Performance versus energy consumption of hyperspectral unmixing algorithms on multi-core platforms

Alfredo Remón, Sergio Sánchez, Sergio Bernabé, Enrique S. Quintana-Ortí, Antonio PlazaEURASIP J. Adv. Signal Process 2013 · DOI

Introduction

Hyperspectral imaging has revolutionized our ability to observe the Earth from space. By capturing hundreds of narrow wavelength bands for every pixel, these sensors allow for the identification of specific chemical compositions. However, the sheer volume of data and the complexity of the required processing present significant hurdles for real-time applications on satellite platforms.

The Problem: Mixed Pixels and the "Power Wall"

A primary challenge in hyperspectral analysis is the "mixed pixel" problem. Because a single pixel often covers several meters of ground, it rarely contains a single pure material. Instead, it captures a mixture of substances like soil, water, and vegetation.

Figure 1: The presence of mixed pixels in hyperspectral imagery, where individual pixels contain spectral signatures from multiple materials.

"Unmixing" is the computational process used to decompose these mixed pixels into their constituent pure substances (endmembers) and their respective proportions (abundances). This process is vital for time-sensitive missions like wildfire monitoring or oil spill detection. However, satellites operate under strict energy budgets—the "Power Wall." While GPUs offer high speed, their power consumption is often prohibitive. Conversely, FPGAs are energy-efficient but difficult to program. This research investigates whether modern multi-core CPUs can provide a viable middle ground.

Methodology: The Unmixing Chain

The researchers evaluated the unmixing process as a three-stage chain:

  1. Dimensionality Estimation: Determining the number of unique materials in a scene (using VD or HySime algorithms).
  2. Endmember Extraction: Identifying the spectral signatures of those materials (using OSP-GS or N-FINDR).
  3. Abundance Estimation: Calculating the percentage of each material per pixel (using ULS or the non-negative ISRA).

To optimize these for a 48-core AMD Opteron platform, the team utilized high-performance linear algebra libraries (Intel MKL) and OpenMP for parallelization, focusing on matrix-matrix operations to maximize cache efficiency.

Key Results and Performance Trade-offs

The study utilized the AVIRIS Cuprite dataset, a benchmark mining district in Nevada, to validate accuracy against USGS mineral libraries.

  • Real-Time Success: The authors defined "real-time" as processing data faster than the sensor's collection rate (approx. 1.98 seconds). The optimized chain of VD + OSP-GS + ULS achieved a processing time of just 0.413 seconds, consuming only 0.0468 Watts-hour.
  • Computational Bottlenecks: Sophisticated algorithms like HySime and ISRA (which enforces non-negativity) proved to be significant hurdles. HySime took 15 seconds compared to VD's 0.15 seconds, while ISRA was over 100 times slower than the unconstrained ULS.
  • CPU vs. GPU: For certain modules like Virtual Dimensionality (VD), the multi-core CPU outperformed GPUs due to lower overhead, suggesting that CPUs are highly competitive for specific stages of the unmixing chain.

Future Directions: Moving Toward Nonlinearity

While this study focused on linear mixture models—where light interacts with only one material before reaching the sensor—real-world scenarios often involve multiple scattering events.

Figure 5: Comparison between linear (single scattering) and nonlinear (multiple scattering) mixture models in hyperspectral remote sensing.

Future research will aim to adapt these multi-core optimizations for more complex non-linear models and test performance on lower-power, mobile-grade multi-core processors suitable for smaller satellite platforms like CubeSats.

This summary is based on research published in the EURASIP Journal on Advances in Signal Processing.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{remon2013performance,
  author = {Alfredo Remón and Sergio Sánchez and Sergio Bernabé and Enrique S. Quintana-Ortí and Antonio Plaza},
  title = {{Performance versus energy consumption of hyperspectral unmixing algorithms on multi-core platforms}},
  journal = {EURASIP J. Adv. Signal Process.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1186/1687-6180-2013-68},
}
Figure