Performance of novel VUV-sensitive Silicon Photo-Multipliers for nEXO

G. Gallina, Y. H. Guan, F. Retière, G. F. Cao, A. E. Bolotnikov, I. Kotov, S. Rescia, A. K. Soma, T. Tsang, L. Darroch, T. Brunner, J. Bolster, J.r. Cohen, T. Pinto Franco, W. Gillis, H. Peltz Smalley, S. Thibado, A. Pocar, Aaqib Ayoub Bhat, A. Jamil, David C. Moore, G. Adhikari, S. Al Kharusi, Evan Angelico, I. J. Arnquist, P. Arsenault, I. Badhrees, J. Bane, V. Belov, E. P. Bernard, Trilochan Bhatta, P. A. Breur, J. Brodsky, A. Brown, E. Caden, Liqiang Cao, C. Chambers, B. Chana, Serge A. Charlebois, D. Chernyak, M. Chiu, B. T. Cleveland, R. Collister, M. Cvitan, J. Dalmasson, T. Daniels, K. Deslandes, R. DeVoe, M. L. di Vacri, Ying Ding, M. J. Dolinski, A. Dragone, J. Echevers, B. Eckert, M. Elbeltagi, L. Fabris, W. M. Fairbank, J. Farine, Yanyan Fu, D. Gallacher, P. Gautam, G. Giacomini, C. Gingras, D. Goeldi, R. Gornea, G. Gratta, C. A. Hardy, S. Hedges, M. Heffner, Emilie Hein, J. D. Holt, E. W. Hoppe, J. Hößl, A. House, W. E. Hunt, A. Iverson, X. S. Jiang, A. Karelin, L. J. Kaufman, R. Krücken, A. Kuchenkov, K.s. Kumar, A. C. Larson, K. G. Leach, B. G. Lenardo, D. S. Leonard, G. Lessard, Gang Li, S. Li, Z. Li, C. Licciardi, R. Lindsay, R. MacLellan, M. Mahtab, S. Majidi, C. Malbrunot, P. Margetak, P. Martel-Dion, L. Martin, J. MasbouThe European Physical Journal C 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

The nEXO collaboration has successfully characterized a new generation of vacuum ultra-violet (VUV) sensitive Silicon Photo-Multipliers (SiPMs) from FBK and Hamamatsu. These sensors exceed the stringent requirements for the nEXO experiment, demonstrating the ability to achieve an energy resolution of ~0.75%—well below the 1% target—essential for detecting the incredibly rare neutrinoless double beta decay in liquid xenon.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nEXO experiment is a massive search for neutrinoless double beta decay ($0\nu\beta\beta$) in $^{136}$Xe. If discovered, this decay would prove that neutrinos are their own antiparticles (Majorana fermions) and provide a window into physics beyond the Standard Model.

To find this needle in a haystack, nEXO needs a detector with an exceptionally high energy resolution ($\le 1\%$) and ultra-low radioactive backgrounds. The detector uses liquid xenon (LXe), which produces scintillation light at a wavelength of 175 nm (vacuum ultra-violet). Traditional vacuum-based photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) are too radioactive for this purpose. SiPMs are the solid-state alternative, but they face three major hurdles:

  1. VUV Sensitivity: Most silicon sensors absorb VUV light in their top layers before it can trigger a signal.
  2. Correlated Noise: "Avalanches" in one pixel can trigger others (crosstalk) or re-trigger the same pixel later (afterpulsing), which smears the energy measurement.
  3. Cryogenic Operation: The sensors must perform reliably at 163 K (the temperature of liquid xenon).

Methods

The researchers performed a comprehensive "stress test" of the latest sensors: the FBK VUVHD3 and the Hamamatsu VUV4 series. Testing was distributed across six international institutions (including TRIUMF, Yale, and McGill) to ensure results were reproducible.

Key experimental techniques included:

  • Cryogenic Characterization: Measuring performance at 163 K using dry cryostats and liquid xenon setups.
  • Pulse Analysis: Using matched-filter algorithms to deconvolve overlapping pulses and extract precise timing and charge information.
  • PDE Measurement: Determining the Photon Detection Efficiency (PDE) by comparing SiPM signals against NIST-calibrated photodiodes under 175 nm illumination.
  • Noise Modeling: Quantifying the "Correlated Avalanche Fluctuation" (CAF), a metric specifically developed to understand how sensor noise impacts the final energy resolution of the nEXO detector.

Datasets

While this is an experimental physics paper rather than a machine learning study, the "datasets" consist of performance metrics for specific sensor batches:

  • FBK VUVHD3: A new generation featuring "triple-doping" technology designed to suppress afterpulsing.
  • Hamamatsu VUV4 (S13370/S13371): New samples of multi-pixel photon counters (MPPCs) with improved VUV sensitivity.
  • Baseline Comparisons: Data from previous generations (VUVHD1 and earlier VUV4 samples) were used to quantify the leap in performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Triple-Doping Success: The FBK VUVHD3's new doping profile significantly suppresses afterpulsing. This allows the sensor to be operated at a higher over-voltage (the voltage above the breakdown point), which increases the signal strength without a proportional increase in noise.
  • The CAF Metric: The paper emphasizes that the average amount of noise isn't the problem; it's the fluctuation in that noise (CAF). Both new sensors showed a significant reduction in CAF compared to previous generations.
  • Interference Effects: The FBK sensors showed "oscillations" in their PDE across different wavelengths. This was traced back to thin-film interference in the ~1.5 µm SiO₂ protection layer on the sensor surface—a crucial detail for accurate detector simulations.
  • Exceeding the Goal: Both sensors achieved a PDE at 175 nm of >20% (HPK) and >24% (FBK), comfortably exceeding the nEXO requirement of 15%.

Key Results

  • Energy Resolution: The projected energy resolution at the $^{136}$Xe $Q$-value (2458 keV) is 0.73% for FBK and 0.76% for Hamamatsu. This is a major milestone, as it beats the nEXO design goal of 1%.
  • Dark Count Rate (DCR): At 163 K, the DCR was measured at < 0.4 Hz/mm², which is more than 20 times lower than the maximum allowable limit (10 Hz/mm²).
  • Gain: Both sensors provide a gain of $> 1.5 \times 10^6$ electrons per photo-electron at typical operating voltages, ensuring signals are well above the electronic noise floor.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scaling Up: The sensors tested were relatively small (~0.35 cm²). nEXO will require roughly 4.5 square meters of SiPMs. The next step is characterizing 1 cm² "tiles" and ensuring mass-production consistency.
  • Radioactivity: While SiPMs are inherently cleaner than PMTs, the packaging (ceramics, wire bonds) must be strictly controlled. The collaboration is investigating Through Silicon Vias (TSV) to replace wire bonds, which would further reduce radioactivity and improve the "fill factor" (active area) of the sensor arrays.
  • Long-term Stability: Future studies will focus on the long-term stability of these sensors when submerged in liquid xenon for years at a time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Liquid xenon time projection chambers are promising detectors to search for neutrinoless double beta decay (0 $$\nu \beta \beta $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi><mml:mi>β</mml:mi><mml:mi>β</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math> ), due to their response uniformity, monolithic sensitive volume, scalability to large target masses, and suitability for extremely low background operations. The nEXO collaboration has designed a tonne-scale time projection chamber that aims to search for 0 $$\nu \beta \beta $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi><mml:mi>β</mml:mi><mml:mi>β</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math> of $$^{136}$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:msup><mml:mrow/><mml:mn>136</mml:mn></mml:msup></mml:math> Xe with projected half-life sensitivity of $$1.35\times 10^{28}$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mn>1.35</mml:mn><mml:mo>×</mml:mo><mml:msup><mml:mn>10</mml:mn><mml:mn>28</mml:mn></mml:msup></mml:mrow></mml:math> yr. To reach this sensitivity, the design goal for nEXO is $$\le $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mo>≤</mml:mo></mml:math> 1% energy resolution at the decay Q -value ( $$2458.07\pm 0.31$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mn>2458.07</mml:mn><mml:mo>±</mml:mo><mml:mn>0.31</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:math> keV). Reaching this resolution requires the efficient collection of both the ionization and scintillation produced in the detector. The nEXO design employs Silicon Photo-Multipliers (SiPMs) to detect the vacuum ultra-violet, 175 nm scintillation light of liquid xenon. This paper reports on the characterization of the newest vacuum ultra-violet sensitive Fondazione Bruno Kessler VUVHD3 SiPMs specifically designed for nEXO, as well as new measurements on new test samples of previously characterised Hamamatsu VUV4 Multi Pixel Photon Counters (MPPCs). Various SiPM and MPPC parameters, such as dark noise, gain, direct crosstalk, correlated avalanches and photon detection efficiency were measured as a function of the applied over voltage and wavelength at liquid xenon temperature (163 K). The results from this study are used to provide updated estimates of the achievable energy resolution at the decay Q -value for the nEXO design.
BibTeX
@article{gallina2022performance,
  author = {G. Gallina and Y. H. Guan and F. Retière and G. F. Cao and A. E. Bolotnikov and I. Kotov and S. Rescia and A. K. Soma and T. Tsang and L. Darroch and T. Brunner and J. Bolster and J.R. Cohen and T. Pinto Franco and W. Gillis and H. Peltz Smalley and S. Thibado and A. Pocar and Aaqib Ayoub Bhat and A. Jamil and David C. Moore and G. Adhikari and S. Al Kharusi and Evan Angelico and I. J. Arnquist and P. Arsenault and I. Badhrees and J. Bane and V. Belov and E. P. Bernard and Trilochan Bhatta and P. A. Breur and J. Brodsky and A. Brown and E. Caden and Liqiang Cao and C. Chambers and B. Chana and Serge A. Charlebois and D. Chernyak and M. Chiu and B. T. Cleveland and R. Collister and M. Cvitan and J. Dalmasson and T. Daniels and K. Deslandes and R. DeVoe and M. L. di Vacri and Ying Ding and M. J. Dolinski and A. Dragone and J. Echevers and B. Eckert and M. Elbeltagi and L. Fabris and W. M. Fairbank and J. Farine and Yanyan Fu and D. Gallacher and P. Gautam and G. Giacomini and C. Gingras and D. Goeldi and R. Gornea and G. Gratta and C. A. Hardy and S. Hedges and M. Heffner and Emilie Hein and J. D. Holt and E. W. Hoppe and J. Hößl and A. House and W. E. Hunt and A. Iverson and X. S. Jiang and A. Karelin and L. J. Kaufman and R. Krücken and A. Kuchenkov and K.S. Kumar and A. C. Larson and K. G. Leach and B. G. Lenardo and D. S. Leonard and G. Lessard and Gang Li and S. Li and Z. Li and C. Licciardi and R. Lindsay and R. MacLellan and M. Mahtab and S. Majidi and C. Malbrunot and P. Margetak and P. Martel-Dion and L. Martin and J. Masbou},
  title = {{Performance of novel VUV-sensitive Silicon Photo-Multipliers for nEXO}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-11072-8},
}
Figure