Piloting a Diagnostic Foot and Ankle Fracture Sonographic Algorithm with Rural and Adolescent Patients

Tariq Alamin, Margaret Lin‐Martore, Aaron E. Kornblith, Adrienne O’Donnell, Sally GragliaPOCUS 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Foot and ankle injuries are a common presenting complaint to the Emergency Department (ED) and are often assessed with plain radiography. Rural environments may not have access to radiography, mandating the referral or transfer of patients to regional centers for definitive diagnosis. The Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules (OFAR) is a clinical decision rule that can assist in ruling out fractures, and Point-of-Care Ultrasound (POCUS) can augment this decision rule. The objective of this study was to assess both the feasibility and test characteristics of a previously described POCUS-augmented clinical assessment, OFAR-POCUS, for adolescent and adult patients with foot and ankle pain in a rural environment. Methods: This was a prospective cohort study from June to August 2022 including patients with a chief complaint of foot or ankle injury presenting to a rural clinic. Patients were included if they had positive finding(s) on the OFAR Test and required radiographic imaging. POCUS was performed by novices who underwent a brief standardized training session. Results: Thirteen POCUS examiners performed exams on 20 patients; four patients had fractures on radiograph (20%). Bedside clinician POCUS interpretation had 100% sensitivity and 94% specificity. Conclusion: A POCUS-enhanced clinical strategy for foot and ankle fractures in a rural setting is feasible, though larger studies are required to further characterize test characteristics.

Introduction

Foot and ankle injuries are a staple of emergency medicine, but diagnosing them accurately without immediate access to imaging remains a significant challenge. The current standard for clinical screening, the Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules (OFAR), is excellent at "ruling out" fractures but suffers from low specificity (25%–42%). This leads to a high volume of unnecessary X-rays.

In rural settings, this inefficiency is magnified. A "just in case" X-ray might require a multi-hour transfer to a regional center, draining scarce resources and delaying care. While POCUS has shown promise in augmenting OFAR (a strategy called OFAR-POCUS), most research has been conducted by experts in high-resource urban hospitals. This study investigates whether POCUS novices in a rural clinic can bridge this gap, particularly in adolescent patients where open growth plates can mimic fractures on sonography.

Methods

The researchers conducted a prospective cohort study at a remote medical clinic in Cimarron, New Mexico. The examiners consisted of 13 POCUS novices (primarily 4th-year medical students) who received a brief, 1.5-to-2-hour standardized training session.

The 5-view POCUS protocol for foot and ankle assessment.

Examiners utilized a 5-view sonographic protocol targeting the inferior, lateral, and superior 5th metatarsal, as well as the posterior tibia and fibula. Patients aged 12 and older who were "OFAR positive" received a POCUS exam before being transported to a regional hospital for the gold-standard diagnostic: a plain film radiograph (X-ray). Two fellowship-trained ultrasound experts retrospectively reviewed the POCUS clips while blinded to clinical data for quality control.

Results

Out of 25 potential participants, 20 patients were included in the final analysis. The cohort included both adolescents (12–17 years) and adults. Four patients (20%) had confirmed fractures via X-ray, all of which were distal fibula fractures.

Ultrasound images showing cortical disruption (fracture) and normal bone.

Bedside novice performance was exceptional, achieving a sensitivity (SN) of 100% and a specificity (SP) of 94%. All four fractures were correctly identified by the bedside examiners. Interestingly, the bedside novices outperformed the blinded experts, who achieved only 75% sensitivity. This discrepancy suggests that clinical correlation—knowing exactly where the patient felt pain—is vital for distinguishing growth plates from fractures.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study demonstrates that a POCUS-enhanced clinical strategy is highly feasible in rural environments. The median POCUS exam took only 10 minutes, representing a massive potential for time and cost savings compared to the hours required for rural transfers. Furthermore, the successful inclusion of patients as young as 15 suggests that the "growth plate confusion" in pediatric POCUS can be managed by non-experts through proper clinical correlation.

The primary limitation is the small sample size (N=20), resulting in wide confidence intervals. While the 100% sensitivity is encouraging, larger multicenter studies are needed to confirm these findings before OFAR-POCUS can officially replace X-rays in rural triage protocols.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> Foot and ankle injuries are a common presenting complaint to the Emergency Department (ED) and are often assessed with plain radiography. Rural environments may not have access to radiography mandating the referral or transfer patients to regional centers for definitive diagnosis. The Ottawa Foot and Ankle Rules (OFAR) is a clinical decision rule that can assist in ruling out fractures. Point of care ultrasound (POCUS) can augment this decision rule. The objective of this study was to assess both the feasibility and test characteristics of a previously described POCUS augmented clinical assessment, OFAR-POCUS, for adolescent and adult patients with foot and ankle pain in a rural environment. <b>Methods:</b> This was a prospective cohort study from June to August 2022 including patients with chief complaint of foot or ankle injury presenting to a rural clinic. Patients were included if they had positive finding(s) on the OFAR Test and required radiographic imaging. Patients were excluded if they did not consent, speak English, were unable to be scanned, had obvious joint deformities, had altered mental status, were not physiologically stable, had other injuries preventing sonography, were pregnant, or had previous injury with internal fixation, osteomyelitis, or rheumatoid arthritis. POCUS was performed before transport for radiography. POCUS examiners were POCUS novices who underwent a one and a half to two-hour, standardized foot and ankle POCUS training session. All POCUS studies were reviewed by two emergency medicine ultrasound fellowship trained faculty for quality assurance. Standard test characteristics were calculated for bedside clinician and expert POCUS interpretations compared to the radiographic control. <b>Results:</b> Thirteen POCUS examiners performed exams on 20 patients included in analysis; four patients had fractures on radiograph (20%). The bedside clinician POCUS interpretation had sensitivity (SN) = 100% (95% Cl, 40%-100%), specificity (SP) =94% (95% Cl, 70%-100%), and negative likelihood ratio (-LR) = 16.00 (95% Cl, 2.40-106.73). Expert POCUS interpretation had SN=75% (95% Cl, 19%-99%), SP=75% (95% Cl, 48%-93%), and -LR=0.33 (95% Cl, 0.06-1.86). <b>Conclusion:</b> A POCUS enhanced clinical strategy for clinically significant foot and ankle fractures in adolescent and adult patients in a rural setting is feasible. Larger studies are required to further characterize test characteristics and use of foot and ankle POCUS where plain radiography is unavailable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alamin2024piloting,
  author = {Tariq Alamin and Margaret Lin‐Martore and Aaron E. Kornblith and Adrienne O’Donnell and Sally Graglia},
  title = {{Piloting a Diagnostic Foot and Ankle Fracture Sonographic Algorithm with Rural and Adolescent Patients}},
  booktitle = {POCUS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.24908/pocus.v9i2.17550},
}
Figure