Persistent hot carrier diffusion in boron arsenide single crystals imaged by ultrafast electron microscopy

Usama Choudhry, Fengjiao Pan, Taeyong Kim, Ryan Gnabasik, Geethal Amila Gamage, Haoran Sun, Alex Ackerman, Zhifeng Ren, Bolin LiaoarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully visualized the movement of charge carriers in boron arsenide (BAs) single crystals using scanning ultrafast electron microscopy (SUEM). They discovered that BAs exhibits "hot carrier" dynamics that persist for over 200 picoseconds—significantly longer than in silicon—positioning this material as a dual-threat powerhouse for both microelectronic thermal management and high-efficiency optoelectronics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cubic boron arsenide (BAs) recently made waves in the materials science community for its extraordinary thermal conductivity (over 1000 W/mK), rivaling diamond. While its thermal properties are well-documented, its potential for optoelectronics (like solar cells or LEDs) remained largely theoretical.

The challenge lies in the "small-sample problem." High-quality BAs crystals are difficult to grow in large sizes, making conventional bulk measurements like the Hall effect unreliable or impossible. Furthermore, while theory predicted that BAs should have high charge mobility and slow "hot carrier" cooling, there was no experimental evidence to back this up—until now.

Methods

The team utilized Scanning Ultrafast Electron Microscopy (SUEM), a "photon-pump/electron-probe" technique.

  1. The Pump: A femtosecond laser pulse (515 nm) hits the BAs crystal, exciting "hot" charge carriers (electrons and holes with excess energy).
  2. The Probe: A picosecond pulse of primary electrons is scanned across the surface at varying delay times (from picoseconds to nanoseconds).
  3. The Contrast: The presence of photoexcited carriers changes the yield of secondary electrons (SEs) emitted from the surface. By subtracting a reference image, the researchers created "difference images" that directly visualize how the cloud of charge carriers expands over time.

To quantify the results, they fitted the expanding bright spots in the images to a 2D Gaussian function, allowing them to calculate the effective diffusivity and the time constant for carrier cooling.

Datasets

The study did not use pre-existing public datasets. Instead, it generated several original experimental datasets:

  • BAs Single Crystals: Synthesized via chemical vapor transport (CVT) and characterized using XRD, EDS, and Raman spectroscopy to ensure high quality.
  • SUEM Time-Series: Multiple sets of time-resolved images taken at different optical fluences (ranging from 80 µJ/cm² to 235 µJ/cm²).
  • Comparison Data: Reference values for silicon were used to contextualize the "prolonged" nature of the BAs dynamics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Phonon Bottleneck: The most striking finding is that hot carriers in BAs stay "hot" for a long time (>200 ps). This is due to a unique feature in BAs's atomic structure: a large frequency gap between acoustic and optical phonons. Hot carriers dump energy into optical phonons, but those phonons can't easily pass that energy to acoustic phonons (which carry heat away), creating a cooling bottleneck.
  • Dual-Purpose Physics: Interestingly, the same phonon gap responsible for BAs's world-class thermal conductivity is also what enables these persistent hot carrier dynamics.
  • Ambipolar vs. Separation:
    • At low fluence, electrons and holes diffuse together (ambipolar diffusion).
  • At high fluence, the researchers observed a "dark region" and a "bright region" expanding at different rates. This indicates spontaneous electron-hole separation, likely because holes in BAs actually move faster than electrons—a phenomenon reminiscent of the photo-Dember effect.

Key Results

  • Persistence: The hot carrier transport time constant ($\tau$) was measured up to 250 ps, compared to roughly 100 ps in crystalline silicon.
  • High Mobility: The researchers extracted an equilibrium ambipolar mobility of approximately 1700 cm²/Vs, confirming theoretical predictions of excellent transport properties.
  • Direct Visualization: The study provided the first real-space "movie" of charge carrier diffusion in BAs, proving that SUEM is a viable tool for characterizing materials that are too small for traditional electronic testing.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current quantitative analysis relies on a simplified diffusion model. For the high-fluence data where electrons and holes separate, a more rigorous "coupled electron-hole transport model" that accounts for complex Coulombic interactions is needed for a truly precise analysis.

Looking forward, the discovery of long-lived hot carriers makes BAs a prime candidate for hot-carrier solar cells, which could theoretically surpass the efficiency limits of standard silicon cells by capturing the energy of carriers before they cool down. The team suggests that BAs is now a top-tier candidate for integrated devices that require both extreme cooling and high-performance optoelectronic functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cubic boron arsenide (BAs) is promising for microelectronics thermal management due to its high thermal conductivity. Recently, its potential as an optoelectronic material is also being explored. However, it remains challenging to measure its photocarrier transport properties due to small sizes of available high-quality crystals. Here, we use scanning ultrafast electron microscopy (SUEM) to directly visualize the diffusion of photoexcited charge carriers in BAs single crystals. Surprisingly, we observed ambipolar diffusion at low optical fluence with persistent hot carrier dynamics for above 200 picoseconds, which can be attributed to the large frequency gap between acoustic and optical phonons, the same feature that is responsible for the high thermal conductivity. At higher optical fluence, we observed spontaneous electron-hole separation. Our results show BAs is an attractive optoelectronic material combining high thermal conductivity and excellent photocarrier transport properties. Our study also demonstrates the capability of SUEM to probe photocarrier transport in emerging materials.
BibTeX
@misc{choudhry2022persistent,
  author = {Usama Choudhry and Fengjiao Pan and Taeyong Kim and Ryan Gnabasik and Geethal Amila Gamage and Haoran Sun and Alex Ackerman and Zhifeng Ren and Bolin Liao},
  title = {{Persistent hot carrier diffusion in boron arsenide single crystals imaged by ultrafast electron microscopy}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2206.12712},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.12712},
}
Figure