Phenotypic Variation in a Species Range: Another Look (Developmental Stability Study of the Meristic Variation in the Sand Lizard Lacerta agilis)

Vladimir Zakharov, Nadezhda P. Zhdanova, Ilya TrofimovSymmetry 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how environmental temperature influences the developmental stability and overall phenotypic variation in the sand lizard, Lacerta agilis. By analyzing meristic traits (scale counts) in both laboratory experiments and natural populations, the researchers found that extreme temperatures increase developmental variability, suggesting that peripheral populations might experience greater phenotypic diversity due to environmental stress.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the sources of phenotypic variation within a species' range is a fundamental challenge in population and developmental biology. While genetic differences are often assumed to be the primary driver, environmental factors and "developmental noise" (random fluctuations during development) also play significant roles. This paper aims to disentangle these influences by examining how developmental stability, a measure of an organism's ability to buffer against developmental noise, varies across different environmental conditions and geographic locations within the sand lizard's range. Specifically, it addresses how temperature, a key environmental factor, impacts both overall phenotypic variation and developmental stability, and whether this relationship holds true in natural populations at the extremes of their geographic distribution.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Laboratory Experiment: Sand lizard eggs were incubated at a range of constant temperatures (20, 22, 25, 27, 30, and 32 °C) to assess the direct impact of temperature on developmental variability.
  • Natural Population Study: Samples of sand lizards were collected from 32 geographic locations across the European part of the species' range, spanning from the Vologda region in the north to the Krasnodar region in the south.

The researchers focused on 13 meristic characters of pholidosis (scale counts). To quantify variation, they used two key metrics:

  • Total Phenotypic Variability: Assessed by the variance of the sum of character values on the left and right sides of the body ($ \overline{\sigma^2_{\Sigma}} $).
  • Developmental Variability (Developmental Stability): Assessed by the variance of the difference in character values on the left and right sides of the body ($ \overline{\sigma^2_d} $). This metric is a measure of fluctuating asymmetry, indicating the degree of developmental noise.

Generalized variance was used to assess variation across the set of characters, and the ratio of developmental variability to total phenotypic variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_d} / \overline{\sigma^2_{\Sigma}} $) was calculated to understand the relative contribution of developmental noise. Statistical tests (F-statistic and Friedman's tests) were used to evaluate differences.

Datasets

  • Laboratory Experiment Data: Eggs from pregnant Lacerta agilis females from the Voronezh region, Russia, incubated at controlled temperatures. 180 specimens were analyzed.
  • Natural Population Data: Samples from 32 geographic points in the European part of the Lacerta agilis range (from 59.20° N to 44.61° N). 805 individuals were studied. The collection was sourced from the Zoological Museum of Moscow State University.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temperature as a Key Regulator: Temperature has a profound impact on both total phenotypic variability and developmental stability. There appears to be an "optimal" temperature (around 25 °C in the lab) where variability is minimized.
  • Asymmetric Response to Temperature: Developmental variability increases more sharply with decreasing temperatures than with increasing temperatures from the optimum. This suggests that cold stress might be a more significant driver of developmental instability than heat stress.
  • Peripheral Populations Under Stress: In natural populations, developmental variability increases towards the northern and southern peripheries of the species' range. This suggests that populations at the edges of the distribution may be experiencing more adverse environmental conditions, leading to higher developmental noise.
  • Total Phenotypic Variability Behaves Differently: Unlike developmental variability, total phenotypic variability shows no clear geographic trend across the species' range in natural populations, despite its clear temperature dependence in the lab. This implies that other factors, such as genotype-environment interactions, might be more influential in shaping overall phenotypic diversity in natural settings.
  • Developmental Noise's Significant Role: The study highlights that developmental noise can contribute significantly to phenotypic variation, even more so than genetic differences in some contexts, particularly under suboptimal environmental conditions.

Key Results

  • In the laboratory experiment, minimal total phenotypic variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_{\Sigma}} $) and developmental variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_d} $) were observed at 25 °C. Variability increased significantly at both higher and lower temperatures (p < 0.01).
  • In natural populations, developmental variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_d} $) increased towards the northern and southern peripheries of the range (p < 0.05), with the highest values found in the northern periphery.
  • No clear geographic trend was observed for total phenotypic variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_{\Sigma}} $) in natural populations.
  • The proportion of developmental variability in total phenotypic variability ($ \overline{\sigma^2_d} / \overline{\sigma^2_{\Sigma}} $) was higher in the northern and southern peripheries of the range compared to the central part.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Laboratory vs. Natural Conditions: The study notes that while laboratory experiments reveal strong temperature effects, the maximum levels of developmental variability observed in natural populations did not reach those seen at extreme laboratory temperatures. This could be due to a narrower range of effective temperatures in nature, or the influence of fluctuating temperatures and other environmental factors not fully captured by constant incubation regimes.
  • Genotype-Environment Interaction: The discrepancy between experimental and natural population data for total phenotypic variability suggests that genotype-environment interactions play a crucial role in shaping diversity in natural settings, a factor that was not directly quantified in this study.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the importance of simultaneously studying total phenotypic variability and developmental variability to gain a comprehensive understanding of phenotypic diversity across a species' range. Future work could explore the impact of fluctuating temperatures, other environmental stressors, and the specific genetic underpinnings of developmental stability in different populations. Investigating how these factors interact to influence adaptation and evolution in peripheral populations would also be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zakharov2022phenotypic,
  author = {Vladimir Zakharov and Nadezhda P. Zhdanova and Ilya Trofimov},
  title = {{Phenotypic Variation in a Species Range: Another Look (Developmental Stability Study of the Meristic Variation in the Sand Lizard Lacerta agilis)}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/sym14112426},
}
Figure