Personal Wellbeing Amid Pandemic Response: Impacts of Neighborhood Built Environment, Risk Communication and Health

Chunlan Guo, Kit Fai Wong, Yong Xu, Kevin Kei Ching Hung, Hung Chak HoApplied Research in Quality of Life 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies a staggering 20% decline in personal wellbeing among Hong Kong residents during the COVID-19 pandemic compared to pre-pandemic baselines. By analyzing data from over 5,400 participants, researchers identified a critical "tug-of-war" for mental health: while access to neighborhood open spaces and traditional news media bolstered resilience, high-density public housing and excessive social media consumption significantly eroded it.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While much of the pandemic-era research focused on viral transmission and physical pathology, this paper tackles the "shadow pandemic" of declining mental and social wellness. Specifically, the authors investigate how the built environment (the physical layout of our neighborhoods), risk communication (how we get our news), and pre-existing health indicators interact to determine an individual's quality of life during a prolonged crisis.

Hong Kong provides a unique "stress test" for these factors due to its extreme urban density, limited green space, and a population already weathering significant socio-political unrest. The researchers sought to identify which specific environmental and behavioral factors act as "buffers" versus "stressors" for personal wellbeing.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional survey design, collecting data from 5,458 participants in Hong Kong between November 2020 and May 2021 (the "fourth wave").

  • Wellbeing Measurement: They used the Personal Wellbeing Index-Adult (PWI-A), which aggregates satisfaction across seven domains: standard of living, health, achieving in life, relationships, safety, community-connectedness, and future security.
  • Spatial Analysis: To assess the built environment, the team used a 500-meter radius buffer around each participant's self-reported location. They integrated Land Utilization Maps and satellite imagery (SPOT-6) to calculate metrics like the percentage of open space, public/private residential land, and the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) for greenness.
  • Urban Density: They utilized the Sky View Factor (SVF)—a measure of unobstructed sky—to quantify the "canyon effect" of high-rise urban environments.
  • Statistical Modeling: Multi-level and multi-variable linear regressions were used to isolate the impact of environmental, communication, and health factors while controlling for sociodemographics.

Datasets

  • PopPanel: A large-scale survey panel operated by the Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute (HKPORI), combining probability-based telephone recruitment and non-probability online registration.
  • Land Utilization Map: Sourced from the Hong Kong Planning Department to categorize neighborhood land use.
  • SPOT-6 Satellite Imagery: Used to calculate high-resolution (6m) greenness (NDVI).
  • Common Spatial Data Infrastructure (CSDI): Building data used to estimate the Sky View Factor (SVF).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The 20% Drop: The most striking finding is the comparison to 2005 data. The mean wellbeing score plummeted from 67.0 to 49.0 (on a 100-point scale). The "Future Security" domain was the hardest hit, likely exacerbated by the intersection of the pandemic and local political shifts.
  • The "Urban Lung" Effect: Even in an ultra-dense city, small increases in neighborhood open space (parks, plazas) were significantly associated with higher wellbeing. These spaces served as essential "pressure valves" for social distancing and physical activity.
  • The Media Paradox: Not all information is helpful. Traditional Information Channel Utilization (TICU)—like TV and newspapers—was a positive predictor of wellbeing. Conversely, New Information Channel Utilization (NICU)—specifically social media—was a negative predictor. The authors suggest that social media's "infodemic" of misinformation and "passive consumption" (scrolling without engaging) fuels anxiety rather than resolving it.
  • Public Housing as a Stressor: A higher percentage of public residential land in a neighborhood was linked to lower wellbeing. This is attributed to higher population densities making social distancing difficult, coupled with limited access to resources and higher perceived infection risk.

Key Results

  • Wellbeing Scores: Females, older age groups (60+), and those with higher education/income reported significantly higher wellbeing.
  • Environmental Impact: In the final regression model (Model 4), % open space was a significant positive predictor ($p < 0.01$), while % public residential area was a strong negative predictor ($p < 0.001$).
  • Communication Impact: Every additional hour spent on social media per day significantly decreased wellbeing scores ($\beta = -0.093, p < 0.001$). Confidence in one's ability to find information was the strongest positive predictor among communication factors ($\beta = 0.226, p < 0.001$).
  • Health Impact: Smoking habits and chronic health conditions were both strongly associated with lower wellbeing, likely due to the increased fear of severe COVID-19 complications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Bias: As an online survey, the sample may skew toward younger, more tech-savvy individuals, potentially underrepresenting the elderly or those without internet access.
  • Cross-Sectional Nature: The study provides a "snapshot" in time. It cannot definitively prove causality (e.g., does social media cause low wellbeing, or do unhappy people use social media more?).
  • Temporal/Political Context: The authors acknowledge that Hong Kong's unique socio-political climate since 2019 likely confounded the "future security" and "personal safety" scores.
  • Future Directions: The authors call for longitudinal research to track how wellbeing recovers (or fails to) post-pandemic and suggest that urban planners prioritize "resilient" neighborhood designs that guarantee access to open space for all socioeconomic groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Maintaining personal wellbeing is essential for an effective pandemic response due to its multifaceted impacts on various aspects of society. This study aimed to evaluate personal wellbeing during pandemic response and investigate the effects of built environment in neighborhoods, risk communication, and health indicators. A cross-sectional survey design was adopted. A sample with 5458 participants was collected in Hong Kong through a self-administered online survey. Personal Wellbeing Index- Adult (PWI-A) was adopted to measure personal wellbeing. This study indicated a more than 20% decrease in personal wellbeing among Hong Kong residents during the pandemic, particularly impacting future security, personal safety, and living standards. Positive influences on wellbeing included more open spaces, using more traditional information channels, seeking reliable media sources, and confidence in information seeking. Conversely, wellbeing was negatively affected by a higher percentage of public residential areas, using more new information channels, increased social media time, smoking habits and chronic health conditions. These findings provide critical insights into the diverse impacts of the pandemic on individuals and communities. They guide targeted interventions and contribute to building resilience against future crises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2024personal,
  author = {Chunlan Guo and Kit Fai Wong and Yong Xu and Kevin Kei Ching Hung and Hung Chak Ho},
  title = {{Personal Wellbeing Amid Pandemic Response: Impacts of Neighborhood Built Environment, Risk Communication and Health}},
  booktitle = {Applied Research in Quality of Life},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s11482-024-10395-w},
}
Figure