Photoproduction of Heavy Quarks

Michael KrämerarXiv 1995 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: Heavy quarks are copiously produced in two-photon collisions at $e^+e^-$ colliders. The theoretical predictions including QCD radiative corrections are compared to recent experimental data on $\gamma\gamma$ production of charm quarks at PETRA, PEP, TRISTAN and LEP. Photoproduction of heavy quarks at HERA is an important tool to measure the gluon distribution in the proton. New theoretical results on heavy quark photoproduction at large transverse momenta are discussed and NLO predictions for inelastic $J/\psi$ photoproduction in the HERA energy range are given. The sensitivity of the results to the parametrization of the gluon distribution in the small-$x$ region is demonstrated.

The Challenge of Heavy Quark Production

In the mid-1990s, particle physicists sought to validate the Standard Model's predictions for "heavy" quarks—specifically charm ($c$) and bottom ($b$). Because these quarks have masses significantly larger than the scale of QCD ($m \gg \Lambda_{QCD}$), their production should, in theory, be calculable using perturbative methods.

However, charm quarks sit on a tricky boundary. Their mass is large enough for perturbative math to apply, but small enough that "higher-twist" effects and uncertainties in the strong coupling constant ($\alpha_s$) can cause significant errors (20–30%). This research evaluates whether theoretical models—specifically Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) QCD—actually match experimental observations at colliders like LEP and HERA, and how these collisions can be used to map out the elusive gluon density inside the proton.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

To improve the precision of theoretical cross-section predictions, researchers utilize Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) QCD radiative corrections. Key methodological points include:

  • Three-Mechanism Framework: For two-photon collisions, the analysis considers (i) Direct production (photons couple directly to quarks), (ii) Single resolved (one photon splits into partons first), and (iii) Double resolved (both photons split).
  • Massive vs. Massless Schemes: For high transverse momentum ($p_\perp$), the "massive" approach (treating the quark mass as a fixed scale) is compared with the "massless" approach (treating the heavy quark as an active, massless flavor).
  • Color-Singlet Model: To predict inelastic $J/\psi$ production, a model is used where the $c\bar{c}$ pair is produced in a color-neutral state, requiring the emission of a hard gluon to satisfy conservation laws.

Validating Theory with $D^*$ Production

Leading-order calculations consistently underestimate experimental data. Including NLO corrections increases predicted cross-sections by roughly 30% in $e^+e^-$ collisions and over 50% in fixed-target experiments, bringing theory into much better alignment with reality.

Comparison of NLO QCD predictions with experimental data for $D^*$ production in two-photon collisions.

As shown in the figure above, the NLO predictions for $D^*$ production in two-photon collisions show satisfactory agreement with data from PETRA, PEP, TRISTAN, and LEP, provided resolved contributions are included. At higher energies (like LEP2), the photon stops acting like a point-like particle and starts acting like a collection of quarks and gluons; these "resolved" processes eventually overtake direct production.

The Proton's Interior: $J/\psi$ as a "Gluonometer"

Inelastic $J/\psi$ photoproduction is highly sensitive to the gluon distribution ($g(x)$) in the proton. Because the cross-section depends on the square of the charm mass and the gluon density at small $x$ (momentum fraction), it serves as a sensitive tool to discriminate between different theoretical parametrizations of the proton's interior.

Sensitivity of $J/\psi$ photoproduction cross-sections to various gluon distribution models.

The figure above demonstrates that at HERA energies, the $J/\psi$ photoproduction cross-section varies significantly depending on which gluon distribution model is used (e.g., MRS(G) vs. GRV). This confirms that HERA data can effectively "pick a winner" among these models. While the shape of the $J/\psi$ energy dependence matches the color-singlet model well, the absolute normalization of the theoretical prediction appears to underestimate early HERA data, suggesting a need for lower charm mass values or further theoretical refinement.

Limitations and Future Outlook

Despite the successes of NLO QCD, several challenges remain:

  • Charm Mass Uncertainty: Results are highly sensitive to the choice of the charm quark mass ($m_c$). Small changes in $m_c$ lead to large swings in predicted cross-sections.
  • Statistics: Early HERA data had large statistical uncertainties, meaning no firm conclusion could be drawn regarding the absolute normalization of $J/\psi$ production at that time.
  • Scheme Transition: The discrepancy between massive and massless schemes at high $p_\perp$ remains a point of contention, requiring more precise measurements of heavy flavor content in the photon to resolve.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heavy quarks are copiously produced in two-photon collisions at $e^+e^-$ colliders. The theoretical predictions including QCD radiative corrections are compared to recent experimental data on $γγ$ production of charm quarks at PETRA, PEP, TRISTAN and LEP. Photoproduction of heavy quarks at HERA is an important tool to measure the gluon distribution in the proton. New theoretical results on heavy quark photoproduction at large transverse momenta are discussed and NLO predictions for inelastic $J/ψ$ photoproduction in the HERA energy range are given. The sensitivity of the results to the parametrization of the gluon distribution in the small-$x$ region is demonstrated.
BibTeX
@misc{kramer1995photoproduction,
  author = {Michael Krämer},
  title = {{Photoproduction of Heavy Quarks}},
  year = {1995},
  eprint = {hep-ph/9505380},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9505380},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure