Performance Testing of Additively Manufactured 316L Stainless Steel in Light Water Reactor Environment

B. Alexandreanu, Yungui Chen, Xin Zhang2024 · DOI

Abstract

This report summarizes research activities conducted at Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) in support of the development, qualification, and certification of additively manufactured (AM) metallic components for the long-term sustainability of light water reactors (LWRs). AM 316L stainless steel (SS) was evaluated in LWR environments for fatigue, environmentally assisted fatigue (EAF), and stress corrosion cracking (SCC) performance in the as-printed condition. Testing utilized AM-produced tubing printed via Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF), which exhibited a low porosity of 0.06%. SCC crack growth rate (CGR) testing indicated that AM specimens in the as-built condition exhibit fatigue and corrosion fatigue responses similar to conventional alloys and are highly resistant to SCC. However, crack initiation testing suggests that as-printed surfaces initiate cracking faster than machined surfaces. Fatigue lives in air were slightly lower than traditional 316 SS, and further reduced in simulated PWR water. Environmental correction factors ($F_{en}$) for AM 316L were found to be comparable to those for conventional alloys, suggesting that existing regulatory frameworks are applicable to AM materials.

Introduction

The global nuclear fleet is aging, making the procurement of replacement parts for decades-old reactors increasingly difficult and costly. Metal additive manufacturing (AM) offers a viable solution for producing complex, custom components on demand. However, the nuclear industry requires rigorous validation that 3D-printed parts can survive the extreme conditions of an LWR—high-temperature water, intense pressure, and cyclic stress—without failing due to Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) or Environmentally Assisted Fatigue (EAF). This study investigates whether "as-printed" 316L stainless steel components, which have not undergone extensive post-processing like Hot Isostatic Pressing, can meet these demanding safety standards.

Methodology

Researchers at ANL used a Renishaw AM400 Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) system to print 316L stainless steel specimens, including tubing surrogates for complex components. The evaluation involved several advanced characterization and testing techniques:

  • Porosity Analysis: High-resolution Synchrotron X-ray tomography at the Advanced Photon Source (APS) mapped internal porosity with micron-level precision.
  • SCC Crack Growth Testing: Conducted in 320°C simulated pressurized water reactor (PWR) environments using the reversing-DC potential difference method to monitor crack length in real-time.
  • Fatigue Testing: Strain-controlled tests in 300°C air were compared against tests in 300°C simulated PWR water to determine environmental impact.
  • Surface Finish Comparison: A "series" test simultaneously loaded as-printed and machined specimens to directly compare crack initiation susceptibility.

Key Results and Discussion

Material Integrity and Isotropic Performance

The as-built material demonstrated a remarkably low porosity of 0.06%, comparable to parts that have undergone expensive post-build densification. Despite the layer-by-layer nature of the LPBF process, the crack growth rates were similar whether the crack was oriented parallel or normal to the build direction, suggesting that the material's bulk behavior is isotropic and uniform.

SCC and Fatigue Resistance

AM specimens proved extremely resistant to SCC, with growth rates aligning with established benchmarks for conventional wrought and cast stainless steels. In fatigue testing, AM 316L showed consistent cyclic softening, likely due to the relaxation of residual stresses from the printing process. While fatigue life in 300°C air was slightly lower than wrought steel at high strain amplitudes, it remained within the expected scatter band. In PWR water, fatigue life was reduced by approximately a factor of two, a trend consistent with traditional nuclear-grade steels.

The Impact of Surface Finish

A critical finding was that the "as-printed" surface finish is significantly more prone to crack initiation than machined surfaces. The "unsupported arches" created during the printing of notches act as local stress concentrators, accelerating the onset of cracking. This highlights that while the bulk material is robust, critical components may still require surface treatments or machining to ensure long-term integrity.

Conclusion

The performance of additively manufactured 316L stainless steel in LWR environments is remarkably similar to that of traditional wrought alloys. The calculated environmental correction factors ($F_{en}$) for AM 316L are reasonably close to those used for conventional alloys, suggesting that existing regulatory frameworks like NUREG-6909 can be adapted for AM materials. Future work will focus on expanding the fatigue dataset and completing microstructural analyses of industrial-scale components to further facilitate the adoption of AM technologies in the nuclear sector.

Summary updated

Abstract

This report summarizes research activities conducted at Argonne National Laboratory in support of the development, qualification and certification of additively manufactured (AM) metallic components for the long-term sustainability of light water reactors.In this program, AM 316L stainless steel (SS) has been evaluated in light water reactor (LWR) environments for their fatigue, environmentally assisted fatigue, and stress corrosion cracking performances on specimens in as-printed condition, aiming for facilitating the regulatory acceptance and ultimately adoption of AM components in aging LWRs.The performance of AM 316L in a light water environment was evaluated using AM-produced tubing -intended to act as surrogates for complex components where nuclear equipment vendors are more likely to consider AM technologies -printed at ANL using a Renishaw AM400 Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) system.The porosity of the as-built material was found to be small, 0.06%.Testing involved SCC initiation, SCC crack growth and EAF of the AM material in the as-built condition.SCC CGR testing revealed that the fatigue and corrosion fatigue CGR response of two AM specimens in the as-built condition -oriented normal to and parallel to the build direction -was found to be similar to that expected for conventional alloys.Also, both AM specimens in the asbuilt condition proved to be extremely resistant to SCC.Crack initiation testing suggest that printing geometry affects local susceptibility to cracking, and that the as-printed surface initiated cracking faster than the machined surface.Strain-controlled fatigue tests in air conducted with 3D-printed 316L SS under different strain amplitudes in a fully reversed mode revealed that the fatigue lives of AM 316L were slightly lower than that of traditionally made 316 SS, especially at high strain amplitude.For the tests performed in simulated PWR water, the fatigue lives of AM316L were lower than that obtained in air, suggesting a negative impact of LWR environment on AM materials.Cyclic softening dominated the evolution of stress amplitude for all fatigue tests on AM 316L SS both in air and in water.Following the same approach proposed in NUREG-6909 for wrought and cast austenitic SSs, environmental correction factors, Fen, were estimated for AM316L and were found to be reasonably close to those for conventional alloys, suggesting a similar baseline behavior in air for wrought and AM316L SSs.
BibTeX
@misc{alexandreanu2024performance,
  author = {B. Alexandreanu and Yungui Chen and Xin Zhang},
  title = {{Performance Testing of Additively Manufactured 316L Stainless Steel in Light Water Reactor Environment}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2172/2460509},
}
Figure