Abstract
This paper provides a theoretical foundation for the performance of greedy heuristics in active sensing and information-theoretic inference. We prove that selecting measurements to maximize immediate mutual information (MI) guarantees at least 50% of the performance of the optimal open-loop sequence. Additionally, we introduce tighter "online" bounds that allow for real-time calculation of optimality during execution. Our results, validated through ocean floor mapping and object tracking simulations, demonstrate that greedy algorithms often significantly exceed the 0.5 theoretical floor, particularly in environments characterized by state diffusion.
Introduction
Active inference involves selecting actions or sensor measurements to reduce uncertainty about a hidden state. In robotics and autonomous systems, this often translates to maximizing the Mutual Information (MI) between future measurements and the state of interest. While the optimal solution requires planning over all possible future sequences—a problem that suffers from "combinatorial explosion"—practitioners typically rely on a greedy heuristic: picking the single most informative measurement at each time step.
Despite its widespread use, the theoretical performance gap between greedy selection and the optimal sequence has remained largely unquantified for sequential observation sets. This work addresses this gap by providing both offline worst-case guarantees and online computable bounds.
Methodology and Theoretical Guarantees
The core of our analysis relies on the property of submodularity, which characterizes the "diminishing returns" often found in information gathering. As more data is collected, the marginal information gain from any additional measurement typically decreases.
The 1/2 Performance Guarantee
We prove that for sequential observation sets, the greedy heuristic is guaranteed to achieve at least 50% (a factor of 0.5) of the total MI of the optimal open-loop sequence. This provides a rigorous "safety net" for the use of greedy algorithms in complex robotics tasks.
Exploiting State Diffusion
In many tracking problems, the target's state is not static but "diffuses" over time (e.g., a random walk). We demonstrate that such diffusion actually benefits the greedy algorithm. Because older information becomes obsolete as the target moves, the "myopic" nature of the greedy choice becomes less of a penalty. We introduce a $(1+\alpha)$ bound, where $\alpha$ represents the strength of the diffusion, showing that the performance guarantee improves as the environment becomes more dynamic.
Online Computable Bounds
Beyond theoretical worst-case floors, we provide formulas for online bounds. These can be calculated during a simulation or live run to provide a much tighter, instance-specific estimate of how close the current greedy sequence is to the theoretical maximum.
Experimental Validation
We validated our theoretical findings using two primary simulations:
- Ocean Floor Mapping: A surface vehicle navigates a grid, selecting cells to measure using a noisy Gaussian sensor. The environment is modeled as a Gauss-Markov random field.
- 2D Object Tracking: A target undergoes a 2D Gaussian random walk, tracked by four stationary sensors providing noisy bearing measurements over 200 time steps.
Results and Discussion
In the mapping simulation, while the theoretical floor was 0.5, our online bounds demonstrated that the greedy algorithm achieved at least 80% of the optimal reward.
The tracking simulation further confirmed that performance guarantees strengthen as measurement noise decreases. For instance, with a measurement standard deviation of 0.1 degrees, the greedy heuristic was guaranteed to be within 77% of the optimal performance.
These results suggest that the greedy approach is not just a computationally necessary compromise but a highly effective strategy for real-world active inference.
Limitations and Future Work
A critical caveat of this work is the distinction between open-loop and closed-loop optimality. While greedy selection is at least 50% as good as the optimal open-loop sequence, it can perform significantly worse than the optimal closed-loop policy (which adjusts plans based on incoming data) in certain large state spaces. Future research will focus on establishing stronger closed-loop guarantees, particularly for diffusive processes, which remains a significant theoretical challenge.
Summary updated