Perinatal midwifery care demand in a tertiary hospital: A time-series analysis

Luisa C. Eggenschwiler, Giusi Moffa, Valerie A. Smith, Michael SimonInternational Journal of Nursing Studies Advances 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that simply looking at average staffing levels in maternity wards masks significant, shift-level unmet care demand, particularly in labor and delivery units. By incorporating patient complexity, the researchers found that labor wards experience understaffing in over half of shifts, highlighting the need for more flexible staffing models to manage the unpredictable nature of births.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global shortage of midwives and nurses poses a significant challenge to providing safe maternity care. While general recommendations for staffing levels exist, they often fail to account for the dynamic and unpredictable nature of care demand within maternity units. This demand fluctuates not only over years and weeks but also within individual shifts, and is heavily influenced by the complexity of each patient's case. Existing research often aggregates data at a hospital or annual level, obscuring these crucial unit- and shift-level variations and leading to an underestimation of actual unmet care needs. This paper aims to address this gap by providing a detailed, shift-level analysis of care demand and available staffing resources in a tertiary hospital's maternity department, specifically incorporating patient complexity.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective, single-center, longitudinal study over a four-year period (2019-2022) at a tertiary hospital's maternity department. They developed a novel approach to quantify care demand by not only counting the number of women but also assigning a "complexity factor" to each case. This factor, inspired by existing models like Birthrate Plus®, accounts for various pregnancy, labor, and newborn complications, assigning weights to reflect the increased care hours required.

Care demand was measured in "care demand hours per shift per case," calculated by multiplying the duration of a woman's stay on a unit by her complexity factor. Staffing hours were determined by the number of registered midwives and nurses multiplied by their shift duration. The "match" between staffing resources and care demand was then calculated by subtracting demand hours from available staff hours, both unweighted and weighted by the complexity factor. Statistical analyses were performed using R, focusing on descriptive statistics, coefficients of variation to assess demand variability, and shift-level matching analysis.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a tertiary hospital's maternity department, specifically from its prenatal (Unit 1), labor (Unit 2), and postnatal (Unit 3) units. The data spanned a four-year period (January 1, 2019, to December 31, 2022).

  • Patient Data: Included inpatient admissions for pregnant women, mothers, and newborns, as well as outpatient visits to the labor ward. This data was extracted from administrative records and a clinical data warehouse.
  • Staffing Data: Rosters and shift information for registered midwives and registered nurses were obtained from the PEP® software, which is used for staff rostering and reimbursement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complexity Matters: Simply counting patients doesn't capture the full picture of care demand. Incorporating patient complexity significantly alters the perceived match between staffing and demand, often revealing greater understaffing.
  • The Labor Ward is a Hotspot: The labor ward (Unit 2) consistently showed the most significant mismatches, with over half of shifts experiencing understaffing when complexity was considered. This highlights the unique challenges of managing labor and delivery, where births can cluster unpredictably.
  • Averages Obscure Reality: Aggregated data (e.g., daily averages) can mask critical shift-level shortages. The study emphasizes the need for granular, shift- and unit-level analysis to accurately identify staffing gaps.
  • Flexibility is Key: The unpredictable nature of births, especially in labor wards, necessitates flexible staffing models that can adapt to sudden increases in demand, rather than relying on fixed rosters.
  • Postnatal Units May Have Surplus (Unweighted): While labor wards struggle, the postnatal unit (Unit 3) showed a surplus of staff when demand was unweighted. However, when weighted for complexity, this surplus diminished, suggesting that even postnatal care requires careful consideration of patient needs.

Key Results

  • Birth Clustering: The daily number of births varied significantly, with a median of seven births per day and a coefficient of variation of 0.36, indicating unpredictable clustering.
  • Labor Ward Understaffing:
    • Unweighted: 32.0% of shifts in the labor ward (Unit 2) lacked at least one registered midwife.
  • Weighted: This figure rose dramatically to 55.2% of shifts experiencing understaffing when patient complexity was factored in.
  • Prenatal and Postnatal Units: These units generally met demand, though some shifts experienced unmet demand (19.1% for Unit 1, 37.7% for Unit 3 when weighted).
  • Complexity Weighting Impact: Weighting care demand by complexity consistently increased the reported amount of unmet care demand across units.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity Factor Validation: The weights assigned to complexity factors were inspired by existing models and reviewed by clinical staff but were not formally validated. Further validation is deemed necessary to increase confidence in the results.
  • Staffing Roster vs. Actual Staffing: The study acknowledges that its analysis is based on planned staffing rosters. It remains open whether observed mismatches were due to deviations from the roster or if the roster planning itself was inadequate.
  • Exclusion of Certain Staff: Supernumerary staff (e.g., leadership, educators) and nurse assistants were excluded from the analysis, as were physicians. While this aligns with a focus on direct-care registered midwives and RNs, these excluded roles provide critical support.
  • Experience and Overtime Not Analyzed: The impact of registered midwife/RN experience and overtime hours on care quality and demand management was not specifically analyzed.
  • COVID-19 Impact: The study period included the COVID-19 pandemic, which introduced some changes (e.g., partner presence). However, the authors state that care proceeded largely as normal and did not explore pandemic-specific impacts on staffing.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Validation of Complexity Weights: A crucial next step to enhance the reliability of the findings.
  • Operational Planning Tools: Developing escalation algorithms for short-notice staffing adjustments based on real-time mismatch levels.
  • Prospective Complexity Assessment: Regularly assessing complexity (e.g., every six hours) for more dynamic operational planning.
  • Investigating Outcomes: Further research should examine the effects of understaffed shifts on maternal and neonatal outcomes.
  • Improving Demand Prediction: Utilizing shared pregnancy assessment data and identifying complexity-increasing factors earlier to improve staffing predictions.
  • Exploring New Shift Structures: Creating new shift patterns to address peak demand periods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Alongside the inclusion of care complexity in assessing care demand, shift- and unit-level analyses showed that average staffing numbers obscure the actual volume of unmet care demand. Staffing in labour wards needs greater flexibility to cope with the clustering of births over short periods.
BibTeX
@article{eggenschwiler2025perinatal,
  author = {Luisa C. Eggenschwiler and Giusi Moffa and Valerie A. Smith and Michael Simon},
  title = {{Perinatal midwifery care demand in a tertiary hospital: A time-series analysis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Nursing Studies Advances},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijnsa.2025.100299},
}

Loading related content...

Figure