Physical activity and fat-free mass during growth and in later life

Klaas R. Westerterp, Yosuke Yamada, Hiroyuki Sagayama, Philip N. Ainslie, Lene Frost Andersen, Liam Anderson, Lenore Arab, Issad Baddou, Kweku Bedu-Addo, Ellen E. Blaak, Stéphane Blanc, A. Bonomi, Carlijn V. C. Bouten, Pascal Bovet, Maciej S. Buchowski, Nancy F. Butte, Stefan Gerardus Camps, Graeme L. Close, Jamie A. Cooper, Sai Krupa Das, Richard Cooper, Lara R. Dugas, Ulf Ekelund, Sonja Entringer, Terrence Forrester, Barry W. Fudge, Annelies Goris, Michael Gurven, Catherine Hambly, Asmaa El Hamdouchi, Marije B. Hoos, Sumei Hu, Noorjehan Joonas, Annemiek M. Joosen, Peter T. Katzmarzyk, Kitty P. Kempen, Misaka Kimura, William E. Kraus, Robert F. Kushner, Estelle V. Lambert, William R. Leonard, Nader Lessan, Corby K. Martin, Anine Christine Medin, Erwin P. Meijer, James C. Morehen, James P. Morton, Marian L. Neuhouser, Theresa A. Nicklas, Robert Ojiambo, Kirsi H. Pietiläinen, Yannis Pitsiladis, Jacob Plange‐Rhule, Guy Plasqui, Ross L. Prentice, Roberto Rabinovich, Susan B. Racette, David A. Raichlen, Éric Ravussin, Rebecca M. Reynolds, Susan B. Roberts, Albertine J. Schuit, Anders Sjödin, Eric Stice, Samuel S. Urlacher, Giulio Valenti, Ludo M. Van Etten, Edgar van Mil, Jonathan C. K. Wells, George Wilson, Brian M. Wood, Jack A. Yanovski, Tsukasa Yoshida, Xueying Zhang, Alexia J. Murphy‐Alford, Cornelia Loechl, Amy Luke, Herman Pontzer, Jennifer Rood, Dale A. Schoeller, William W. Wong, John R. SpeakmanAmerican 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages a large, international dataset to investigate the relationship between physical activity and fat-free mass (FFM) across the human lifespan. It confirms that physical activity is a crucial determinant of FFM, particularly during growth and in early adulthood, but its ability to fully counteract age-related FFM decline in later life is limited.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining muscle mass (a key component of FFM) is vital for overall health, mobility, and preventing age-related conditions like sarcopenia. While it's generally understood that physical activity is beneficial for muscle, the precise role of physical activity in FFM accrual during growth and its efficacy in preserving FFM in older age, especially when accounting for other factors like fat mass, remains an area of active research. This paper aims to clarify these relationships by analyzing a comprehensive dataset that spans a wide age range and uses robust methods for measuring energy expenditure and body composition.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional analysis using data from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Doubly Labeled Water (DLW) database. This database contains measurements from 2000 participants aged 3 to 96 years.

  • Physical Activity Level (PAL): This was calculated by dividing Total Energy Expenditure (TEE) by Resting Energy Expenditure (REE), both measured using the DLW method. DLW is considered a gold-standard for measuring energy expenditure in free-living individuals.
  • Fat-Free Mass (FFM): FFM was determined using isotope dilution, a method derived from total body water measurements, which is a well-established indirect method for body composition analysis.
  • Statistical Modeling: The analysis involved multiple regression models. For participants under 18, FFM was analyzed directly, accounting for fat mass (FM) and age. For participants 18 and older, FFM was expressed as the fat-free mass index (FFMI) to account for height differences, and models included age, fat mass index (FMI), PAL, and interaction terms to capture non-linear relationships and how PAL's effect might change with age.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Doubly Labeled Water database. This is a pre-existing, large-scale, international compilation of DLW data from multiple studies, providing a unique resource for lifespan research. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physical Activity is a Cornerstone of FFM: The study strongly reinforces that physical activity is a primary driver of FFM, not just during the growth phase but also throughout adulthood.
  • Growth Phase is Critical for Peak FFM: The findings highlight that being physically active during childhood and adolescence is crucial for building a higher peak FFM, which has long-term implications.
  • Fat Mass Interacts with FFM: The study emphasizes the importance of accounting for fat mass when assessing the impact of physical activity on FFM. Gains or losses in fat mass are often accompanied by changes in FFM, and this relationship needs to be controlled for to isolate the true effect of activity.
  • Age Dampens the Benefits of Activity: While physical activity continues to be associated with higher FFM in older adults, its protective effect against age-related FFM loss is only partial. The positive impact of activity diminishes with age, suggesting that other age-related physiological changes become more dominant.
  • Peak FFM Occurs Earlier Than Previously Thought: The study identified peak FFM around age 30, which is earlier than some previous estimates that placed it in the mid-40s for females. This difference might be attributable to variations in how fat mass was accounted for in different studies.

Key Results

  • Early Life Impact: In participants under 18, PAL was a significant determinant of FFM. A very active participant (PAL=2.0) had 1.7 kg (females) and 3.4 kg (males) more FFM than a sedentary participant (PAL=1.5), after adjusting for fat mass.
  • Adult FFM: For adults (≥18 y), FFMI was significantly higher with higher FMI and PAL.
  • Age-Related Differences: At age 18, a very active participant had 3.6 kg (females) and 4.4 kg (males) more FFM than a sedentary one. By age 80, this difference reduced to 0.7 kg (females) and 1.0 kg (males), indicating a substantial decline in the benefit of activity for FFM preservation in older age.
  • Model Explanatory Power: Models including age, fat mass, and PAL explained 76% and 85% of FFM variation in individuals <18 years, and 32% and 47% in individuals ≥18 years, for females and males respectively.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Observational Design: The study is cross-sectional, meaning it cannot establish causality definitively. While the authors discuss potential causal links, the observed associations could be influenced by unmeasured confounders.
  • Two-Compartment Model: The body composition model used (FFM vs. Fat Mass) does not differentiate between the components of FFM, such as muscle mass and bone mass.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that while aerobic exercise may not fully prevent FFM loss in aging, resistance exercise might be more effective. They also point to hormonal alterations as a potential explanation for age-associated FFM decline and the interaction between age and physical activity. Further longitudinal studies are needed to confirm causal relationships and explore the efficacy of different exercise modalities in older adults.

Summary updated

Abstract

If these associations are causal, they suggest physical activity is a major determinant of body composition as reflected in peak FFM, and that a physically active lifestyle can only partly protect against loss of FFM in aging adults.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{westerterp2021physical,
  author = {Klaas R. Westerterp and Yosuke Yamada and Hiroyuki Sagayama and Philip N. Ainslie and Lene Frost Andersen and Liam Anderson and Lenore Arab and Issad Baddou and Kweku Bedu-Addo and Ellen E. Blaak and Stéphane Blanc and A. Bonomi and Carlijn V. C. Bouten and Pascal Bovet and Maciej S. Buchowski and Nancy F. Butte and Stefan Gerardus Camps and Graeme L. Close and Jamie A. Cooper and Sai Krupa Das and Richard Cooper and Lara R. Dugas and Ulf Ekelund and Sonja Entringer and Terrence Forrester and Barry W. Fudge and Annelies Goris and Michael Gurven and Catherine Hambly and Asmaa El Hamdouchi and Marije B. Hoos and Sumei Hu and Noorjehan Joonas and Annemiek M. Joosen and Peter T. Katzmarzyk and Kitty P. Kempen and Misaka Kimura and William E. Kraus and Robert F. Kushner and Estelle V. Lambert and William R. Leonard and Nader Lessan and Corby K. Martin and Anine Christine Medin and Erwin P. Meijer and James C. Morehen and James P. Morton and Marian L. Neuhouser and Theresa A. Nicklas and Robert Ojiambo and Kirsi H. Pietiläinen and Yannis Pitsiladis and Jacob Plange‐Rhule and Guy Plasqui and Ross L. Prentice and Roberto Rabinovich and Susan B. Racette and David A. Raichlen and Éric Ravussin and Rebecca M. Reynolds and Susan B. Roberts and Albertine J. Schuit and Anders Sjödin and Eric Stice and Samuel S. Urlacher and Giulio Valenti and Ludo M. Van Etten and Edgar van Mil and Jonathan C. K. Wells and George Wilson and Brian M. Wood and Jack A. Yanovski and Tsukasa Yoshida and Xueying Zhang and Alexia J. Murphy‐Alford and Cornelia Loechl and Amy Luke and Herman Pontzer and Jennifer Rood and Dale A. Schoeller and William W. Wong and John R. Speakman},
  title = {{Physical activity and fat-free mass during growth and in later life}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1093/ajcn/nqab260},
}
Figure