Persistent Homology of Graph Embeddings

Vinesh Solanki, Patrick Rubin‐Delanchy, Ian GallagherarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel way to distinguish between different network models (like the standard vs. mixed membership stochastic block models) by analyzing the "shape" of their embedded representations using persistent homology. They show that this topological approach can reliably estimate the underlying structure of these networks, even when the embeddings are not uniquely identifiable, and develop a hypothesis test for model selection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When we represent complex networks (like social networks or biological interaction networks) as points in a geometric space using techniques like spectral embedding, these points often reveal underlying structures. Two popular models for generating networks, the standard stochastic block model (SBM) and the mixed membership stochastic block model (MMSBM), produce embeddings with distinct geometric properties: SBM embeddings tend to form clusters, while MMSBM embeddings form a simplex. However, simply looking at the raw embeddings can be tricky, and existing methods might not fully capture these subtle topological differences. Furthermore, spectral embeddings can be ambiguous (non-identifiable), meaning different underlying network structures could lead to similar embeddings. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using persistent homology, a tool from topological data analysis, to robustly characterize the geometric structure of these embeddings and distinguish between SBM and MMSBM, even in the presence of non-identifiability.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in applying persistent homology to the point clouds generated by spectral embedding of graphs. Here's a breakdown:

  • Spectral Embedding: This is a standard technique where the adjacency matrix of a graph is decomposed, and its eigenvectors are used to map nodes to points in a lower-dimensional Euclidean space ($\mathbb{R}^d$). The paper builds upon the framework of generalized random dot-product graphs (GRDPGs), which provides a theoretical foundation for understanding these embeddings.
  • Persistent Homology: This is the key novel contribution. Instead of just looking at the final embedding, persistent homology analyzes the "shape" of the point cloud across different scales. It does this by constructing topological features (like connected components, holes, etc.) as a radius increases (e.g., by building unions of balls around points or using kernel density estimates) and tracking when these features appear ("birth") and disappear ("death"). These are summarized in persistence diagrams.
  • Consistency Estimation: A major challenge is that spectral embeddings are not uniquely identifiable. The paper demonstrates that despite this ambiguity, the persistent homology of the support of the underlying distribution (the true geometric space where points are drawn from) and its super-level sets (regions of higher density) can still be consistently estimated.
  • Hypothesis Testing: As an application, the authors develop a topological hypothesis test to distinguish between SBM and MMSBM. This test leverages the differences in the topological features (specifically, the bottleneck distance between persistence diagrams) of embeddings generated by these two models.

Datasets

The paper uses simulated datasets generated from:

  • Standard Stochastic Block Model (SBM): Used to generate graphs with distinct community structures.
  • Mixed Membership Stochastic Block Model (MMSBM): Used to generate graphs where nodes can belong to multiple communities with varying degrees.

The paper simulates graphs with varying parameters for these models to test their methods under different conditions. No new benchmark datasets are introduced; rather, the focus is on analyzing the properties of graphs generated by established models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topology as a Discriminator: The paper's central insight is that the "shape" of network embeddings, as captured by persistent homology, can reliably distinguish between different network generation models (SBM vs. MMSBM). This is a powerful idea because it moves beyond simple clustering and looks at more fundamental topological properties.
  • Robustness to Non-Identifiability: A significant achievement is demonstrating that persistent homology can provide consistent estimates of topological features even when the spectral embedding itself is ambiguous. This means the topological information is more robust than the exact coordinates of the embedded points.
  • Super-Level Sets for Density: The use of super-level sets of kernel density estimates is a clever way to probe the internal structure and density variations within the embedded point clouds, revealing topological features that might be missed by just looking at the support.
  • Unexpected Behavior of MMSBM: The paper highlights that distinguishing MMSBM becomes harder not only when the mixing parameters are very small (approaching SBM) but also when they are very large. This suggests a nuanced understanding of how network structure emerges from these models.

Key Results

  • The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the consistent estimation of persistent homology for the support and super-level sets of the underlying distributions of GRDPGs.
  • They establish bottleneck distance bounds that quantify how well the estimated persistence diagrams approximate the true diagrams, with rates depending on factors like sample size and dimensionality.
  • A topological hypothesis test is proposed and evaluated on simulated data. The test demonstrates good performance in distinguishing SBM from MMSBM, showing it is conservative under the null hypothesis (SBM) and has power under the alternative (MMSBM).
  • Figure 1 and Figure 2 visually demonstrate how different topological constructions (union of balls, kernel density estimates) reveal distinct topological features for SBM and MMSBM, aiding in their differentiation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Non-Identifiability of Base Measure: While the paper addresses the non-identifiability of the embedding (i.e., the transformation $Q_n$), the underlying base probability measure $P$ itself is not uniquely identifiable. The paper uses "representative" measures to handle this, but it's a known limitation.
  • Assumptions on Base Measure: Some theoretical results rely on assumptions like local lower $\gamma$-regularity for the base measure $P$. While these are met by common models like SBM and Dirichlet distributions, it might limit applicability to more exotic distributions.
  • Parameter Estimation: The hypothesis testing procedure relies on estimating model parameters (like $B$ and $\nu$ for SBM). The paper acknowledges that the performance of the test can be affected by the accuracy of these estimates, especially in the parametric bootstrap approach.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring a fuller topological hypothesis testing framework and investigating what other geometric features of the point distribution can be inferred in the presence of non-identifiability. They also mention that the current work focuses on undirected graphs, and extending it to directed graphs would be a natural next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Popular network models such as the mixed membership and standard stochastic block model are known to exhibit distinct geometric structure when embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{d}$ using spectral methods. The resulting point cloud concentrates around a simplex in the first model, whereas it separates into clusters in the second. By adopting the formalism of generalised random dot-product graphs, we demonstrate that both of these models, and different mixing regimes in the case of mixed membership, may be distinguished by the persistent homology of the underlying point distribution in the case of adjacency spectral embedding. Moreover, despite non-identifiability issues, we show that the persistent homology of the support of the distribution and its super-level sets can be consistently estimated. As an application of our consistency results, we provide a topological hypothesis test for distinguishing the standard and mixed membership stochastic block models.
BibTeX
@misc{solanki2019persistent,
  author = {Vinesh Solanki and Patrick Rubin‐Delanchy and Ian Gallagher},
  title = {{Persistent Homology of Graph Embeddings}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1912.10238},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1912.10238},
}
Figure