Phosphorus nutrition of phosphorus-sensitive Australian native plants: threats to plant communities in a global biodiversity hotspot

Hans Lambers, I. Ahmedi, Oliver Berkowitz, C. Dunne, Patrick M. Finnegan, G.E.St.J. Hardy, Ricarda Jost, Étienne Laliberté, Stuart J. Pearse, François P. TesteConservation 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

Southwestern Australia's unique biodiversity hotspot, thriving on extremely phosphorus-poor soils, faces a significant threat from phosphorus enrichment. This paper highlights how many native plant species are highly sensitive to increased phosphorus, leading to toxicity and competitive exclusion, and argues for urgent development of alternatives to phosphite, a common but problematic treatment for Phytophthora cinnamomi.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the critical issue of maintaining the exceptional biodiversity found in southwestern Australia, a region characterized by ancient, nutrient-poor soils, particularly low in phosphorus (P). While these infertile conditions have driven unique plant adaptations, they also make the ecosystem highly vulnerable to external P inputs. The authors identify two major threats: eutrophication from various sources (fire, agriculture, urban activity) and the widespread use of phosphite as a fungicide for Phytophthora cinnamomi. The core problem is that many native species, especially those adapted to extreme P scarcity, are highly sensitive to increased P levels, leading to toxicity and displacement by more competitive species. Furthermore, phosphite, while effective against P. cinnamomi, acts as a P source, exacerbating the eutrophication problem. The paper seeks to understand these threats and propose a path forward.

Methods

This paper is a review, synthesizing existing research rather than presenting new experimental data. The authors draw upon a broad range of physiological, ecological, and molecular studies to build their arguments. Key approaches discussed include:

  • Physiological studies: Examining plant adaptations to low-P soils, such as the development of cluster roots and dauciform roots for enhanced P acquisition, and high P-use efficiency.
  • Molecular studies: Investigating the mechanisms of phosphate uptake and regulation in plants, focusing on PHT1 family transporters and the role of genes like PHO2.
  • Ecological studies: Analyzing plant community composition along soil chronosequences and in response to environmental changes (e.g., fire frequency, nutrient enrichment).
  • Fungicide efficacy studies: Evaluating the role of phosphite in managing Phytophthora cinnamomi and its potential side effects on plant physiology and soil P levels.

The review synthesizes findings from various experimental setups, including glasshouse experiments, field observations, and laboratory analyses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • P-impoverished soils drive unique adaptations: The extreme P scarcity in southwestern Australia has fostered a remarkable array of plant adaptations, including specialized root structures (cluster roots, dauciform roots) and high P-use efficiency, allowing non-mycorrhizal species to thrive where mycorrhizal ones might struggle.
  • P-sensitivity is a double-edged sword: While adaptations for efficient P uptake are crucial in infertile soils, they also render many native species highly susceptible to P toxicity. This sensitivity means even small increases in soil P can be detrimental.
  • Phosphite is a double-edged sword: While an effective tool against the devastating pathogen Phytophthora cinnamomi, phosphite itself acts as a source of phosphorus, contributing to eutrophication and potentially harming P-sensitive native species. This creates a paradox where a solution to one threat exacerbates another.
  • Eutrophication is a major threat: Increased fire frequency, agricultural runoff, and urban development are all contributing to elevated soil P levels, leading to shifts in plant community composition, favoring less P-sensitive and more competitive species at the expense of the unique flora adapted to infertile conditions.
  • Understanding molecular mechanisms is key: The authors emphasize that a deeper understanding of how phosphite works at the molecular level, particularly its interaction with plant P-signaling pathways, is essential for developing truly effective and sustainable alternatives.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present new quantitative results but synthesizes findings from numerous studies:

  • Biodiversity correlation with low P: A consistent pattern is observed where the highest plant diversity in southwestern Australia is found on the most P-impoverished soils.
  • Phosphite application increases soil P: Evidence suggests that regular phosphite spraying, at rates comparable to annual P fertilization, leads to an inexorable increase in soil P over time.
  • Impact on plant communities: Studies in Gull Rock National Park show that phosphite application, alongside P. cinnamomi infestation, negatively impacts species composition and diversity, with unsprayed, infested sites showing the lowest diversity.
  • Leaf P increase with phosphite: In the Stirling Range National Park, Banksia anatona and other species showed significantly increased leaf P concentrations in areas treated with phosphite, even in the absence of P. cinnamomi.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phosphite's precise molecular mechanism: While phosphite's effects are observed, its exact molecular mode of action in plants, particularly concerning P-signaling networks, remains incompletely understood. This knowledge gap hinders the development of precise alternatives.
  • Long-term impacts of phosphite: The long-term consequences of phosphite application on native plant communities and ecosystem structure are not fully elucidated, though initial studies suggest negative impacts on diversity.
  • Developing alternatives: The paper strongly advocates for urgent research into alternative compounds that can induce plant defense against P. cinnamomi without contributing to P enrichment. This requires a deeper understanding of phosphite's metabolic targets.
  • Epigenetic inheritance: The possibility that phosphite-induced resistance might be passed to offspring via epigenetic modifications is an exciting avenue for future research, potentially leading to more sustainable, inheritable defense mechanisms.
  • Broader applicability: The threats and challenges discussed for southwestern Australia are likely relevant to other P-impoverished biodiversity hotspots globally, such as the fynbos in South Africa and the cerrado in Brazil, suggesting a need for similar research and conservation efforts in these regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

South-western Australia harbours a global biodiversity hotspot on the world's most phosphorus (P)-impoverished soils. The greatest biodiversity occurs on the most severely nutrient-impoverished soils, where non-mycorrhizal species are a prominent component of the flora. Mycorrhizal species dominate where soils contain slightly more phosphorus. In addition to habitat loss and dryland salinity, a major threat to plant biodiversity in this region is eutrophication due to enrichment with P. Many plant species in the south-western Australian biodiversity hotspot are extremely sensitive to P, due to a low capability to down-regulate their phosphate-uptake capacity. Species from the most P-impoverished soils are also very poor competitors at higher P availability, giving way to more competitive species when soil P concentrations are increased. Sources of increased soil P concentrations include increased fire frequency, run-off from agricultural land, and urban activities. Another P source is the P-fertilizing effect of spraying natural environments on a landscape scale with phosphite to reduce the impacts of the introduced plant pathogen Phytophthora cinnamomi, which itself is a serious threat to biodiversity. We argue that alternatives to phosphite for P. cinnamomi management are needed urgently, and propose a strategy to work towards such alternatives, based on a sound understanding of the physiological and molecular mechanisms of the action of phosphite in plants that are susceptible to P. cinnamomi. The threats we describe for the south-western Australian biodiversity hotspot are likely to be very similar for other P-impoverished environments, including the fynbos in South Africa and the cerrado in Brazil.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lambers2013phosphorus,
  author = {Hans Lambers and I. Ahmedi and Oliver Berkowitz and C. Dunne and Patrick M. Finnegan and G.E.St.J. Hardy and Ricarda Jost and Étienne Laliberté and Stuart J. Pearse and François P. Teste},
  title = {{Phosphorus nutrition of phosphorus-sensitive Australian native plants: threats to plant communities in a global biodiversity hotspot}},
  booktitle = {Conservation},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1093/conphys/cot010},
}

Loading related content...

Figure