Perturbations during Gait: A Systematic Review of Methodologies and Outcomes

Zoe Taylor, Gregory S. Walsh, Hannah Hawkins, Mario Inacio, Patrick Esser2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This systematic review synthesizes current methods for applying balance perturbations during gait and the outcome variables used to measure responses. It highlights a wide variety of perturbation techniques and a significant lack of standardization, which complicates the interpretation of results and the translation of findings into clinical practice.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Assessing balance is crucial for understanding fall risk, especially in older adults. Perturbation testing is a common method to evaluate how individuals maintain balance when their equilibrium is challenged. However, the field has seen a proliferation of different perturbation methods (e.g., treadmill translations, waist pulls, visual stimuli) and outcome measures (e.g., step width, joint angles, muscle activity) without a clear consensus on best practices. This lack of standardization makes it difficult to compare results across studies, hinders the development of reliable fall risk assessment tools, and impedes the translation of research findings into clinical applications. This paper aims to address this by systematically reviewing and summarizing the diverse perturbation methodologies and outcome variables currently employed in gait research.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature review, searching Web of Science, CINAHL, and PubMed for studies published from 2015 onwards. They included studies involving participants aged 18 years or older who experienced mechanical balance perturbations during gait, and where biomechanical outcomes (kinetic, kinematic, spatiotemporal, or muscle activation) were reported. Excluded were studies where perturbations didn't occur during continuous gait, or were non-mechanical, observational, or literature reviews.

Data extraction focused on participant demographics, perturbation methods (type, duration, intensity, timing), and outcome variables. A qualitative analysis was performed to synthesize the findings. Risk of bias was assessed using the Appraisal tool for Cross-sectional Studies (AXIS) tool.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a systematic review of existing literature, not an empirical study that collects new data or uses specific datasets for training/evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Methodological Chaos: The sheer diversity in how balance perturbations are applied is striking. From simple treadmill translations to complex wearable devices and even physical therapist interventions, there's no single "standard" approach. This makes direct comparisons between studies challenging.
  • Outcome Variable Overload: Similarly, the range of outcome variables measured is vast, encompassing spatiotemporal (step width, length), kinetic (ground reaction forces), kinematic (joint angles, CoM sway), and muscle activation data. While this provides a rich picture, it also contributes to the lack of standardization.
  • The Treadmill Reigns Supreme (Mostly): Mediolateral (ML) treadmill belt translation emerged as the most frequent perturbation method. However, this doesn't imply it's the most effective or universally applicable.
  • Spatiotemporal Dominance: Spatiotemporal variables, particularly step width, are the most commonly reported outcomes. This suggests a focus on observable gait characteristics, but the authors hint that incorporating kinetic and kinematic data could offer deeper insights.
  • Risk of Bias is Pervasive: All included studies showed some risk of bias, often related to reporting of sampling approaches. This further complicates the interpretation of findings.
  • Clinical Translation Hurdle: The lack of standardization in both perturbation methods and outcome measures is a significant barrier to translating research findings into practical clinical tools for fall risk assessment and intervention.

Key Results

  • 33 studies were included in the review, totaling 779 participants.
  • The most frequent perturbation method was treadmill translation (19 studies used treadmills, 14 used overground walking).
  • The most frequent outcome variable was participant step width, followed closely by step length.
  • Large variations were reported in perturbation type, duration, intensity, and outcome variables across studies.
  • Despite the diversity, there was some agreement on increased muscle activation, dynamic stability, MoS, BoS, peak vGRF, and step time, and decreased CoP motion when participants' CoM was perturbed. However, conflicting results were found for step width and length.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Age Exclusion: While the protocol initially focused on older adults (>65), it was broadened to include all adults (18+) to capture a wider range of perturbation methods. This broader scope might have introduced more variability.
  • Publication Bias: The search was limited to publications from 2015 onwards, potentially excluding relevant earlier work.
  • Participant Heterogeneity: The lack of strict exclusion criteria for participant parameters (age, condition, fall history) led to a wide variety of populations, contributing to the heterogeneity of results.
  • Focus on Kinetic/Kinematic: The review focused on kinetic and kinematic biomechanical outcomes. The authors suggest that an up-to-date review on central and peripheral motor control measurements would be beneficial.

Future work should focus on:

  • Standardization: Developing standardized perturbation protocols and outcome variable sets is crucial for improving the interpretability and clinical applicability of gait perturbation research.
  • Clinical Application: Active mechanical perturbation holds promise for identifying fallers, but this requires standardized testing methods and outcome variables that accurately assess fall risk.
  • Novel Approaches: Exploring novel approaches in motor control and psychometric measurement properties would further advance the field.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{taylor2022perturbations,
  author = {Zoe Taylor and Gregory S. Walsh and Hannah Hawkins and Mario Inacio and Patrick Esser},
  title = {{Perturbations during Gait: A Systematic Review of Methodologies and Outcomes}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22155927},
}
Figure