Pilot Evaluation of the Long-Term Reproducibility of Capillary Zone Electrophoresis–Tandem Mass Spectrometry for Top-Down Proteomics of a Complex Proteome Sample

Seyed Amirhossein Sadeghi, Wenrong Chen, Qianyi Wang, Qianjie Wang, Fei Fang, Xiaowen Liu, Liangliang SunJournal of Proteome Research 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tackles the critical issue of long-term reproducibility in top-down proteomics using capillary zone electrophoresis coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (CZE-MS/MS). Researchers developed and validated an effective capillary cleaning protocol that enables highly reproducible proteoform identification and quantification in complex samples, paving the way for large-scale applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Top-down proteomics (TDP) is a powerful technique for analyzing intact proteins and their modifications (proteoforms), offering deeper biological insights than traditional bottom-up approaches. CZE-MS/MS is a promising method for TDP due to its high separation power and sensitivity. However, a major hurdle for its widespread adoption in large-scale studies is the lack of understanding and validation of its long-term reproducibility. Specifically, it was unclear how consistently CZE-MS/MS could identify and quantify proteoforms over many runs, especially when dealing with complex biological samples like cell lysates. This paper addresses this gap by systematically evaluating the long-term performance of CZE-MS/MS and identifying a key challenge: proteoform adsorption onto the capillary surface, which degrades performance over time.

Methods

The core of this study involved running a yeast cell lysate sample repeatedly using CZE-MS/MS with a single linear polyacrylamide (LPA)-coated capillary.

  • Sample Preparation: Yeast cells were lysed, and proteins were buffer-exchanged to remove urea using a 10 kDa cutoff filter.
  • CZE-MS/MS: A 1-meter LPA-coated capillary was used with a dynamic pH junction-based sample stacking technique for enhanced separation. The system was coupled to a Q-Exactive HF mass spectrometer. Data-dependent acquisition (DDA) was employed for MS/MS fragmentation.
  • Proteoform Identification and Quantification: The TopPIC software was used for database searching against UniProt, and TopDiff was used for label-free quantification.
  • Capillary Cleanup: A novel and efficient capillary cleanup procedure was developed, involving sequential flushing with diluted ammonium hydroxide (NH4OH), water, and the background electrolyte (BGE). This was a key innovation to address performance degradation.
  • Reproducibility Assessment: The study meticulously tracked the number of identified proteoforms and proteins, as well as proteoform intensity correlations, across numerous runs. They also performed experiments with diluted samples to assess quantitative accuracy.
  • Proteoform Mobility Prediction: The study also validated a semiempirical model for predicting electrophoretic mobility (µef) of proteoforms, which is crucial for confirming proteoform identities and post-translational modifications (PTMs).

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study was a yeast cell lysate. This complex biological sample was analyzed across 62 CZE-MS/MS runs. The MS RAW files were deposited in the ProteomeXchange Consortium with the data set identifier PXD046651. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on evaluating the reproducibility of analyzing a complex, existing biological sample.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proteoform Adsorption is a Major Hurdle: The most significant finding was the observation that proteoforms gradually adsorb onto the LPA-coated capillary's inner wall over repeated runs. This adsorption leads to decreased proteoform intensity, peak broadening, and a reduction in the number of identified proteoforms and proteins.
  • An Effective Cleanup Solution Exists: The development and validation of a simple NH4OH-based capillary cleanup procedure proved to be highly effective in restoring the capillary's performance and enabling reproducible analyses. This is a critical practical takeaway for anyone using CZE-MS for TDP.
  • Two "Phases" of Reproducibility: The study identified two distinct phases of reproducibility:
  • Phase I (Fresh Capillary): High reproducibility for the first ~10 runs, but performance degrades thereafter.
  • Phase II (After Cleanup): After sufficient cleanup, the capillary's performance stabilizes, allowing for reproducible analyses over at least 23 runs. This phase is crucial for large-scale studies.
  • CZE-MS/MS is Ready for Large-Scale TDP: Despite the initial challenges, the data strongly suggest that CZE-MS/MS, when coupled with appropriate operational procedures like regular capillary cleanup, is robust enough for large-scale quantitative TDP of complex samples.
  • Predictive Models Aid Validation: The strong correlation between experimentally measured and theoretically predicted electrophoretic mobilities of proteoforms (even with PTMs) validates the proteoform identifications and provides confidence in the data.

Key Results

  • High Proteoform Identification: Over 1000 proteoforms were identified per run across 62 runs using a single LPA-coated capillary.
  • Performance Degradation: Substantial decreases in proteoform intensity and identification were observed after approximately 10 runs due to proteoform adsorption. For instance, one proteoform's intensity dropped to 20% of its initial level by run 24.
  • Effective Cleanup Restoration: The capillary cleanup procedure using NH4OH successfully restored the proteoform identification and intensity to near-original levels.
  • Phase II Reproducibility: After cleanup, reproducible CZE-MS/MS measurements were achieved for at least 23 runs.
  • Quantitative Reproducibility: Pairwise proteoform intensity correlation coefficients were high (median ~0.95 for Phase I, ~0.85 for Phase II), demonstrating reasonable quantitative reproducibility, especially in Phase II.
  • Dilution Experiments: Dilution experiments confirmed that CZE-MS/MS in Phase II condition performs well for relative quantification, with observed intensities aligning with the dilution factor.
  • Proteoform Mobility Prediction: Strong linear correlations (R² = 0.95-0.96) were observed between experimental and predicted µef of proteoforms, even when accounting for N-terminal acetylation or phosphorylation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Capillary Inner-Wall Chemistry Consistency: The authors acknowledge that further efforts are needed to create more consistent capillary inner-wall chemistry during CZE-MS/MS runs to further enhance reproducibility for large-scale studies.
  • Label-Free Quantification Strategy: For large-scale quantitative studies, it's recommended to either use stable isotopic labeling techniques (like TMT) or to strictly adhere to either Phase I (short-term, fresh capillary) or Phase II (long-term, cleaned capillary) conditions to avoid challenges in data alignment due to migration time shifts.
  • Future Directions: The study suggests that CZE-MS/MS is ready for deployment in broad biological applications, particularly for discovering critical proteoforms in biological processes and diseases in a quantitative manner. The findings also highlight potential challenges and areas for future optimization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based top-down proteomics (TDP) has revolutionized biological research by measuring intact proteoforms in cells, tissues, and biofluids. Capillary zone electrophoresis-tandem MS (CZE-MS/MS) is a valuable technique for TDP, offering a high peak capacity and sensitivity for proteoform separation and detection. However, the long-term reproducibility of CZE-MS/MS in TDP remains unstudied, which is a crucial aspect for large-scale studies. This work investigated the long-term qualitative and quantitative reproducibility of CZE-MS/MS for TDP for the first time, focusing on a yeast cell lysate. Over 1000 proteoforms were identified per run across 62 runs using one linear polyacrylamide (LPA)-coated separation capillary, highlighting the robustness of the CZE-MS/MS technique. However, substantial decreases in proteoform intensity and identification were observed after some initial runs due to proteoform adsorption onto the capillary inner wall. To address this issue, we developed an efficient capillary cleanup procedure using diluted ammonium hydroxide, achieving high qualitative and quantitative reproducibility for the yeast sample across at least 23 runs. The data underscore the capability of CZE-MS/MS for large-scale quantitative TDP of complex samples, signaling its readiness for deployment in broad biological applications. The MS RAW files were deposited in ProteomeXchange Consortium with the data set identifier of PXD046651.
BibTeX
@article{sadeghi2024pilot,
  author = {Seyed Amirhossein Sadeghi and Wenrong Chen and Qianyi Wang and Qianjie Wang and Fei Fang and Xiaowen Liu and Liangliang Sun},
  title = {{Pilot Evaluation of the Long-Term Reproducibility of Capillary Zone Electrophoresis–Tandem Mass Spectrometry for Top-Down Proteomics of a Complex Proteome Sample}},
  journal = {Journal of Proteome Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jproteome.3c00872},
}

Loading related content...

Figure