Pervasive hybridization during evolutionary radiation ofRhododendronsubgenusHymenanthesin mountains of southwest China

Yazhen Ma, Xingxing Mao, Ji Wang, Lei Zhang, Yuanzhong Jiang, Yuying Geng, Tao Ma, Liming Cai, Shuang‐Quan Huang, Peter M. Hollingsworth, Kangshan Mao, Minghui Kang, Yiling Li, Wenlu Yang, Haolin Wu, Yang Chen, Charles C. Davis, Nawal Shrestha, Richard H. Ree, Zhenxiang Xi, Quanjun Hu, Richard I. Milne, Jianquan LiuNational 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that pervasive hybridization played a significant role in the evolutionary radiation of Rhododendron subgenus Hymenanthes in the mountains of southwest China. By analyzing extensive genomic data from 143 species, the researchers found evidence of widespread hybridization events occurring both early and late in the diversification process, suggesting a crucial interplay between isolation and gene flow in generating species diversity in these complex mountainous ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Evolutionary radiations, the rapid diversification of species from a common ancestor, are particularly common in challenging environments like mountains. While geographical and ecological isolation are often cited as the primary drivers of speciation in these regions, the role of hybridization – the mixing of genetic material between different species or populations – has been less explored, especially using comprehensive genomic data. This paper addresses the question of whether hybridization contributed to the remarkable species diversity within Rhododendron subgenus Hymenanthes, a group known for its geographic isolation in the mountains of southwest China. Understanding this contribution is key to unraveling the complex mechanisms that generate biodiversity in such environments.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted genomic approach. They generated a high-quality, chromosome-level reference genome for Rhododendron prattii using a combination of SMRT sequencing, Illumina sequencing, 10x Genomics, and Hi-C mapping. This reference genome was then used to analyze whole-genome resequencing data from 164 individuals representing 143 species of Hymenanthes, along with 93 species from four other Rhododendron subgenera.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Phylogenetic inference: Constructing a time-calibrated species tree using nuclear genome Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) and chloroplast DNA (plastome) data to understand evolutionary relationships and divergence times.
  • Hybridization detection: Employing statistical methods like Patterson's D-statistics (ABBA-BABA test) and the "f-branch" metric to identify signals of historical gene flow and admixture between lineages, clades, and species.
  • Haplotype analysis: Examining identity-by-descent (IBD) blocks to quantify haplotype sharing between species, indicating recent interspecific gene flow.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): To visualize genetic differentiation between subgenera.

The study also took care to minimize the impact of recent hybridization by genotyping multiple natural populations of widespread species and selecting individuals with pure genetic composition for sequencing.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this study are:

  • Newly sequenced genomes: Whole-genome resequencing data from 164 individuals of 143 Rhododendron subgenus Hymenanthes species, and 93 individuals from four other Rhododendron subgenera.
  • Reference genome: A newly assembled, chromosome-level genome for Rhododendron prattii.
  • Existing genomic data: Used for comparison of repeat content and gene family numbers.

The raw sequencing data has been deposited in the Genome Sequence Archive (National Genomics Data Center), and the genome assembly and annotation are available in the Genome Warehouse.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybridization as a driver of mountain radiation: The study provides strong genomic evidence that hybridization is not just a byproduct but an active contributor to the diversification of Hymenanthes in mountainous regions, challenging the traditional view that isolation is the sole driver.
  • Early and late hybridization: Hybridization events were not confined to a single period but occurred both early in the diversification of Hymenanthes and more recently, suggesting a persistent role throughout its evolutionary history.
  • Phylogenetic discordance as a signal of hybridization: Significant topological conflicts between nuclear and plastome phylogenies, and between different nuclear datasets, strongly indicate that hybridization and introgression have shaped the evolutionary history of this subgenus.
  • "Sky island" dynamics: The findings align with the concept of "sky islands" in mountains, where cycles of connection and isolation can facilitate both divergence and hybridization, creating a complex web of genetic exchange.
  • Widespread genetic admixture: Extensive sharing of genetic material (IBD blocks and excess allele sharing) across various taxonomic levels (lineages, clades, subclades, and species) underscores the pervasive nature of hybridization.

Key Results

  • Monophyletic Hymenanthes: The study confirmed that Rhododendron subgenus Hymenanthes is a monophyletic group.
  • Radiation timing: The subgenus underwent significant diversification from the late Oligocene to the middle Miocene, coinciding with periods of increased geological and climatic oscillations in southwest China.
  • Hybridization signals: Approximately 34.2% of all possible species triplets showed significant evidence of hybridization.
  • Extensive allele sharing: 22.7% of species-branch pairs exhibited significant excess allele sharing, indicating gene flow between lineages. A total of 238 out of 278 branches in the nuclear species tree showed significant excess allele sharing with at least one other species.
  • Morphological vs. genomic data: The genomic analyses revealed that many traditional classifications based on morphology do not reflect the true evolutionary relationships, highlighting the power of genomic data in resolving complex evolutionary histories.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Quantifying the acceleration effect: While the study demonstrates pervasive hybridization, the authors acknowledge that the exact extent to which hybridization accelerated diversification (e.g., through mixing-isolation-mixing or hybrid speciation) requires further exploration.
  • Distinguishing historical vs. recent hybridization: Although efforts were made to exclude recent hybrids, the pervasive nature of hybridization means that the signals of the oldest events might be obscured by younger ones.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that similar models of isolation and hybridization likely apply to other mountainous floras and faunas worldwide, indicating a broad applicability of their findings. Further research could focus on disentangling the specific mechanisms of hybrid speciation and quantifying their precise contribution to diversification rates in Hymenanthes and other groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

Radiations are especially important for generating species biodiversity in mountainous ecosystems. The contribution of hybridization to such radiations has rarely been examined. Here, we use extensive genomic data to test whether hybridization was involved in evolutionary radiation within <i>Rhododendron</i> subgenus <i>Hymenanthes</i>, whose members show strong geographic isolation in the mountains of southwest China. We sequenced genomes for 143 species of this subgenus and 93 species of four other subgenera, and found that <i>Hymenanthes</i> was monophyletic and radiated during the late Oligocene to middle Miocene. Widespread hybridization events were inferred within and between the identified clades and subclades. This suggests that hybridization occurred both early and late during diversification of subgenus <i>Hymenanthes</i>, although the extent to which hybridization, speciation through mixing-isolation-mixing or hybrid speciation, accelerated the diversification needs further exploration. Cycles of isolation and contact in such and other montane ecosystems may have together promoted species radiation through hybridization between diverging populations and species. Similar radiation processes may apply to other montane floras in this region and elsewhere.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2022pervasive,
  author = {Yazhen Ma and Xingxing Mao and Ji Wang and Lei Zhang and Yuanzhong Jiang and Yuying Geng and Tao Ma and Liming Cai and Shuang‐Quan Huang and Peter M. Hollingsworth and Kangshan Mao and Minghui Kang and Yiling Li and Wenlu Yang and Haolin Wu and Yang Chen and Charles C. Davis and Nawal Shrestha and Richard H. Ree and Zhenxiang Xi and Quanjun Hu and Richard I. Milne and Jianquan Liu},
  title = {{Pervasive hybridization during evolutionary radiation of<i>Rhododendron</i>subgenus<i>Hymenanthes</i>in mountains of southwest China}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwac276},
}
Figure