TL;DR
This paper introduces two novel models, "pipe pile" and "key stratum," to evaluate the effectiveness of grouting reinforcement for preventing water inrush in mine floors. By combining theoretical modeling, numerical simulations, and microseismic monitoring, the study demonstrates that regional grouting ("key stratum") offers superior water control compared to localized drilling ("pipe pile").
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Mining operations, especially in North China's Carboniferous-Permian coalfields, face a significant threat from water inrush due to fractured and deep floor strata. Grouting reinforcement is a common solution, but its effectiveness, particularly in complex limestone aquifers under varying treatment modes, is not well-understood. This lack of a robust evaluation method leads to blind and random application of grouting techniques, potentially compromising safety and resource recovery. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and validating models to assess different grouting strategies.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted approach:
- Conceptual Modeling: Two distinct models are proposed:
- "Pipe Pile" Model: Represents reinforcement using cross-layer drilling grouting, where casings and grout form a structural element.
- "Key Stratum" Model: Represents reinforcement through regional treatment grouting, aiming to transform a specific stratum into a water-resistant "key layer."
- Theoretical Analysis: The paper delves into the spatial stress characteristics of the "pipe pile" structure under distributed abutment pressure and analyzes the mechanical mechanism of the grout-filled casing, considering its bending stiffness. For the "key stratum," it applies key layer theory and elastic thin plate theory to analyze hydraulic criteria for water inrush.
- Numerical Simulation: A coupled finite-element (FLAC3D) and discrete element (PFC3D) model is developed to simulate crack propagation and the behavior of the "key layer" under different conditions, specifically varying crack angles.
- Microseismic Monitoring: Field data from two working faces (230102 and 220106) employing different grouting methods ("pipe pile" vs. "key stratum") are collected using "point and plane" and "line and line" microseismic monitoring arrays. This data is statistically analyzed to compare the microseismic response characteristics.
Datasets
The study utilizes field data from the Xinji No. 2 Coal Mine, specifically from the 230102 and 220106 working faces. These datasets consist of microseismic event frequencies and characteristics recorded during mining operations under different grouting reinforcement strategies. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Pipe Pile" vs. "Key Stratum" Effectiveness: The "key stratum" model, achieved through regional treatment, demonstrates superior water control compared to the "pipe pile" model from localized drilling. This is attributed to the "key stratum" creating a more comprehensive and continuous water-resistant layer.
- Microseismic Signatures: Different grouting methods produce distinct microseismic responses. The "pipe pile" method is associated with higher frequency and deeper disturbances, indicating more significant mining impact. Conversely, the "key stratum" method results in lower frequency and shallower disturbances, suggesting better floor stability and water resistance.
- Crack Angle Impact: Numerical simulations reveal that the angle of cracks significantly influences their propagation. A 90° crack angle led to the largest crack propagation and block generation, while a 60° angle showed the smallest impact, deviating from conventional mechanical analysis in certain stress conditions.
- Stress Concentration and Casing Action: The "pipe pile" model highlights that grouting casings are most effective in the transition zone of the floor rock stratum, where they can significantly improve deformation and failure resistance.
Key Results
- Microseismic monitoring data showed a significantly higher frequency of microseismic events in the limestone strata of the 230102 working face (pipe pile) compared to the 220106 working face (key stratum).
- The 230102 working face exhibited high-frequency and sub-deep disturbances, while the 220106 working face showed low-frequency and sub-shallow disturbances, indicating better water control and stability with the "key stratum" approach.
- Numerical simulations indicated that the "key stratum" approach effectively suppressed karst fissures, leading to improved water resistance.
Limitations and Future Work
- Generalizability of "Key Layer" Model: While the "key layer" model is presented, its application might be limited to specific geological conditions and requires further validation across diverse mine environments.
- Microseismic Data Interpretation: While differences in microseismic responses are noted, a more detailed statistical analysis and correlation with specific failure mechanisms could enhance the predictive power.
- Numerical Model Refinement: The numerical simulations, while insightful, could benefit from incorporating more complex geological heterogeneities and dynamic mining processes for greater realism.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further analysis of the size effect and strength characteristic parameters of the "key layer" to improve water inrush prediction and prevention. They also propose continued microseismic monitoring to refine the understanding of floor behavior under different reinforcement strategies.
Summary updated