11 age- and education-matched controls.

  • Stimuli: The experiment utilized a contrast between harmonic tones (which have a clear pitch) and frequency-matched noise (which does not). Crucially, they used "resolved harmonics" (harmonics 3–6), which are known to be the primary drivers of pitch-responsive regions in the human brain.
  • ROI Analysis: To ensure statistical rigor, a "localize-and-test" approach was used. Pitch-responsive voxels were identified in one subset of the data, and their response was measured in an independent subset to prevent "double-dipping."
  • Anatomical Mapping: Responses were mapped onto the superior temporal plane to compare the physical location and extent of these regions between groups.

Datasets and Behavioral Results

Participants included 22 subjects (11 amusic, 11 control). Amusics were identified using the Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia (MBEA), which measures various components of music perception.

Figure 1: MBEA scores for amusic and control participants. The shaded region indicates the threshold for classification as "Amusic."

Behavioral data confirmed that the amusic group had significantly higher pitch discrimination thresholds (the smallest pitch change a subject can detect) compared to controls ($p < 0.05$), establishing a clear perceptual deficit.

Key Insights and Results

Despite their profound behavioral inability to perceive pitch differences, amusics showed perfectly normal fMRI responses in their auditory cortex. Their pitch-responsive regions were identical in location, size, and selectivity to those of the control group.

Figure 6: fMRI activation maps showing pitch-responsive regions (Harmonic Tones > Noise) in the left (L) and right (R) hemispheres for both groups. The clusters are comparable in extent and anatomical location.
  • Selectivity: There was no significant difference in pitch selectivity between amusics and controls ($p = 0.88$).
  • Extent and Density: The number of pitch-responsive voxels and their density within anatomical regions like Heschl's Gyrus were statistically indistinguishable between groups ($p > 0.4$).
  • Encoding vs. Access: These results strongly support the idea that the brain encodes pitch information at the sensory level in amusia, but the individual cannot access or use that information for conscious musical tasks.

Discussion and Future Work

The finding of normal pitch-responsive regions in the auditory cortex suggests that the deficit in amusia lies in higher-order processing or connectivity. However, fMRI has resolution limits; it is possible that individual neurons within these regions exhibit abnormal tuning or temporal coding that fMRI cannot detect.

Future work should investigate the white matter tracts connecting these healthy-looking pitch regions to the frontal cortex. If the regions are functional but the "wiring" is impaired, it would explain the lack of conscious perception. Additionally, using high-temporal-resolution methods like MEG or EEG could determine if the timing of neural responses to pitch is disorganized in amusic individuals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Congenital amusia is a lifelong deficit in music perception thought to reflect an underlying impairment in the perception and memory of pitch. The neural basis of amusic impairments is actively debated. Some prior studies have suggested that amusia stems from impaired connectivity between auditory and frontal cortex. However, it remains possible that impairments in pitch coding within auditory cortex also contribute to the disorder, in part because prior studies have not measured responses from the cortical regions most implicated in pitch perception in normal individuals. We addressed this question by measuring fMRI responses in 11 subjects with amusia and 11 age- and education-matched controls to a stimulus contrast that reliably identifies pitch-responsive regions in normal individuals: harmonic tones versus frequency-matched noise. Our findings demonstrate that amusic individuals with a substantial pitch perception deficit exhibit clusters of pitch-responsive voxels that are comparable in extent, selectivity, and anatomical location to those of control participants. We discuss possible explanations for why amusics might be impaired at perceiving pitch relations despite exhibiting normal fMRI responses to pitch in their auditory cortex: (1) individual neurons within the pitch-responsive region might exhibit abnormal tuning or temporal coding not detectable with fMRI, (2) anatomical tracts that link pitch-responsive regions to other brain areas (e.g., frontal cortex) might be altered, and (3) cortical regions outside of pitch-responsive cortex might be abnormal. The ability to identify pitch-responsive regions in individual amusic subjects will make it possible to ask more precise questions about their role in amusia in future work.
BibTeX
@article{normanhaignere2016pitch,
  author = {Sam Norman-Haignere and Philippe Albouy and Anne Caclin and Josh H. McDermott and Nancy Kanwisher and Barbara Tillmann},
  title = {{Pitch-Responsive Cortical Regions in Congenital Amusia}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.2705-15.2016},
}
Figure