TL;DR
This study uses ancient and modern pig DNA (mtDNA) to trace human migration patterns across Island Southeast Asia and Oceania. The findings reveal distinct dispersal routes for pigs, suggesting that the "wild" pigs found in regions like New Guinea are likely feral descendants of domesticated pigs introduced by early agriculturalists, challenging some existing models of human expansion.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The peopling of Oceania is a complex puzzle with various proposed models for the dispersal of Austronesian peoples and the associated Lapita culture. These models, primarily based on linguistic, genetic, and archaeological data, often conflict. This paper aims to contribute to this debate by using the genetic history of pigs, which were integral to human migration and settlement, as a proxy to understand human movement and cultural diffusion. Specifically, it addresses the origins and dispersal routes of pigs in Island Southeast Asia (ISEA) and Oceania, and how these relate to human expansion, particularly the Neolithic expansion and the Lapita cultural complex.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining molecular genetics and morphometrics:
- Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Sequencing: They sequenced the mitochondrial control region (663 bp) from 243 wild, feral, and domestic pigs. This was combined with existing data from 512 GenBank entries, resulting in a dataset of 755 individuals.
- Ancient DNA Analysis: DNA was extracted and amplified from 23 ancient pig specimens from various sites. Special protocols for ancient DNA were followed to account for degradation.
- Phylogenetic Analysis: Bayesian Monte Carlo-Markov chain (MCMC) methodology was used to construct phylogenetic trees, inferring evolutionary relationships and ancestral origins of the pig haplotypes.
- Geometric Morphometrics: Elliptic Fourier analysis was applied to the outlines of third lower molars (M3) from modern and archaeological pig specimens. This technique quantifies shape variations and was used to independently verify genetic findings and explore potential correlations between pig morphology and their origins.
Datasets
- Modern and Museum Pig Samples: 243 modern and museum specimens were newly sequenced.
- Ancient Pig Samples: DNA was extracted from 23 ancient pig bones and teeth from 27 sites.
- GenBank Data: 512 previously published pig mtDNA sequences were incorporated into the analysis.
- Archaeological Pig Specimens: Ancient DNA was successfully extracted from five archaeological pig specimens from various Pacific Island sites.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Two Distinct Pig Dispersal Routes: The study identified two major human-mediated dispersal routes for pigs into and within ISEA and Oceania, separate from natural wild boar movements.
- "Wild" Pigs are Often Feral Domesticates: The research strongly suggests that what are currently considered "wild" pigs in regions east of the Wallace Line, including New Guinea, are most likely feral descendants of domestic pigs introduced by early agriculturalists.
- Pacific Clade Originates in Mainland Asia: The "Pacific Clade" of pig mtDNA, found extensively in Oceania, originated in mainland Asia, with a potential initial domestication center in peninsular Southeast Asia.
- Lapita Association: One of the major pig dispersal routes is unequivocally linked to the Neolithic (Lapita) and later Polynesian migrations, connecting pigs from Java, Sumatra, Wallacea, and Oceania to mainland Southeast Asian Sus scrofa.
- Early Translocation of Sus celebensis: Evidence points to an early human-mediated translocation of the Sulawesi warty pig (Sus celebensis) to Flores and Timor, predating the Neolithic expansion.
- Challenging Austronesian Dispersal Models: The distribution and frequency of pig haplotypes do not fully support existing models of Austronesian dispersal, particularly those suggesting a direct movement from Taiwan to the New Guinea region via the Philippines that included domestic pigs.
Key Results
- Pacific Clade Identification: A distinct "Pacific" clade of pig mtDNA was identified, showing a clear evolutionary divergence from mainland Asian and western ISEA pig populations.
- Geographic Distribution: The Pacific Clade was found in pigs from Halmahera, New Guinea, and various Pacific islands, with high frequencies in New Guinea and the Lesser Sundas, but absent in mainland China, Taiwan, and the Philippines.
- Early Appearance in Wallacea: Archaeological evidence indicates the first appearance of pigs in the Moluccas and Lesser Sundas is associated with the Neolithic cultural package, dating back to 7000–3500 BP.
- Morphological Confirmation: Geometric morphometric analysis of pig teeth corroborated the genetic findings, showing a distinct dental morphotype for pigs associated with the Pacific Clade and introduced domesticates.
- Two Additional Dispersal Episodes: Beyond the Pacific Clade, two other dispersal events were identified: one linking East Asia, the Philippines, and Micronesia, and another involving the translocation of Sus celebensis within ISEA.
Limitations and Future Work
- Origin of Pacific Clade: While the Pacific Clade is strongly linked to mainland Asia, its precise origin within peninsular Southeast Asia requires further sampling to pinpoint.
- Domestication Center: The possibility of independent pig domestication in ISEA is raised, but further investigation is needed to confirm or refute this.
- Complex Migration Models: The authors emphasize the need for more complex models that account for various degrees of exchange of language, genes, and artifacts as populations moved, suggesting that different components of the Neolithic cultural complex may have had different origins and trajectories.
- Further Morphometric Analysis: While morphometric data provided strong support, further analysis of modern and ancient domestic pig teeth is recommended to fully confirm associations.
- Ancient DNA Survival: The successful extraction of ancient DNA from Liang Bua, Flores, highlights the potential for long-term DNA survival in certain environments, opening avenues for future research in similar contexts.
Summary updated