Permafrost carbon-climate feedbacks accelerate global warming

Charles D. Koven, Bruno Ringeval, Pierre Friedlingstein, Philippe Ciais, Patricia Cadule, Dmitry Khvorostyanov, Gerhard Krinner, C. TarnocaiProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

Permafrost soils hold vast amounts of carbon, and this study shows that as the planet warms, these frozen soils could release significant amounts of CO2 and methane, accelerating global warming. Using a sophisticated ecosystem model, the researchers found that high-latitude regions could shift from being carbon sinks to sources by the end of the century, with a potential loss of up to 85 Pg C.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Earth's permafrost regions, vast areas of permanently frozen ground in the Arctic and sub-Arctic, store an enormous amount of organic carbon – roughly twice as much as is currently in the atmosphere. For millennia, this carbon has been locked away by the cold. However, as global temperatures rise due to climate change, this permafrost is thawing. The critical question is: what happens to this vast carbon reservoir when it thaws? Will it remain inert, or will microbes decompose it, releasing greenhouse gases like CO2 and methane into the atmosphere, creating a dangerous positive feedback loop that further accelerates warming? Previous climate models (like those used in the IPCC AR4) often didn't fully account for these permafrost-specific processes, leading to an underestimation of potential future warming. This paper aims to fill that gap by explicitly modeling permafrost carbon dynamics.

Methods

The researchers employed the ORCHIDEE terrestrial ecosystem model, a sophisticated tool designed to simulate the Earth's land-based carbon cycle. They introduced several key permafrost-related processes into the model:

  • Inhibition of decomposition in frozen soil: This is a fundamental aspect of permafrost, where low temperatures drastically slow down microbial activity.
  • Vertical mixing of soil carbon: As the active layer (the top layer of soil that thaws seasonally) deepens, it can mix older carbon from deeper layers to the surface, making it more available for decomposition.
  • Methane (CH4) emissions from flooded areas: Thawing permafrost can lead to changes in hydrology, creating new wetlands or expanding existing ones, which are significant sources of methane.
  • Microbial heat release: Decomposition of organic matter by microbes generates heat, which can further warm the soil and accelerate thawing and decomposition – a process known as "microbial heating."

They ran four sets of simulations to isolate the effects of these processes: "Control" (standard soil carbon model), "Freeze" (inhibiting decomposition in frozen layers), "Permafrost" (including vertical mixing and insulation effects), and "Heating" (adding microbial heat release). These simulations were run from 1860 to 2100 under a SRES A2 climate scenario.

Datasets

The study utilized climate forcing data from the IPSL-CM4 climate system model for historical and future (SRES A2) scenarios. They also referenced observed data from the Circumpolar Active Layer Monitoring (CALM) program for validating trends in active layer thickness. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing observational data was used for model validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Permafrost is a ticking carbon bomb: The most striking insight is that permafrost regions, currently a net carbon sink, could become a significant carbon source by the end of the 21st century under warming scenarios. This is a critical shift with major implications for global climate targets.
  • Microbial heating is a game-changer: The "Heating" experiment, which included the self-generated heat from microbial decomposition, showed the most dramatic carbon release, highlighting the potential for a runaway feedback loop.
  • Methane matters too: While CO2 is the primary focus, the study also quantifies significant increases in methane emissions from wetlands, adding another layer to the permafrost feedback.
  • Model improvements are crucial: The study underscores the limitations of previous models that didn't fully capture permafrost dynamics, leading to potentially underestimated warming.

Key Results

  • CO2 Flux Shift: Under the "Permafrost" scenario (without microbial heating), high-latitude ecosystems are projected to shift from a carbon sink of 68 Pg (1860-2100) to a source of 4 ± 18 Pg. With the "Heating" scenario, this loss escalates to a staggering 85 ± 16 Pg C.
  • Methane Emissions Increase: Methane emissions from high latitudes are projected to increase from 34 Tg CH4/yr to 41-70 Tg CH4/yr by the end of the century.
  • Permafrost Extent Reduction: The model predicts a 30% reduction in permafrost extent by 2100, with a deepening of the active layer where permafrost still exists.
  • Regional Differences: The spatial maps show that carbon losses are particularly pronounced in central Canada and Eastern Siberia, with the "Heating" experiment showing the most severe impacts.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • C-N Interactions: The ORCHIDEE model used in this study did not explicitly include carbon-nitrogen (C-N) interactions. These interactions, particularly nitrogen mineralization from thawing permafrost, could significantly alter plant growth and decomposition, potentially reducing the CO2-induced carbon sink. Including C-N interactions might even turn all simulation experiments into carbon sources by 2100.
  • Hydrological Effects: Small-scale hydrological effects and the complex interactions between warming and hydrology are only crudely represented.
  • Missing Processes: Fundamental processes like thermokarst erosion and the effects of drying on peatland CO2 emissions were not included, introducing uncertainty.
  • Wetland Dynamics: Modeling wetland dynamics and the microbial processes governing methane emissions, especially in the context of permafrost thaw, remains a significant source of uncertainty.

Future work should focus on integrating these missing processes, particularly C-N interactions and more detailed hydrological modeling, to refine these projections and better understand the full scope of permafrost carbon feedbacks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Permafrost soils contain enormous amounts of organic carbon, which could act as a positive feedback to global climate change due to enhanced respiration rates with warming. We have used a terrestrial ecosystem model that includes permafrost carbon dynamics, inhibition of respiration in frozen soil layers, vertical mixing of soil carbon from surface to permafrost layers, and CH(4) emissions from flooded areas, and which better matches new circumpolar inventories of soil carbon stocks, to explore the potential for carbon-climate feedbacks at high latitudes. Contrary to model results for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth Assessment Report (IPCC AR4), when permafrost processes are included, terrestrial ecosystems north of 60°N could shift from being a sink to a source of CO(2) by the end of the 21st century when forced by a Special Report on Emissions Scenarios (SRES) A2 climate change scenario. Between 1860 and 2100, the model response to combined CO(2) fertilization and climate change changes from a sink of 68 Pg to a 27 + -7 Pg sink to 4 + -18 Pg source, depending on the processes and parameter values used. The integrated change in carbon due to climate change shifts from near zero, which is within the range of previous model estimates, to a climate-induced loss of carbon by ecosystems in the range of 25 + -3 to 85 + -16 Pg C, depending on processes included in the model, with a best estimate of a 62 + -7 Pg C loss. Methane emissions from high-latitude regions are calculated to increase from 34 Tg CH(4)/y to 41-70 Tg CH(4)/y, with increases due to CO(2) fertilization, permafrost thaw, and warming-induced increased CH(4) flux densities partially offset by a reduction in wetland extent.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koven2011permafrost,
  author = {Charles D. Koven and Bruno Ringeval and Pierre Friedlingstein and Philippe Ciais and Patricia Cadule and Dmitry Khvorostyanov and Gerhard Krinner and C. Tarnocai},
  title = {{Permafrost carbon-climate feedbacks accelerate global warming}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1103910108},
}
Figure