Performance forecasts for the primordial gravitational wave detection pipelines for AliCPT-1

Shamik Ghosh, Yang Liu, Le Zhang, Siyu Li, Junzhou Zhang, Jiaxin Wang, Jiazheng Dou, Jiming Chen, Jacques Delabrouille, M. Remazeilles, Chang Qing Feng, Bin Hu, Zhiqi Huang, Hao Liu, Larissa Santos, Pengjie Zhang, Zhaoxuan Zhang, Wen Zhao, Hong Li, Xinmin ZhangJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

AliCPT is the first Chinese cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiment which will make the most precise measurements of the CMB polarization in the northern hemisphere. The key science goal for AliCPT is the detection of primordial gravitational waves (PGWs). It is well known that an epoch of cosmic inflation, in the very early universe, can produce PGWs, which leave an imprint on the CMB in form of odd parity $B$-mode polarization. In this work, we study the performance of the component separation and parameter estimation pipelines in context of constraining the value of the tensor-to-scalar ratio. Based on the simulated data for one observation season, we compare five different pipelines with different working principles. Three pipelines perform component separation at map or spectra level before estimating $r$ from the cleaned spectra, while the other two pipelines performs a global fit for both foreground parameters and $r$. We also test different methods to account for the effects of time stream filtering systematics. This work shows that our pipelines provide consistent and robust constraints on the tensor-to-scalar ratio and a consistent sensitivity $\sigma(r) \sim 0.02$. This showcases the potential of precise $B$-mode polarization measurement with AliCPT-1. AliCPT will provide a powerful opportunity to detect PGWs, which is complementary with various ground-based CMB experiments in the southern hemisphere.

Introduction

The detection of primordial gravitational waves (PGWs) generated during the inflationary epoch is a primary objective of modern cosmology. These waves are expected to leave a distinct signature in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) in the form of $B$-mode polarization. However, this signal is exceptionally faint and buried under significant astrophysical foregrounds—primarily Galactic dust and synchrotron radiation—as well as instrumental systematics and atmospheric noise.

AliCPT-1, located in Tibet, is the first major Chinese experiment dedicated to measuring CMB polarization from the northern hemisphere. This study evaluates the robustness of five independent data analysis pipelines designed to extract the tensor-to-scalar ratio ($r$) from the complex data expected from AliCPT-1's initial observation season.

Experimental Configuration and Datasets

The study utilizes the Data Challenge 1 (DC1) dataset, which simulates one observation season of AliCPT-1. The experiment operates primarily in two frequency bands, 90 GHz and 150 GHz, utilizing Transition Edge Sensor (TES) detector technology.

Technical specifications of the AliCPT-1 experiment, including site location, resolution, and detector counts.

The simulations incorporate a "clean patch" covering approximately 17% of the northern sky, specifically chosen for low foreground contamination. To aid in foreground removal, the pipelines also integrate ancillary data from the Planck and WMAP satellites. A "blind" truth value of $r = 0.023$ was embedded in the simulations to rigorously test the accuracy of the recovery pipelines.

Analysis Methodology

Five distinct pipelines were compared to ensure methodological redundancy and cross-validation:

  1. Clean-then-Fit Approaches:
    • ABS (Analytic Blind Separation): A model-independent method using mathematical projections to isolate the CMB signal.
  2. GLS (Generalized Least Squares) & cILC (Constrained Internal Linear Combination): These methods perform foreground cleaning at the map level before power spectrum estimation.
  3. Global Fitting Approaches:
    • McMfL (Multi-component Multi-frequency Likelihood) & TF (Template Fitting): These perform a joint parametric fit for foregrounds, instrumental effects, and the cosmological signal $r$.

A critical aspect of the analysis was handling time-stream filtering systematics. The study compared "Backward Correction" (using transfer functions) against "Forward Modeling" (incorporating filtering effects directly into the theoretical model).

Results and Performance

The primary finding is the remarkable consistency across all five pipelines. Despite their different mathematical foundations, all methods achieved a sensitivity of $\sigma(r) \sim 0.02$.

Sky coverage maps and noise distribution histograms for the 90 GHz and 150 GHz channels in the AliCPT-1 simulation.

For the mock data with a true value of $r = 0.023$, the recovered values ranged from $0.012$ to $0.029$, all within $1\sigma$ or $2\sigma$ of the truth. Furthermore, null tests on noise-only simulations correctly yielded upper limits (e.g., $r < 0.041$ at 95% confidence), demonstrating that the pipelines do not introduce spurious signals. The "Forward Modeling" approach, particularly in the ABS and TF pipelines, proved especially robust in mitigating signal suppression from filtering.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The results demonstrate that AliCPT-1 is well-positioned to provide high-precision $B$-mode measurements that complement southern hemisphere experiments like BICEP/Keck. While the current study uses simplified systematics and treats gravitational lensing as a known noise component, it establishes a solid foundation for future data analysis. Subsequent work will incorporate more complex instrumental effects, such as bandpass mismatch and non-Gaussian beams, and will extend the forecasts to multi-year observation periods to further improve sensitivity.

Reference: Ghosh, S., et al. (2022). Performance forecasts for the primordial gravitational wave detection pipelines for AliCPT-1. JCAP. arXiv:2205.14804v3.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract AliCPT is the first Chinese cosmic microwave background (CMB) experiment which will make the most precise measurements of the CMB polarization in the northern hemisphere. The key science goal for AliCPT is the detection of primordial gravitational waves (PGWs). It is well known that an epoch of cosmic inflation, in the very early universe, can produce PGWs, which leave an imprint on the CMB in form of odd parity B -mode polarization. In this work, we study the performance of the component separation and parameter estimation pipelines in context of constraining the value of the tensor-to-scalar ratio. Based on the simulated data for one observation season, we compare five different pipelines with different working principles. Three pipelines perform component separation at map or spectra level before estimating r from the cleaned spectra, while the other two pipelines performs a global fit for both foreground parameters and r . We also test different methods to account for the effects of time stream filtering systematics. This work shows that our pipelines provide consistent and robust constraints on the tensor-to-scalar ratio and a consistent sensitivity σ ( r ) ∼ 0.02. This showcases the potential of precise B -mode polarization measurement with AliCPT-1. AliCPT will provide a powerful opportunity to detect PGWs, which is complementary with various ground-based CMB experiments in the southern hemisphere.
BibTeX
@article{ghosh2022performance,
  author = {Shamik Ghosh and Yang Liu and Le Zhang and Siyu Li and Junzhou Zhang and Jiaxin Wang and Jiazheng Dou and Jiming Chen and Jacques Delabrouille and M. Remazeilles and Chang Qing Feng and Bin Hu and Zhiqi Huang and Hao Liu and Larissa Santos and Pengjie Zhang and Zhaoxuan Zhang and Wen Zhao and Hong Li and Xinmin Zhang},
  title = {{Performance forecasts for the primordial gravitational wave detection pipelines for AliCPT-1}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2022/10/063},
}
Figure