Philosophical Analysis of Phenomena in Live Video Streaming

Yuanyuan Zhang, Qian WangPhilosophy 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into the philosophical underpinnings of live video streaming, arguing that its ethical issues stem from cognitive fragmentation and a lack of self-discipline, exacerbated by the platform's design. It proposes leveraging traditional Chinese philosophical concepts to foster better judgment and self-control, moving beyond mere external supervision.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Live video streaming, while offering unprecedented convenience and immersive experiences, has also given rise to phenomena that challenge public order and good deeds. These range from the broadcasting of vulgar and even criminal content to impulsive financial "tipping" by audiences. The paper identifies a gap in addressing these issues by focusing solely on external controls like legal and social supervision, which have proven insufficient. It argues for a deeper, philosophical examination to understand the root causes and propose more fundamental solutions.

Methods

The paper employs a philosophical analysis approach, drawing on epistemology and applied ethics. It dissects the inherent characteristics of live video streaming, such as its low threshold for broadcasting, decentralization, and profit models, to understand how they contribute to negative phenomena. The authors then propose solutions rooted in traditional Chinese philosophy, specifically the concepts of "observing things by Heart" and "emotion dominated by rationality."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cognitive Fragmentation as a Root Cause: The paper posits that the fragmented nature of live video streaming content, which stimulates senses and distracts attention, leads to a lack of comprehensive thinking and judgment. This makes audiences susceptible to impulsive behavior and less aware of their social responsibilities.
  • The "Tipping" Phenomenon: The voluntary "tipping" mechanism, while providing economic benefits, is highlighted as a key area where audiences exhibit impulsive behavior, often driven by superficial attraction to hosts rather than rational consideration.
  • Decentralization and Lack of Standards: The decentralized nature of live streaming, while democratizing content creation, also leads to a lack of unified standards for content, values, and aesthetics, making effective supervision difficult.
  • The "Law of Bad Money Driving Out Good Money" Analogy: The paper suggests that shallow and vulgar content, which requires less investment and can gain wider reach, may overshadow more meaningful and educational content, similar to how less valuable currency can displace more valuable currency.
  • The Power of Traditional Chinese Philosophy: The authors propose that concepts like "observing things by Heart" (holistic, embodied thinking) and "emotion dominated by rationality" (controlling emotions with moral principles) offer valuable frameworks for cultivating rational judgment and self-discipline, which are crucial for navigating the challenges of live video streaming.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results as it is a philosophical analysis. Its key findings are qualitative insights into the underlying causes of ethical issues in live video streaming and proposed philosophical solutions. The authors argue that by fostering internal capacities for rational judgment and self-discipline, rather than relying solely on external controls, the negative phenomena associated with live video streaming can be more effectively addressed.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that while external measures like laws and social supervision are necessary, they are insufficient on their own. The authors emphasize the need for improving participants' abilities of rational judgment and self-discipline through education and publicity. Future work could involve exploring practical applications of the proposed Chinese philosophical concepts in educational programs or platform design to mitigate the negative effects of live video streaming. The paper also implicitly suggests that further research could investigate how to effectively integrate these philosophical insights into practical governance and supervision strategies for live video streaming platforms.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017philosophical,
  author = {Yuanyuan Zhang and Qian Wang},
  title = {{Philosophical Analysis of Phenomena in Live Video Streaming}},
  booktitle = {Philosophy},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.17265/2159-5313/2017.06.004},
}
Figure