Piezoresistive foam sensor arrays for marine applications

Jeff Dusek, Michael S. Triantafyllou, Jeffrey H. LangSensors and Actuators A Physical 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, flexible, and cost-effective piezoresistive foam sensor array for marine applications. Inspired by fish lateral lines, these "smart-skins" can provide detailed near-field flow measurements on curved surfaces, crucial for improving marine vehicle performance and enabling advanced underwater exploration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine vehicles, from submarines to autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs), operate in a complex fluid environment. Understanding the near-field flow around their hulls is critical for improving maneuverability, efficiency, and enabling advanced control strategies. However, existing pressure sensors are often rigid, expensive, and not well-suited for conformal mounting on curved surfaces or prolonged underwater exposure. This lack of detailed, spatially-dense pressure data limits our ability to implement effective flow control. The authors draw inspiration from the biological lateral line system found in fish, which acts as a distributed array of pressure and velocity sensors, allowing them to navigate and interact with their environment with remarkable agility. The goal is to replicate this bio-inspired sensing capability in engineered systems for marine applications.

Methods

The core innovation is the development of a Carbon Black-doped-Poly(dimethylsiloxane) (CBPDMS) foam sensor array. This material leverages the piezoresistive property of carbon black dispersed in a flexible silicone matrix.

  • Material Development: A closed-cell CBPDMS foam was fabricated by mixing carbon black into a two-component silicone casting foam (Soma Foama 15). This foam provides a flexible, waterproof, and low-cost sensing element.
  • Sensor Array Fabrication: The arrays were constructed with alternating segments of piezoresistive CBPDMS foam and highly conductive silver-carbon black-PDMS (Ag-CBPDMS) electrodes. A pure PDMS base layer was used for structural support and adhesive properties.
  • Four-Point Probe Measurement: To mitigate the impact of contact resistance and isolate the piezoresistive behavior of the foam, a four-point probe measurement technique was employed. This involves using separate current-carrying and voltage-measuring leads.
  • Characterization Setup: The sensor arrays were characterized using a computer-controlled linear stage to perform vertical plunging experiments in a water tank. This generated time-varying hydrostatic pressure stimuli.
  • Calibration: The raw voltage output from the sensors was processed through bandpass filtering and then calibrated against the known hydrostatic pressure. A piecewise polynomial fit, combining a third-degree polynomial with a linear correction for low-pressure regimes, was developed to accurately map sensor output to pressure.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The paper presents experimental data collected from the fabricated sensor arrays during controlled plunging experiments. This data consists of time-series voltage outputs from the sensor channels and corresponding hydrostatic pressure stimuli generated by the linear stage. This experimental data was used to characterize the sensor's performance and develop calibration models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bio-inspiration is Key: The fish lateral line serves as a powerful model for developing distributed sensing systems in challenging environments like the ocean.
  • Foam as a Smart Material: Utilizing a closed-cell piezoresistive foam offers a unique combination of flexibility, waterproofing, and low cost, making it ideal for conformal marine applications.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The developed sensor arrays have a material cost of less than $10 per sensor, a significant reduction compared to existing commercial alternatives.
  • Compressible Model Dominance: The piezoresistive response of the CBPDMS foam under hydrostatic pressure aligns with the compressible model, where compression leads to increased conductive pathways and decreased resistance.
  • Piecewise Calibration is Necessary: A simple polynomial fit is insufficient. A piecewise calibration, combining a polynomial for higher pressures and a linear correction for lower pressures, is required to accurately capture the sensor's behavior across its dynamic range.

Key Results

  • Sensitivity: The sensor arrays exhibit a sensitivity on the order of 5 Pascal.
  • Dynamic Range: The sensors demonstrated a dynamic range of approximately 50-500 Pascal.
  • Repeatability: The sensor arrays showed repeatable responses across multiple experimental runs, with DC offset variations being the primary source of spread, which was addressed by calibration.
  • Calibration Accuracy: The piecewise polynomial calibration achieved a Normalized Root Mean Square Error (NRMSE) of approximately 13-15% when compared to theoretical hydrostatic pressure.
  • Cost: Material costs were significantly reduced to approximately $10 per sensor for a 4x1 array.
  • Physical Properties: The arrays are waterproof, completely flexible, and have a form factor suitable for mounting on curved surfaces with radii of curvature as small as 5-10 cm. Sensor thickness is also kept below 5 mm to avoid vortex shedding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • DC Offset Variation: While the dynamic response was repeatable, variations in the DC offset voltage between experiments were observed. This was addressed by calibration but suggests a need for further investigation into the stability of the baseline resistance.
  • Transient Behavior: The first oscillation of each plunging experiment consistently produced a lower sensor output voltage, which was treated as an outlier. The source of this transient behavior is unknown and identified as a direction for future study.
  • Dynamic Pressure Neglect: In the plunging experiments, the dynamic pressure component was found to be orders of magnitude smaller than the hydrostatic component and was neglected for future analysis. However, for applications where dynamic pressure is significant, this aspect would require more detailed investigation.
  • Electrode Material Cost: While significantly cheaper than commercial sensors, the silver used in the electrodes is a major cost contributor. Future work could explore alternative conductive materials to further reduce cost.
  • Full-Scale Ocean Testing: The current experiments were conducted in a controlled laboratory setting. Future work should involve testing the arrays in real-world ocean environments to assess their performance under more complex and demanding conditions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dusek2016piezoresistive,
  author = {Jeff Dusek and Michael S. Triantafyllou and Jeffrey H. Lang},
  title = {{Piezoresistive foam sensor arrays for marine applications}},
  booktitle = {Sensors and Actuators A Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1016/j.sna.2016.07.025},
}
Figure