Performance of Base and Noble Metals for Electrocatalytic Hydrogenation of Bio-Oil-Derived Oxygenated Compounds

Evan Andrews, Juan A. Lopez‐Ruiz, Jonathan D. Egbert, Katherine Koh, Udishnu Sanyal, Miao Song, Dongsheng Li, Abhijeet Karkamkar, Miroslaw A. Derewinski, Johnathan E. Holladay, Oliver Y. Gutiérrez, Jamie D. HolladayACS 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores electrocatalytic hydrogenation (ECH) as a sustainable method to upgrade bio-oil, a complex mixture derived from biomass. The researchers screened various metal catalysts, finding that aldehydes are readily converted to alcohols or dimers, with reaction pathways controllable by catalyst choice and applied potential. This work provides crucial guidelines for selecting catalysts and conditions for efficient bio-oil upgrading.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bio-oil, a product of biomass pyrolysis, is rich in oxygenated organic molecules that are unstable and can lead to issues like reactor fouling. Traditional hydrogenation methods to upgrade bio-oil are energy-intensive and require high pressures and temperatures, often leading to catalyst deactivation. Electrocatalytic hydrogenation (ECH) offers a promising alternative, operating under mild conditions (ambient temperature and pressure) without the need for external hydrogen gas. However, the complex and variable composition of bio-oil makes it challenging to predict how different catalysts will perform. This paper aims to bridge the gap between fundamental ECH studies and practical bio-oil upgrading by systematically evaluating a range of metal catalysts on model compounds and real bio-oil under identical conditions.

Methods

The researchers synthesized various carbon-supported transition metal catalysts (both noble metals like Pd, Ru, Rh and base metals like Cu, Ni, Co, Zn). They characterized these catalysts using techniques like ICP-OES, H2 chemisorption, N2O titration, and STEM imaging to understand their properties.

The core of their experimental approach involved electrocatalytic hydrogenation (ECH) experiments conducted in a continuous flow cell. They tested the catalysts with a variety of model biomass-derived oxygenated compounds (aldehydes, ketones, phenols, acids) and then with actual bio-oil. Key parameters controlled and varied included:

  • Applied potential: Ranging from -600 to -1400 mV vs. Ag/AgCl.
  • Catalyst type: Comparing noble metals, base metals, and blank carbon felt.
  • Substrate: A range of functionalized organic molecules and bio-oil.
  • Bio-oil concentration: From 0% to 10% in the electrolyte.

They analyzed the reaction products using gas chromatography (GC) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with refractive index detection, and identified products using ¹H-NMR. They also measured carboxylic acid, phenolic, and carbonyl content in the bio-oil samples to assess the upgrading process.

Datasets

The study utilized a set of model biomass-derived organic compounds as substrates for ECH. These compounds were chosen to represent various functional groups and structural features found in bio-oil. The specific compounds tested are listed in Scheme 1 and Figure 3 of the paper. Additionally, a real bio-oil sample, obtained from the fast pyrolysis of a blended feedstock (hybrid poplar, wheat straw, and forest thinnings), was used for the upgrading experiments. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on evaluating existing materials and processes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aldehydes are prime targets: Aldehydes, particularly aromatic ones like benzaldehyde and furfural, are highly reactive towards ECH under the tested conditions, making them ideal candidates for upgrading.
  • Catalyst and potential control reaction pathways: The choice of metal catalyst and the applied potential significantly influence the reaction outcome. Noble metals tend to favor alcohol formation and hydrogen evolution, while base metals can be tuned to favor either alcohol formation or dimerization.
  • Dimerization as a competing pathway: For base metals, at more cathodic potentials, dimerization of aldehydes (like benzaldehyde forming hydrobenzoin) becomes a significant competing reaction to simple hydrogenation to alcohols. This suggests a delicate balance between surface hydrogen availability and radical coupling.
  • Bio-oil components compete: The presence of other compounds in bio-oil (phenolics, carboxylic acids) can compete with target molecules like benzaldehyde for reduction equivalents, impacting the overall efficiency of the ECH process.
  • Pd and Cu show promise: Palladium (Pd) and Copper (Cu) emerged as the most active and efficient catalysts for ECH of model compounds, making them strong candidates for bio-oil upgrading. Pd, in particular, demonstrated excellent stability and recovery.
  • Base metals can be more efficient: While noble metals often show higher reaction rates, base metals can offer comparable conversions with better efficiencies, especially in terms of hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) selectivity.

Key Results

  • Aldehyde conversion: Benzaldehyde and furfural showed the highest ECH rates on Pd, with rates of 3.6 and 2.2 mmol gcat⁻¹ h⁻¹ respectively. Aliphatic aldehydes like cyclohexanecarboxaldehyde and heptanal had significantly lower rates.
  • Dimerization selectivity: Base metals (Co, Ni, Zn) showed a propensity for dimerization of benzaldehyde to hydrobenzoin at potentials more cathodic than -900 mV vs. Ag/AgCl.
  • HER vs. ECH: Noble metals like Rh exhibited high HER activity, which competed with ECH, leading to lower Faradaic efficiencies for hydrogenation. Cu showed a good balance between ECH and HER.
  • Bio-oil upgrading: In the presence of 10 wt% bio-oil, Pd and Cu showed a decrease in carbonyl content, indicating successful reduction of carbonyl functionalities. Pd maintained stable performance, while Cu showed some deactivation. Phenolic and carboxylic acid content remained largely unchanged, suggesting they are not readily upgraded under these conditions.
  • Stability: Pd demonstrated remarkable stability, recovering its initial performance even after exposure to various feed compositions and operational conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mass transfer limitations: While the authors state they ruled out external mass transfer limitations based on previous work, the high Tafel slopes observed suggest potential internal mass transfer or surface reaction limitations that warrant further investigation.
  • Bio-oil component reactivity: The study found that phenolics and carboxylic acids in bio-oil were not readily upgraded under the tested conditions. Future work could explore catalysts and conditions specifically designed to target these more recalcitrant compounds.
  • Residence time: For bio-oil upgrading, longer residence times were found to be necessary to observe significant conversion, especially at higher bio-oil concentrations. Optimizing flow cell configurations and residence times for complex bio-oil mixtures is an area for future research.
  • Catalyst deactivation: While Pd showed excellent stability, Cu exhibited some deactivation upon introduction of bio-oil. Understanding the mechanisms of deactivation for various catalysts in complex bio-oil environments is crucial for long-term industrial application.
  • Product identification in bio-oil: While benzaldehyde conversion was monitored, the identification and quantification of products from other bio-oil components were limited, especially at shorter residence times. More detailed product analysis for complex bio-oil streams would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electrocatalytic hydrogenation is a particularly attractive approach for converting the most unstable compounds in biogenic feedstocks at ambient conditions without external H2. Here, we synthesized a variety of carbon-supported transition metal catalysts and characterized their activity for the electrocatalytic hydrogenation of a series of model compounds and pyrolysis bio-oil. Carbonyl compounds, especially aromatic aldehydes, such as furfural and benzaldehyde, are particularly inclined to hydrogenation driven by an applied current. This was verified with pure solutions of the model compounds and with pyrolysis bio-oil, where we achieved stable and steady continuous operation on Pd. When optimal catalyst composition was chosen, the conversion of benzaldehyde shifted from alcohol production (e.g., on Pd and Cu) to dimerization (e.g., on Co, Ni, and Zn). Pd and Cu were shown to offer the best compromise between reaction rates and efficiency although, in general, base metals offer similar conversions but better efficiencies than noble metals. Thus, the present work offers foundational results and guidelines for choosing the optimal metal catalyst and the applied potential for processing organic feedstocks as a function of its composition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{andrews2020performance,
  author = {Evan Andrews and Juan A. Lopez‐Ruiz and Jonathan D. Egbert and Katherine Koh and Udishnu Sanyal and Miao Song and Dongsheng Li and Abhijeet Karkamkar and Miroslaw A. Derewinski and Johnathan E. Holladay and Oliver Y. Gutiérrez and Jamie D. Holladay and Jamie D. Holladay and Jamie D. Holladay},
  title = {{Performance of Base and Noble Metals for Electrocatalytic Hydrogenation of Bio-Oil-Derived Oxygenated Compounds}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1021/acssuschemeng.9b07041},
}
Figure