Performance Improvement of a Liquid Molten Salt Pump: Geometry Optimization and Experimental Verification

Kai Wang, Xin Lu, Yu Li, Xianghui He, Houlin Liu, Hyoung-Bum KimSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of improving the hydraulic efficiency and structural stability of liquid molten salt pumps, crucial components in advanced nuclear reactors. By employing a combination of numerical simulations and experimental validation, the researchers successfully optimized the pump's geometry, leading to a significant increase in efficiency and a reduction in pressure pulsation and vibration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liquid molten salt pumps are vital for transporting high-temperature, corrosive fluids in applications like advanced nuclear reactors. However, these pumps often face issues with hydraulic efficiency and structural integrity due to the harsh operating conditions and the inherent complexities of fluid dynamics at high temperatures. Existing research has primarily focused on the internal flow characteristics and modeling experiments, with less emphasis on practical geometric modifications for performance enhancement and structural stability. This paper aims to bridge this gap by identifying specific geometric features that contribute to flow losses and structural issues and proposing targeted modifications to address them.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Numerical Simulation: Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) was used to analyze the internal flow field of a prototype liquid molten salt pump. This involved creating a detailed 3D model, generating a hexahedral mesh, and performing simulations under design flow conditions. The standard k-ε turbulence model was utilized for the analysis.
  • Geometric Modification: Based on the insights from the numerical simulations, specific geometric modifications were implemented. These included trimming the back-blades of the impeller to reduce power loss and smoothing a sharp corner near the outlet pipe of the annular chamber to mitigate flow separation and pressure pulsation.
  • Experimental Verification: A comprehensive experimental setup was used to validate the numerical findings and assess the performance of both the original and modified pumps. This involved measuring hydraulic performance (head, flow rate, efficiency), pressure pulsation, and vibration characteristics. Water was used as the experimental medium, as its performance characteristics are considered consistent with molten salt in this context.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from a prototype pump and simulation results generated by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flow Separation and Pressure Pulsation: The numerical analysis revealed critical areas contributing to performance degradation: a low-velocity zone in the scroll region and a separated flow region near a sharp corner at the outlet pipe. These phenomena were identified as primary causes of pressure pulsation and reduced efficiency.
  • Targeted Geometric Optimization: The paper demonstrates that precise geometric modifications, such as trimming impeller back-blades and smoothing sharp corners, can effectively address identified flow issues. This highlights the power of combining simulation-driven design with experimental validation.
  • Holistic Performance Improvement: The modifications not only improved hydraulic efficiency but also significantly reduced pressure pulsation and vibration. This suggests that geometric optimization can lead to a more robust and stable pump design, crucial for high-temperature applications.
  • Correlation between Flow and Vibration: The study implicitly shows a strong link between fluid dynamics and mechanical vibration. Reducing flow instabilities and pressure fluctuations directly translates to lower vibration levels, enhancing the pump's overall reliability.

Key Results

  • Hydraulic Efficiency: The modified pump achieved an efficiency of 76.7% at the design flow rate, a significant increase of 5.26 percentage points compared to the original pump (71.5%). This meets the design requirement of 75%.
  • Pressure Pulsation:
    • At monitoring points P1-P4, the amplitude of pressure pulsation decreased by 38.9%, 42.9%, 27.1%, and 5.4%, respectively, in the improved pump.
  • At point P6, the peak-to-peak value of the time-domain pressure pulsation was reduced by 71.4%, and the amplitude in the frequency domain decreased by 32.5%.
  • Vibration Characteristics:
    • Wide frequency bands observed in the original pump's vibration spectrum (e.g., at M1 and M10/M16) largely disappeared or diminished in the improved pump.
  • The maximum vibration intensity at monitoring point M4 decreased by 18.1% (from 1.27 mm/s to 1.04 mm/s).
  • Vibration intensities at most monitoring points, particularly at the inlet flange and bearing locations, were reduced in the improved pump.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Physical Properties of Molten Salt: The authors acknowledge that the influence of the physical properties of molten salt (e.g., viscosity, thermal expansion) on the pump's performance and stability was not considered in this study. They suggest that future research should include a comprehensive study of these properties.
  • Experimental Medium: While water was used as a proxy for molten salt, direct experimental verification with actual molten salt would provide more definitive results, especially concerning high-temperature effects on material properties and fluid behavior.
  • Further Optimization: The study focused on specific geometric modifications. Further optimization could explore a wider range of design parameters and potentially more complex geometric changes.
  • Long-term Stability: While the study shows immediate performance improvements, long-term operational stability and wear characteristics of the modified pump under actual molten salt conditions would be valuable to investigate.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{wang2019performance,
  author = {Kai Wang and Xin Lu and Yu Li and Xianghui He and Houlin Liu and Hyoung-Bum Kim},
  title = {{Performance Improvement of a Liquid Molten Salt Pump: Geometry Optimization and Experimental Verification}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11030423},
}
Figure