Photorefractive keratectomy with extended ablation zone for recurrent corneal erosion syndrome accompanied with refractive errors: a study of effectiveness, safety, and refractive outcomes

Xinxin Yu, Chenchen Wang, Zuhui Zhang, Wuqi Zhang, Yizeng Yang, Shuangqing WuFrontiers in Medicine 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the effectiveness and safety of photorefractive keratectomy (PRK) with an extended ablation zone for treating recurrent corneal erosion syndrome (RCES) in patients who also have refractive errors. The findings suggest that this PRK approach is comparable to traditional phototherapeutic keratectomy (PTK) for RCES and offers similar refractive outcomes to trans-epithelial PRK (TPRK) in unaffected eyes, providing a dual therapeutic and refractive solution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Recurrent corneal erosion syndrome (RCES) is a painful condition characterized by repeated breakdown of the corneal epithelium, significantly impacting patients' quality of life. While various treatments exist, including conservative measures and surgical interventions like PTK, managing RCES in patients who also have refractive errors (like myopia) presents a challenge. Traditional PTK primarily addresses the corneal surface irregularities but doesn't correct refractive errors. While PRK can correct refractive errors, its application in RCES patients with refractive errors has been explored with varying approaches, often involving multiple steps or smaller ablation zones, leading to inconsistent outcomes. This paper aims to evaluate a specific, one-step PRK approach with an extended ablation zone for RCES patients with refractive errors, comparing its effectiveness, safety, and refractive outcomes to established PTK and TPRK procedures.

Methods

This retrospective, non-randomized, controlled study involved 79 eyes from 62 patients diagnosed with RCES. The patients were divided into three groups:

  • PRK group: 16 eyes undergoing PRK with an extended ablation zone for RCES and refractive errors.
  • TPRK group: 11 contralateral eyes undergoing trans-epithelial PRK for myopia correction.
  • PTK group: 52 eyes undergoing traditional phototherapeutic keratectomy for RCES without refractive errors.

Surgical parameters such as optical zone diameter, treatment zone diameter, and ablation depth were meticulously recorded. Postoperative outcomes assessed included corneal epithelialization duration, recurrence of erosion, complications, visual acuity, and refractive error. The study utilized the Schwind Amaris® 1050RS excimer laser system for all procedures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved patient data collected from the Eye Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual-Action PRK: The study highlights the potential of a single-step PRK procedure with an extended ablation zone to simultaneously treat RCES and correct refractive errors, offering a more streamlined approach for affected patients.
  • Comparable Efficacy: The effectiveness and safety of this extended-zone PRK for RCES were found to be comparable to traditional PTK, suggesting it's a viable alternative for managing the condition.
  • Refractive Outcome Parity: The refractive outcomes achieved with extended-zone PRK in RCES eyes were similar to those achieved with TPRK in the unaffected eyes of the same patients, indicating good refractive predictability.
  • Importance of Ablation Depth: While not statistically significant in this study, there's a suggestion that a greater ablation depth might contribute to a lower recurrence rate, aligning with some previous findings.
  • Milder Recurrence Manifestations: Patients experiencing recurrence after PRK exhibited milder clinical symptoms compared to those who had recurrence after PTK.

Key Results

  • Surgical Parameters: The treatment zone diameter was comparable between the PRK and PTK groups, but larger in the PTK group than the TPRK group. The ablation depth was significantly greater in the PRK and TPRK groups compared to the PTK group.
  • Recurrence Rates: The recurrence rate in the PRK group was 6.25% (1 eye), and in the PTK group was 5.77% (3 eyes). While not statistically significant, the PRK cohort showed milder clinical manifestations during recurrence.
  • Visual Acuity: All patients in the PRK and TPRK groups achieved an uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) of 1.0 or better at the final visit. In the PTK group, a high percentage of patients achieved visual acuity equal to or better than preoperative levels at 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months postoperatively (76.5%, 82.1%, and 100%, respectively).
  • Refractive Outcomes: The mean deviation of the target spherical equivalent at the final visit was -0.25 ± 0.57 D for the PRK group and -0.13 ± 0.26 D for the TPRK group. The mean change in spherical equivalent for the PTK group was +0.09 ± 0.62 D.
  • Complications: Delayed corneal epithelial healing was observed in 12.50% of PRK eyes, 15.38% of PTK eyes, and 9.09% of TPRK eyes. Mild corneal haze and nebula were also reported, generally resolving within months.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The sample size for the PRK and TPRK groups was relatively small due to the lower incidence of RCES patients with refractive errors or meeting eligibility criteria for refractive correction.
  • Unbalanced Groups: The retrospective design led to an unbalanced sample size between the groups, potentially affecting the reliability of statistical results.

Future work suggested by the authors includes designing prospective studies to validate these findings and further explore risk factors associated with RCES recurrence.

Summary updated

Abstract

In conclusion, the effectiveness and safety of PRK with extended oblation zone were comparable with PTK for RCES and the refractive outcomes were similar with TPRK. It is recommended for RCES patients accompanied with refractive errors for relieving symptoms and acquiring encouraging visual acuity simultaneously.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2025photorefractive,
  author = {Xinxin Yu and Chenchen Wang and Zuhui Zhang and Wuqi Zhang and Yizeng Yang and Shuangqing Wu},
  title = {{Photorefractive keratectomy with extended ablation zone for recurrent corneal erosion syndrome accompanied with refractive errors: a study of effectiveness, safety, and refractive outcomes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2025.1592539},
}
Figure