Phototoxic effects of nonlinear optical microscopy on cell cycle, oxidative states, and gene expression

Xinyi Zhang, Gabriel Dorlhiac, Markita P. Landry, Aaron StreetsScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Nonlinear optical microscopy techniques like SRS are powerful but can damage cells. This study systematically investigates the phototoxic effects of these lasers on mouse neuroblastoma cells (N2A) by measuring cell proliferation, gene expression, and reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation. The findings establish a range of laser parameters that minimize cellular damage, providing crucial guidance for researchers using these advanced imaging methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nonlinear optical microscopy, particularly Stimulated Raman Scattering (SRS), offers label-free chemical imaging capabilities that are revolutionizing biological research. However, these techniques rely on high-intensity pulsed lasers, which can inadvertently damage the cells being studied. This photodamage can confound experimental results, especially when imaging is combined with downstream analyses like RNA sequencing or when performing time-lapse experiments. The critical challenge is to understand the threshold at which laser exposure causes significant cellular perturbation and to define safe imaging parameters that allow for accurate interpretation of biological processes without artifact.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to assess phototoxicity:

  • Cell Proliferation Assay: They monitored the growth rate of N2A cells over 30 hours after laser exposure using automated phase-contrast imaging. This measured the long-term impact on cell viability and reproductive capacity.
  • Bulk RNA Sequencing (RNA-seq): To assess transcriptional changes, RNA was extracted from cells 1 hour after laser exposure. Differential gene expression analysis was performed to identify any significant changes in gene activity compared to unexposed control cells.
  • Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) Assay: Using the CellROX Green fluorescent dye, the generation of ROS was measured immediately after laser exposure. ROS are key indicators of cellular stress and damage that can occur on shorter timescales than changes in proliferation or gene expression.
  • Laser System: A femtosecond laser system with a tunable output (796 nm) and a fundamental wavelength (1040 nm) was used. This allowed for both single-laser excitation and two-laser SRS experiments, with precise control over parameters like average intensity, pulse width, repetition rate, and inter-pulse delay.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized cultured mouse neuroblastoma (N2A) cells as the biological model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • N2A Cells Show Remarkable Resilience: Contrary to initial expectations, N2A cells demonstrated a surprising tolerance to a wide range of laser excitation settings relevant to SRS imaging. Significant phototoxic effects were only observed at the highest intensity levels tested.
  • Intensity, Not Fluency, is the Primary Driver of ROS: While both intensity and fluency (energy per unit area) are important, the study found that high laser intensity was the main factor driving ROS generation. Even with very high fluency, if the intensity was kept low, ROS levels remained comparable to controls.
  • No Significant Gene Expression Changes at Moderate Intensities: Even under conditions that might be considered high for some microscopy applications, RNA-seq revealed no significant differential gene expression changes 1 hour post-exposure. This suggests that transcriptional responses are less sensitive to moderate laser perturbation than other cellular processes.
  • Thermal Effects Dominate at High Intensities: At the highest tested intensities, which led to decreased proliferation and increased ROS, the authors suggest that thermal effects are the primary damage mechanism, rather than Raman resonance.
  • Guidance for Parameter Selection: The study successfully defines a range of laser parameters (specifically, average intensity and fluency) for which N2A cells exhibit no significant phototoxic effects on proliferation, gene expression, or ROS generation.

Key Results

  • Proliferation: Laser exposure at moderate intensities (e.g., 47.72 mW/µm² and 238.58 mW/µm²) did not affect N2A cell proliferation rates over 30 hours. Significant reduction in proliferation (~25%) was observed only at the highest intensity tested (610.7 mW/µm²).
  • Gene Expression: No significant differential gene expression was detected 1 hour after exposure to various laser settings, including those that did not impact proliferation or ROS levels, and even at near-burning conditions (I3-E3-SRS).
  • ROS Generation: Only the highest intensity condition (14-E5, 610.7 mW/µm²) resulted in a significant increase in ROS generation. Other tested conditions, including those with high fluency but lower intensity, did not show elevated ROS levels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cell Type Specificity: The study focused on a single cell line (N2A). The authors acknowledge that other cell types may exhibit different sensitivities to laser exposure.
  • Time Scale of Gene Expression: While RNA was collected 1 hour post-exposure, it's possible that longer-term transcriptional changes might occur that were not captured.
  • Other Perturbations: The study focused on proliferation, gene expression, and ROS. Other cellular processes or subtle changes might still be affected by laser exposure.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring the potential benefits of ROS scavengers or lowering cell culture temperature to mitigate photodamage. Further investigation into the impact of repeated exposures and the interplay between intensity and fluency across a broader range of parameters would be valuable. Additionally, extending these studies to other cell types and imaging modalities is recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nonlinear optical imaging modalities, such as stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) microscopy, use pulsed-laser excitation with high peak intensity that can perturb the native state of cells. In this study, we used bulk RNA sequencing, quantitative measurement of cell proliferation, and fluorescent measurement of the generation of reactive oxygen species to assess phototoxic effects of near-IR pulsed laser radiation, at different time scales, for laser excitation settings relevant to SRS imaging. We define a range of laser excitation settings for which there was no significant change in mouse Neuro2A cells after laser exposure. This study provides guidance for imaging parameters that minimize photo-induced perturbations in SRS microscopy to ensure accurate interpretation of experiments with time-lapse imaging or with paired measurements of imaging and sequencing on the same cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022phototoxic,
  author = {Xinyi Zhang and Gabriel Dorlhiac and Markita P. Landry and Aaron Streets},
  title = {{Phototoxic effects of nonlinear optical microscopy on cell cycle, oxidative states, and gene expression}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-23054-7},
}
Figure