TL;DR
This study analyzes over a century of pertussis data in South Australia, revealing a dramatic decline in mortality and hospitalizations but a recent surge in reported cases since 1993. The shift towards more sensitive diagnostic tests, particularly serology, appears to be driving this increase in notifications, especially among older age groups.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Pertussis, or whooping cough, has historically been a significant childhood illness. While widespread vaccination and improved treatments have drastically reduced its severity and mortality, understanding current trends and the factors influencing disease reporting is crucial for public health. This paper addresses the question of how pertussis epidemiology has evolved in South Australia over a long period, specifically investigating the reasons behind a recent, unexpected rise in reported cases despite declining mortality and hospitalization rates. The authors aim to disentangle the effects of vaccination, diagnostic advancements, and true incidence changes.
Methods
The researchers employed a retrospective analysis of three distinct data sources to track pertussis trends in South Australia from 1893 to 1996:
- Mortality Data: Sourced from South Australian yearbooks, providing records of deaths attributed to pertussis dating back to 1893.
- Notification Data: Obtained from the South Australian Health Commission's notifiable diseases register, covering medical practitioner and laboratory notifications from 1909 onwards, with detailed age and diagnostic method data available from 1984.
- Hospitalisation Data: Extracted from the Inpatient Separations Information System (ISIS) database, detailing hospital discharges for pertussis or related complications from July 1985.
Crude and age-specific rates for mortality, notifications, and hospitalizations were calculated using Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) population estimates. Statistical analysis was performed using Epi-Info 6.02. A key methodological aspect was the retrospective review of notification forms to ascertain the laboratory diagnostic methods used in specific years, allowing for an assessment of the impact of changing testing strategies.
Datasets
- South Australian Yearbooks (1893-1996): Provided mortality data for pertussis.
- South Australian Health Commission Notifiable Diseases Register (1917-1996): Supplied notification data, with detailed age and diagnostic information available from 1984.
- Inpatient Separations Information System (ISIS) Database (July 1985-1996): Contained hospitalisation data for pertussis and related complications.
- Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Population Estimates: Used for calculating age-specific rates.
No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing historical public health data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Diagnostic Shift is Key: The most striking insight is the dramatic increase in pertussis notifications since 1993, which doesn't correlate with increased mortality or hospitalizations. This strongly suggests that the adoption of more sensitive diagnostic tests, particularly serology, has led to the detection and reporting of milder or previously undiagnosed cases, especially in older individuals.
- Pertussis is Shifting Demographically: While historically a childhood disease, the median age of pertussis notifications has significantly increased, from 4 years in 1984 to 15 years in 1996. This highlights that pertussis is no longer solely a concern for young children.
- Infants Remain Most Vulnerable: Despite the rise in older case notifications, infants under 6 months remain the most vulnerable group, bearing the brunt of severe disease requiring hospitalization. This is critical because they are too young to be fully protected by the primary vaccination series.
- Long-Term Decline is Real: The study confirms a substantial, long-term decline in pertussis mortality and notification rates since the turn of the century, largely attributed to mass vaccination programs initiated in the 1950s and the availability of antibiotics.
Key Results
- Mortality: A significant decline in pertussis mortality rates has occurred since 1893. No deaths due to pertussis have been reported in South Australia since 1967.
- Notifications: While notification rates generally declined over time, a significant increase was observed starting in 1993, with 1,351 notifications recorded, a seven-fold increase compared to the preceding 20 years.
- Age Distribution: The median age for pertussis notifications increased from 4 years in 1986 to 15 years in 1996. In 1993, for the first time, the notification rate in the 5-14 year age group exceeded that of infants under 6 months.
- Diagnostic Testing: The proportion of notified cases confirmed by serological testing rose dramatically from 15% in 1985 to 90% in 1996, while culture-based diagnosis decreased from 71% to 2% over the same period.
- Hospitalizations: The highest rates of hospital admissions for pertussis consistently occurred in infants aged 6 months and under. While overall hospitalizations didn't substantially increase in the recent surge, the year 1993 saw a notable rise in admissions for children under 15.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Under-reporting: Notification data is known to be incomplete, with fewer infants aged ≤ 6 months notified than hospitalized, suggesting that notified cases represent a smaller proportion of actual disease in this age group.
- Misclassification: Potential misclassification of acute disease in adults is noted, particularly with the introduction of new case definitions.
- Diagnostic Accuracy: The accuracy of coding procedures in the hospital discharge database (ISIS) prior to an audit in 1994 is a concern.
- Interpretation Complexity: The cyclical nature of pertussis and the introduction of new diagnostic tests make interpreting data from only a few years complex.
Future work could involve:
- Sustained Epidemic vs. Diagnostic Shift: Further investigation is needed to definitively determine whether the current trend represents a sustained epidemic or is primarily an artifact of more sensitive diagnostic testing.
- Impact of Newer Vaccines: While not discussed in this paper (which predates newer acellular vaccines), future research would likely focus on the impact of these vaccines on pertussis epidemiology.
- National Comparisons: Expanding the analysis to a national level could provide a broader understanding of pertussis trends in Australia.
Summary updated