TL;DR
This study analyzes Chinese tourists' online travel notes about Seoul to understand their urban tourism experience (UTE). By combining content analysis, social network analysis (SNA), and modified importance-performance analysis (MIPA), the research identifies key UTE elements, their interrelationships, and overall satisfaction, offering insights for Seoul's tourism recovery post-COVID-19.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic has severely impacted global tourism, particularly for destinations like Seoul that rely heavily on international visitors. As tourism begins to recover, understanding the specific demands and experiences of key tourist demographics is crucial for effective recovery strategies. Chinese tourists represent a significant market for Seoul, and their travel experiences, especially in the context of evolving travel behaviors influenced by the pandemic, need in-depth analysis. Existing research often relies on traditional methods with limited sample sizes or struggles to capture the complex relationships between various aspects of a tourism experience. This paper aims to address this gap by using a novel approach to analyze a large dataset of online travel notes to provide a comprehensive understanding of Chinese tourists' UTE in Seoul.
Methods
The study employs a mixed-methods approach:
- Manual Content Analysis: This was the initial step to extract and categorize Urban Tourism Experience (UTE) elements from the travel notes. Two trained operators systematically read and encoded tourist perceptions, creating a structured table of 28 UTE elements for Seoul. This method aimed to overcome limitations of automated text analysis by allowing for nuanced interpretation.
- Social Network Analysis (SNA): Used to analyze the structural characteristics and interrelationships between the identified UTE elements. SNA helps visualize how different elements are connected and their relative importance within the overall tourism experience network. Tools like UCINET and Netdraw were used for this analysis.
- Modified Importance-Performance Analysis (MIPA): This technique assesses both the perceived importance of UTE elements by tourists and their actual performance (satisfaction) with those elements. MIPA, with its introduction of a 45-degree slash, provides a more nuanced understanding of strengths and weaknesses compared to traditional IPA, helping to identify areas for improvement.
Datasets
The primary dataset consists of 1750 online travel notes posted by Chinese tourists about Seoul, collected from the Mafengwo website (www.mafengwo.cn). These notes were written between January 1 and December 30, 2019, to capture pre-pandemic travel patterns. After screening for relevance and quality, the dataset comprised 216 travelogues with a total of 281,400 words. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing online travel notes were utilized as a rich source of qualitative data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Interconnectedness of Experience: UTE elements are not isolated but form a complex, interconnected network. Understanding these relationships is key to grasping the overall tourist experience.
- "Korean Wave" as a Major Driver: Elements related to the "Korean Wave" (K-pop, K-dramas) are highly influential, often linked with shopping, catering, and even specific filming locations. This highlights the power of cultural content in driving tourism.
- Smart Tourism Technology is Essential: Chinese tourists increasingly rely on smart tourism technology for information, navigation, and payment, indicating a need for robust digital infrastructure.
- The Paradox of "Core" Elements: While traditional elements like shopping and catering are highly important, tourist satisfaction with them is not meeting expectations, suggesting a gap between perceived importance and actual delivery.
- Cultural Homology Reduces Appeal: For Chinese tourists, traditional Korean culture may hold less mystery and attraction compared to other Asian cultures due to shared cultural roots, impacting its perceived novelty.
- Photoshoot as a Key Experience: The desire to capture personal moments and "look for themselves" makes photoshoots a significant part of the tourism experience, especially for younger travelers.
Key Results
- 28 UTE Elements Identified: Through content analysis, 28 distinct elements of Seoul's urban tourism experience were identified.
- High Network Density: SNA revealed a high network density (0.55) and clustering coefficient (0.707), indicating strong internal coordination among UTE elements.
- Core Elements Identified: The most important UTE elements, based on degree centrality, include Catering, Communication, Smart City, Shopping, Prices, Photoshoot, International Travel, and Korean Wave.
- MIPA Quadrant Analysis:
- Quadrant I (Keep Up The Work): Seven elements (catering, smart city, shopping, accommodation, human environment, photoshoot, recreation) are highly important and well-received. However, shopping and catering showed a gap between importance and satisfaction.
- Quadrant II (Possible Overkill): Seven elements (natural environment, architectural feature, folk customs, med-aesthetic treatment, safety, emotional experience, resident hospitality) received higher satisfaction than expected, despite lower perceived importance. Safety, in particular, had high satisfaction.
- Quadrant III (Low Priority): Six elements (traditional Korean costume fitting experience, tickets, culture and history, city characteristics, tour guide service, infrastructure) are of lower importance and performance.
- Quadrant IV (Concentrate Here): Eight elements (urban landscape, prices, international travel, urban transportation, communication, Korean wave, internet celebrity, weather and climate) are highly important but have low satisfaction, indicating critical areas for improvement.
- Overall Satisfaction: The average satisfaction score for UTE elements in Seoul was 3.75, suggesting a relatively high overall quality of tourism experience.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Source Limitation: The study relied on travel notes from a single website (Mafengwo), which might limit the objectivity and comprehensiveness of the data. Future work could involve analyzing data from multiple platforms.
- Absence of Demographic Data: The analysis did not include demographic information (age, gender) or geographical variations in tourist preferences. Future research could incorporate these factors for a more granular understanding.
- Future Directions: The authors suggest expanding the analysis to include data from multiple websites and incorporating demographic and geographic variables. Further research could also explore the impact of different tourism product types and refine marketing strategies based on these findings.
Summary updated