Phylogenetic analysis of multidrug-resistant Escherichia coli clones isolated from humans and poultry.

Massimo Ciccozzi, Maria Giufrè, Marisa Accogli, Alessandra Lo Presti, Caterina Graziani, Eleonora Cella, Marina CerquettiPubMed 2013

TL;DR

This study uses phylogenetic analysis to investigate the origins of multidrug-resistant Escherichia coli (MDR E. coli) that cause human infections. They found that certain E. coli strains (phylogroups A and B1) associated with MDR are likely exchanged between poultry and humans, posing a public health concern, while other strains (phylogroups B2 and D) appear to have a more limited zoonotic potential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Extraintestinal infections caused by Escherichia coli (ExPEC) are a significant global health burden, and the increasing prevalence of antimicrobial resistance in these pathogens complicates treatment. There's a growing suspicion that poultry products might be a reservoir for MDR E. coli strains that infect humans. However, a clear understanding of the genetic relatedness and potential transmission pathways between E. coli strains found in humans and poultry is needed to effectively manage this zoonotic risk. This paper aims to fill this gap by performing a detailed phylogenetic analysis of E. coli strains from both sources to elucidate their evolutionary relationships and potential for inter-species transmission.

Methods

The researchers employed multilocus sequence typing (MLST) to characterize E. coli strains. They then used this data to construct phylogenetic trees. Specifically, they applied:

  • Maximum Likelihood (ML) phylogenetic analysis: This method infers evolutionary trees by finding the tree that best explains the observed sequence data under a given model of molecular evolution. They used the TN93 + I + G model, selected via hierarchical likelihood ratio tests.
  • Bayesian phylogenetic analysis: This approach uses Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to estimate the posterior probability distribution of possible trees, incorporating evolutionary rates and divergence times. They utilized a relaxed clock model and a Bayesian skyline plot (BSP) to model population dynamics and estimate the Time of the Most Recent Common Ancestor (TMRCA) for various clades.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 172 E. coli strains:

  • 83 strains from human extraintestinal infections (urinary tract infections and bloodstream infections).
  • 43 strains from healthy avian species.

These strains were subjected to MLST, resulting in 58 distinct Sequence Types (STs). These STs were then categorized into human-exclusive (H-STs), avian-exclusive (A-STs), and shared human-avian (HA-STs). For phylogenetic analysis, concatenated MLST sequences were used, with a total dataset of 58 STs for the Bayesian analysis and separate datasets for human (37 STs) and avian (30 STs) ML analyses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phylogenetic divergence between phylogroups: The study highlights a significant genetic separation between E. coli strains belonging to phylogroups B2 and D, and those belonging to phylogroups A and B1, particularly when considering their source (human vs. avian).
  • Zoonotic potential of MDR strains: The intermixing of avian and human strains within phylogroups A and B1, especially those associated with multidrug resistance (MDR), strongly suggests a potential for exchange and transmission between poultry and humans. This is a key public health concern.
  • Limited zoonotic potential of B2/D strains: Conversely, the clear segregation of B2 and D phylogroup strains from different hosts indicates a lower likelihood of zoonotic transmission for these specific E. coli clones.
  • Early emergence of B2/D vs. recent emergence of A/B1: The Bayesian dating suggests that B2 and D phylogroups have an older evolutionary history, while A and B1 phylogroups, particularly those linked to MDR, have emerged more recently, aligning with the hypothesis of their increased exchangeability.
  • The ST131 clone: While the study did not find direct evidence of an avian reservoir for the pandemic clone ST131, its segregation with other human B2 strains, and the suggestion of an avian ancestor, points to a complex evolutionary history that warrants further investigation.

Key Results

  • Human E. coli phylogeny: Showed a major clade with intermixed A and B1 STs, and separate clusters for B2 and D STs. MDR strains predominated in the A/B1 intermixed clade and the D cluster.
  • Avian E. coli phylogeny: Exhibited greater heterogeneity, with strains dispersed across various clusters. MDR strains were more evenly distributed.
  • Bayesian analysis (combined human/avian): Revealed that B2 and D human STs clustered separately from avian strains, while A and B1 MDR strains were intermixed with avian strains.
  • Dating of clades: Clades containing B2 and D strains dated back to the mid-1990s, while clades with A and B1 strains, including MDR ones, emerged more recently, in the mid-2000s.
  • Mean genetic distances: The highest genetic distance was observed between phylogroups B2 and D (0.017), while the lowest was between B1 and A (0.008).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Narrow time span and insufficient ST data: The authors acknowledge that the dataset's narrow time span and the number of STs might limit the precision of estimated emergence dates. They emphasize that only statistically supported clades with high posterior probabilities were dated.
  • Lack of commensal human strains: The study did not include E. coli strains from healthy human subjects, which could have provided a more complete picture of human commensal populations.
  • Potential for reclassification: The recent development of a new quadruplex PCR method for phylogroup assignment could potentially lead to reclassification of some strains, though initial testing on D phylogroup strains showed correct assignment.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest the need for more comprehensive studies, including whole-genome-based phylogeny reconstruction of single lineages within ST clones, to fully elucidate the complex issue of MDR E. coli origins and transmission. They also highlight the importance of analyzing large datasets over extended periods to clarify the epidemiology of important pathogenic clones like ST131.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chicken products represent a source for multidrug-resistant Escherichia coli causing extraintestinal infections (ExPEC) in humans. We applied phylogenetic analysis to a collection of E. coli strains from both hosts (poultry/humans) to improve our understanding of the origin and spread of ExPEC in humans. The dataset consisted of 58 sequences among 172 E. coli strains from human extraintestinal infections and avian species. Human phylogenetic tree analysis showed a major clade, within which ST clones belonging to groups A and B1 were largely intermixed, and two clusters, each exclusively including B2 or D clones. The avian tree exhibited greater heterogeneity between and within clades/clusters. In the Bayesian tree, consisting of sequences from both human and avian E. coli, the B2 and D human ST clones were clustered together separate from the avian strains, whereas B1 and A ST clones (frequently associated with multidrug resistance) were intermixed with avian strains. This study suggests that a subgroup of E. coli clones, A and B1, associated with multidrug resistance, is potentially exchangeable between poultry and humans. Such a subgroup may be of public health concern. On the contrary, E. coli clones included in B2 and D appeared clearly separate between human and avian sources, suggesting a minor zoonotic potential of these phylotypes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ciccozzi2013phylogenetic,
  author = {Massimo Ciccozzi and Maria Giufrè and Marisa Accogli and Alessandra Lo Presti and Caterina Graziani and Eleonora Cella and Marina Cerquetti},
  title = {{Phylogenetic analysis of multidrug-resistant Escherichia coli clones isolated from humans and poultry.}},
  booktitle = {PubMed},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure