Abstract
The mechanism that controls the superconducting (SC) transition temperature $T_{\mathrm{c}}^{0}$ as a function of doping is one of the central questions in cuprate high-temperature superconductors. While it is generally accepted that $T_{\mathrm{c}}^{0}$ in underdoped cuprates is not determined by the scale of pairing but by the onset of global phase coherence, the role of phase fluctuations in the overdoped region has been controversial. Here, our transport measurements in perpendicular magnetic fields ($H$) on underdoped Bi-2201 reveal immeasurably small Hall response for $T > T_{\mathrm{c}}(H)$ as a signature of SC phase with vortexlike phase fluctuations. We find that the extent of such a regime in $T$ and $H$ is suppressed near optimal doping but becomes strongly enhanced in heavily overdoped Bi-2201. Our results thus show that vortexlike phase fluctuations play an important role in the field-tuned SC transition in the heavily overdoped region, in contrast to conventional mean-field Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer description. The unexpected nonmonotonic dependence of phase fluctuations on doping provides a new perspective on the SC transition in cuprates.
Introduction
In high-temperature cuprate superconductors, the transition to a zero-resistance state at $T_c$ involves two distinct physical processes: the pairing of electrons into Cooper pairs and the establishment of long-range phase coherence. In the underdoped regime, it is well-established that $T_c$ is limited by phase fluctuations rather than the pairing energy scale. This leads to a "vortex liquid" state where superconducting pairs exist but lack the coordination to flow without resistance.
Historically, the overdoped region was thought to follow the standard Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) theory, where pairing and coherence occur simultaneously. However, recent evidence has questioned this mean-field description. This study investigates whether vortex-like phase fluctuations persist into the overdoped regime by examining the magnetotransport properties of the single-layer cuprate Bi-2201.
Methods
The researchers focused on Bi-2201 (Bi$_2$Sr$_{2-x}$La$_x$CuO$_{6+\delta}$) due to its structural simplicity and relatively low $T_c$, which allows for the suppression of superconductivity using available magnetic fields. The study spanned the entire superconducting dome, utilizing underdoped single crystals ($p \approx 0.10$), weakly overdoped crystals ($p \approx 0.18$), and heavily overdoped thin films ($p \approx 0.25$ and $0.27$).
Key experimental techniques included:
- Magnetotransport: Measurements of longitudinal resistivity ($\rho_{xx}$) and Hall resistivity ($\rho_{yx}$) were conducted in perpendicular magnetic fields up to 45 Tesla and at temperatures as low as 16 mK.
- Hall Effect Signature: The "smoking gun" for the vortex liquid phase is the observation of a vanishing Hall response ($R_H = 0$) while the longitudinal resistivity remains non-zero. In this regime, moving vortices effectively cancel out the Hall voltage, a behavior distinct from normal metallic transport.
Results and Discussion
The most significant finding is the discovery of a non-monotonic "U-shaped" trend in the prominence of phase fluctuations across the doping range. While phase fluctuations are extensive in the underdoped regime, they are suppressed near optimal doping. Surprisingly, they re-emerge with significant strength in the heavily overdoped region.
In heavily overdoped samples ($p \approx 0.25$), the relative width of the fluctuation regime ($\delta T/T_c$) reached values as high as 7, which is comparable to the underdoped side and significantly exceeds the predictions of mean-field BCS theory ($\delta T/T_c \ll 1$). This suggests that the overdoped regime is not a simple Fermi liquid but is influenced by electronic granularity—pockets of superconductivity forming within a metallic matrix.
Conclusion
The persistence of vortex-like phase fluctuations in heavily overdoped Bi-2201 challenges the conventional BCS view of the cuprate phase diagram. The non-monotonic dependence of these fluctuations on doping suggests that phase coherence is a universal limiting factor for $T_c$ across the entire dome. Future work involving direct visualization via Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) in high magnetic fields will be essential to confirm the suspected "superconducting puddles" and to further explore the connection between these fluctuations and the "strange metal" state.
Summary updated