Phase-Field Investigation of Lithium Electrodeposition at Different Applied Overpotentials and Operating Temperatures

Joonyeob Jeon, Gil Ho Yoon, Tejs Vegge, Jin Hyun ChangACS 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a sophisticated phase-field model to investigate how applied voltage (overpotential) and temperature affect lithium metal dendrite formation in batteries. They found that while higher overpotentials and temperatures generally promote dendrite growth, there's an "optimal" operating temperature that can inhibit it, and this optimum shifts with the applied voltage. Crucially, they highlight that comparing experimental results from different testing conditions (galvanostatic vs. potentiostatic) requires careful consideration due to how temperature influences current and voltage differently in each.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lithium metal anodes hold immense promise for next-generation batteries due to their high energy density. However, their practical application is severely hampered by the formation of lithium dendrites during charging. These needle-like structures can pierce the separator, leading to short circuits, battery failure, and safety hazards. While much research has focused on understanding dendrite formation and suppression, the interplay between two key operational parameters – applied overpotential (the driving force for lithium deposition) and operating temperature – remains incompletely understood. This lack of clarity makes it difficult to design batteries that operate reliably across a range of conditions.

Methods

The authors employ a phase-field model to simulate lithium electrodeposition. This is a powerful computational technique that tracks the evolution of interfaces between different phases (in this case, the lithium metal anode and the electrolyte) by solving a set of partial differential equations.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Coupling of Equations: They integrate the Allen-Cahn equation (describing interface evolution) with a modified Butler-Volmer equation (describing electrochemical reaction kinetics).
  • Temperature-Dependent Parameters: A significant contribution is the explicit inclusion of temperature-dependent properties for crucial parameters like exchange current density, ionic diffusivity, electrode and electrolyte conductivity, and surface tension. These dependencies are derived from experimental data.
  • Two-Dimensional Simulation: The simulations are performed in a 2D domain representing a Li metal anode and electrolyte.
  • Assessment Metrics: Dendrite formation is quantified using two metrics: dendrite height (the difference between the peak height and average height of the Li metal surface) and tortuosity (a measure of surface roughness). They establish threshold values for these metrics to define the onset of dendrite formation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on established literature values for various physical and chemical parameters, which are temperature-dependent and incorporated into their model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Li-ion Concentration as a Predictor: The paper validates a key finding from previous work: dendrite formation can be predicted early by observing the Li-ion concentration profile at the interface. Dendrites form when this concentration drops below the bulk electrolyte concentration, indicating a transport-limited deposition process.
  • Optimal Temperature for Dendrite Suppression: Contrary to a simple "higher temperature = more dendrites" assumption, the study identifies an "optimal operating temperature" that can inhibit dendrite formation. This optimum shifts with the applied overpotential, generally increasing as the overpotential magnitude increases.
  • Galvanostatic vs. Potentiostatic Discrepancy: A critical insight is the warning against directly comparing experimental results obtained under galvanostatic (constant current) and potentiostatic (constant voltage) conditions, especially when analyzing temperature effects. Temperature affects induced current and overpotential differently in each mode, leading to potentially contradictory observations if not accounted for.
  • Smooth Transition to Dendrites: The study demonstrates that the transition from a dendrite-free to a dendritic regime is gradual, not abrupt. This is supported by the continuous change in tortuosity and dendrite height.

Key Results

  • Overpotential's Role: Increasing the magnitude of the applied overpotential consistently lowers the onset point for dendrite formation and generally increases dendrite height and tortuosity.
  • Temperature's Complex Role: While higher temperatures generally accelerate electrodeposition (reducing the time to reach a certain Li height), their effect on dendrite formation is more nuanced. An optimal temperature range exists for inhibiting dendrites, and this range shifts with overpotential.
  • Threshold Criteria: The authors establish quantitative thresholds for dendrite height (around 2.05 µm) and tortuosity (around 1.014) to define dendrite formation.
  • Onset Point Dependence: The onset point for dendrite formation decreases monotonically with increasing overpotential. The temperature dependence of the onset point is non-linear, with an optimal temperature that shifts with overpotential.

Limitations and Future Work

  • SEI Neglect: The authors acknowledge that their model omits the effect of the solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI). The SEI plays a crucial role in dendrite formation and growth, and its accurate modeling is a significant challenge. Future work should aim to incorporate SEI formation and evolution.
  • 2D Simplification: The simulations are performed in 2D. While this captures essential physics, a 3D model would provide a more realistic representation of dendrite growth.
  • Combined Potentiostatic/Galvanostatic Study: The authors suggest that future research should combine potentiostatic and galvanostatic investigations, potentially incorporating internal heat generation, convection, and radiation, for a more comprehensive understanding of dendrite formation mechanisms.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: While temperature-dependent parameters are included, a detailed sensitivity analysis of other parameters could further refine the model's predictive capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Li metal is an exciting anode for high-energy Li-ion batteries and other future battery technologies due to its high energy density and low redox potential. Despite their high promise, the commercialization of Li-metal-based batteries has been hampered due to the formation of dendrites that lead to mechanical instability, energy loss, and eventual internal short circuits. In recent years, the mechanism of dendrite formation and the strategies to suppress their growth have been studied intensely. However, the effect of applied overpotential and operating temperature on dendrite formation and their growth rate remains to be fully understood. Here, we elucidate the correlation between the applied overpotential and operating temperature to the dendrite height and tortuosity of the Li-metal surface during electrodeposition using phase-field model simulations. We identify an optimal operating temperature of a half-cell consisting of a Li metal anode and 1 M LiPF<sub>6</sub> in EC/DMC (1/1), which increases gradually as the magnitude of the overpotential increases. The investigation reveals that the temperature dependence identified in the simulations and experiments often disagree because they are primarily conducted under galvanostatic and potentiostatic conditions, respectively. The temperature increase under potentiostatic conditions increases the induced current while it decreases the induced overpotential under galvanostatic conditions. Therefore, the analysis and comparison of temperature-dependent characteristics must be carried out with care.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jeon2022phase,
  author = {Joonyeob Jeon and Gil Ho Yoon and Tejs Vegge and Jin Hyun Chang},
  title = {{Phase-Field Investigation of Lithium Electrodeposition at Different Applied Overpotentials and Operating Temperatures}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1021/acsami.2c00900},
}
Figure