Abstract
旱地土壤中流失的磷是地表水体中磷的重要来源,本文通过模拟实验对比太湖地区丘陵旱地土壤和水稻土对磷的吸持解吸特征,结果表明虽然旱地土壤对磷的固定能力略高于水稻土,但由于旱地土壤的有效磷水平普遍高于水稻土,因而前者磷的吸持饱和度(DPS)要大大高于后者,这就决定了旱地土壤中的磷被淋溶或以溶解态随径流流失的风险和数量也显著高于水稻土.磷吸持饱和度是土壤磷素水平和土壤固磷能力的综合指标,更能反映土壤固相中的磷进入液相的难易程度,可以作为评价水-土界面磷迁移能力的重要指标.
Introduction
Eutrophication remains a critical environmental challenge for Taihu Lake, with phosphorus (P) acting as the primary limiting nutrient. While point-source pollution has been heavily regulated, non-point source pollution from agriculture continues to pose a significant threat. Historically, research in the Taihu watershed focused on rice paddies. However, a shift in land use toward high-value "upland" crops—such as vegetables, tea, and orchards—has introduced higher fertilizer inputs into the ecosystem. This study investigates whether these upland soils behave differently from traditional paddy soils in their ability to retain or release phosphorus, and evaluates the "Degree of Phosphorus Saturation" (DPS) as a metric for predicting P loss risk.
Materials and Methods
Sixteen soil samples (8 upland, 8 paddy) were collected from the hilly regions of the Taihu watershed at a depth of 0–15 cm. Upland soils included yellow-brown and red soils, while paddy soils served as a baseline. The study utilized three main analytical approaches:
- Sorption Isotherms: Phosphorus was added at varying concentrations to determine maximum sorption capacity ($Q_m$) using the Langmuir equation.
- Desorption (Pi-test): Iron oxide-impregnated paper strips were used in eight successive extractions to simulate long-term phosphorus release.
- Degree of Phosphorus Saturation (DPS): Calculated as the ratio of available phosphorus (Olsen P) to the soil's maximum sorption capacity ($Q_m$).
Results and Discussion
Sorption Characteristics
Laboratory analysis revealed that upland soils possess a slightly higher theoretical capacity to fix phosphorus than paddy soils. The average maximum sorption capacity ($Q_m$) for upland soils was 763.3 mg/kg, compared to 707.8 mg/kg for paddy soils. This capacity is influenced by the presence of active iron and aluminum oxides in the hilly soils.
Degree of Phosphorus Saturation (DPS) and Environmental Risk
Despite their higher sorption capacity, upland soils were found to be much closer to their saturation limits due to intensive fertilization. The average DPS for upland soils was 2.80%, double that of paddy soils (1.40%). This higher saturation level directly correlates with a greater risk of phosphorus "leaking" into the environment via leaching or surface runoff.
A critical finding of this study is the strong linear relationship between a soil's DPS and its cumulative phosphorus release. As shown in Figure 4, the correlation ($r^2 = 0.94$) is highly significant ($p < 0.01$), suggesting that DPS is a far more reliable indicator of pollution risk than total phosphorus levels alone.
Land Use and Phosphorus Release
Upland soils released significantly more phosphorus during the desorption tests, with an average cumulative desorbed P ($\sum Pi-P$) of 37.1 mg/kg, compared to 25.4 mg/kg for paddy soils. Specific land uses, such as vegetable and tea gardens, showed exceptionally high Olsen P levels (up to 56 mg/kg) and high DPS, marking them as critical "hotspots" for potential nutrient runoff into Taihu Lake.
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that upland agriculture in the Taihu Lake watershed poses a higher risk of phosphorus loss than traditional paddy farming. While these soils have a robust capacity to bind P, excessive fertilization has pushed many toward a tipping point of saturation. The Degree of Phosphorus Saturation (DPS) serves as an integrated index of soil P levels and sorption capacity, providing a reliable tool for identifying high-risk areas. Future management strategies should consider establishing environmental thresholds for DPS to guide fertilizer application and protect regional water quality.
Summary updated