Phylogenetic Analysis and Expression Patterns of Triterpenoid Saponin Biosynthesis Genes in 19 Araliaceae Plants

Chi Ma, Yu Lin, Jianwei Yin, Lijuan Zhu, Jinkai Fang, Dan ZhangInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages comparative transcriptomics to reconstruct the evolutionary history of the Araliaceae family and pinpoint the genetic basis for ginsenoside production. By analyzing gene expression patterns, researchers identified key enzymes that likely enable Panax species to uniquely synthesize these valuable compounds, paving the way for improved conservation and utilization of Araliaceae resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Araliaceae family, which includes economically and medicinally important plants like ginseng, is known for its complex morphology and vast diversity, making its evolutionary relationships difficult to untangle. Furthermore, while many Araliaceae species produce triterpenoid compounds, only a few, notably Panax species, accumulate high levels of ginsenosides, the primary bioactive constituents with significant pharmacological activities. The precise evolutionary pathways and the specific genetic mechanisms behind this differential ginsenoside production remained unclear. This study aims to address these gaps by providing a robust phylogenetic framework for Araliaceae and investigating the expression patterns of genes involved in ginsenoside biosynthesis to understand why Panax species are such potent producers.

Methods

The researchers employed a comparative transcriptomics approach, analyzing transcriptome data from 19 Araliaceae species and two outgroup species from the Apiaceae family.

  • Phylogenetic Reconstruction: They identified 510 single-copy orthologous genes across these species. Phylogenetic trees were constructed using both concatenation-based (Maximum Likelihood with IQ-TREE, Bayesian inference with MrBayes) and coalescent-based (ASTRAL) methods to ensure robust evolutionary relationships.
  • Divergence Time Estimation: The MCMCTree module in PAML was used to estimate divergence times for key evolutionary events within the family, calibrated with known fossil data and divergence estimates.
  • Allopolyploidy Inference: The PhyloNet software was used to infer phylogenetic networks, specifically employing the "InferNetwork_MP_Allopp" and "InferNetwork_MPL" methods to investigate the origin of polyploid Panax species.
  • Whole-Genome Duplication (WGD) Detection: Synonymous substitution (Ks) values of paralogous genes were analyzed to identify potential WGD events and estimate their timing.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Transcriptome data was aligned to the P. ginseng genome to quantify gene expression levels (TPM). Heatmaps were generated to visualize the expression patterns of key enzyme genes involved in ginsenoside biosynthesis.
  • Gene Family Evolution: Gene trees for key enzyme families (β-AS, DDS, CYP450, UGTs) were constructed to understand their evolutionary trajectories and potential functional divergence.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available transcriptome data from 19 Araliaceae plant species and two outgroup species (Centella asiatica and Daucus carota) from the Apiaceae family, totaling 21 species. These data were sourced from GenBank SRA. No new datasets were generated or introduced as benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aralia Family Structure Revealed: The study provides a well-resolved phylogenetic tree for Araliaceae, confirming the division into two subfamilies (Aralioideae and Hydrocotyloideae) and further classifying Aralioideae into three distinct groups: the Aralia–Panax group, the Polyscias–Pseudopanax group, and the Asian Palmate group.
  • Polyploid Origins of Panax: The research strongly suggests that key Panax species like P. ginseng, P. quinquefolius, and P. japonicus originated from an allopolyploid event, likely involving hybridization between P. notoginseng and P. pseudoginseng. This sheds light on the complex genetic makeup of these valuable medicinal plants.
  • The pg-β Event's Significance: All Aralioideae species appear to have undergone a whole-genome duplication event, termed "pg-β," which is hypothesized to be crucial for the evolution of ginsenoside biosynthesis.
  • Panax's Unique Ginsenoside Synthesis: A striking finding is the distinct expression patterns of key genes (β-AS, DDS, CYP450, UGTs) in Panax species compared to other Araliaceae. These genes show independent evolutionary lineages, suggesting specialized adaptations that allow Panax to efficiently produce ginsenosides.
  • DDS Gene Divergence: The DDS gene, critical for forming the basic triterpenoid skeleton, shows a distinct evolutionary trajectory in Panax, suggesting neofunctionalization that might be key to their high ginsenoside production.

Key Results

  • A robust phylogenetic tree of Araliaceae was constructed with high support values across most branches.
  • The Araliaceae family is estimated to have originated around 57.29 million years ago (MYA).
  • The pg-β WGD event was identified as a shared event across Aralioideae plants, occurring around 24.6 MYA.
  • The emergence of the Panax genus dates back to approximately 11.43 MYA.
  • The study identified distinct expression patterns for key ginsenoside biosynthesis genes, with Panax species showing significantly higher expression of genes like CYP450 and UGTs compared to other Araliaceae.
  • Gene trees for DDS, CYP450, and UGTs revealed independent evolutionary lineages for genes within Panax, suggesting functional specialization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Asian Palmate Group Resolution: The study acknowledges that the limited sample size for the Asian Palmate group prevented a fully comprehensive resolution of its complex phylogenetic relationships. Future work with broader species sampling is suggested to further elucidate this group.
  • Hydrocotyloideae WGD: While a potential WGD event in H. umbellata was observed, its exact nature and relation to other WGD events remain unclear due to the lack of closely related species in the dataset. Further studies with additional Hydrocotyloideae species are needed to verify this hypothesis.
  • Functional Validation: The identified uniquely evolved and specifically expressed genes in Panax are highlighted as important candidate genes for subsequent functional validation experiments to confirm their roles in ginsenoside synthesis.
  • Whole-Genome Data: For a more definitive understanding of WGD events and their impact, the authors suggest that whole-genome data and chromosomal evolution analyses may be required.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Araliaceae family has significant economic and medicinal value. However, the phylogenetic relationships and the expression patterns of key genes of the active triterpenoid substance within this family are still unclear. In this study, we employed comparative transcriptomics to analyze the transcriptomes of 19 species from 11 genera of Araliaceae, aiming to elucidate the evolutionary history of the family and the expression patterns of key genes in the ginsenoside biosynthesis pathway. Our results divide Araliaceae into two subfamilies: Aralioideae and Hydrocotyloideae. Aralioideae is further classified into three groups: the <i>Aralia-Panax</i> group, the <i>Polyscias-Pseudopanax</i> group, and the Asian Palmate group. PhyloNet analysis reveals that the common ancestor of <i>Panax ginseng</i>, <i>Panax quinquefolius</i>, and <i>Panax japonicus</i> was an allopolyploid, likely resulting from hybridization between <i>Panax notoginseng</i> and <i>Panax pseudoginseng</i>. Additionally, all Aralioideae species underwent the pg-β event, which may be critical for ginsenoside biosynthesis. We discovered that <i>Panax</i> species exhibit distinct expression patterns of key enzyme genes (<i>β-AS</i>, <i>DDS</i>, <i>CYP450</i>, <i>UGTs</i>) compared to other Araliaceae species. These enzyme genes show independent evolutionary lineages in gene trees, suggesting unique functional adaptations that enable <i>Panax</i> species to efficiently synthesize ginsenosides. This study provides a theoretical foundation for the conservation and utilization of Araliaceae germplasm resources.
BibTeX
@article{ma2025phylogenetic,
  author = {Chi Ma and Yu Lin and Jianwei Yin and Lijuan Zhu and Jinkai Fang and Dan Zhang},
  title = {{Phylogenetic Analysis and Expression Patterns of Triterpenoid Saponin Biosynthesis Genes in 19 Araliaceae Plants}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms26073439},
}
Figure