Performance Evaluations of LoRa Wireless Communication in Building Environments

Ruobing Liang, Liang Zhao, Peng Wang2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the performance of LoRa wireless communication within a multi-story office building, focusing on crucial metrics like round-trip time (RTT) and packet delivery rate (PDR). The findings provide valuable insights into LoRa's suitability for smart building applications, highlighting its strengths and limitations in complex indoor environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Smart buildings (SBs) are increasingly leveraging the Internet of Things (IoT) to enhance energy management, occupant comfort, and safety. A critical component of SBs is reliable wireless communication for sensor data acquisition and control. While LoRa technology offers advantages like long-range transmission and low power consumption, its performance in challenging indoor environments, particularly within reinforced concrete structures, remains a significant concern. Existing research often focuses on outdoor or simpler indoor scenarios, leaving a gap in understanding LoRa's real-world effectiveness for dense, multi-floor building applications where signal penetration and multipath interference are substantial. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a detailed experimental evaluation of LoRa's communication performance within a typical office building.

Methods

The study employs a practical, experimental approach to evaluate LoRa's performance. Three key metrics were measured:

  • Round-Trip Time (RTT): This measures the time it takes for a signal to travel from a transmitter to a receiver and back. It's a crucial indicator of real-time performance for control systems.
  • Packet Delivery Rate (PDR): This quantifies the percentage of transmitted packets that are successfully received, indicating the reliability of the communication link.

The experiments were conducted in a 16-story reinforced concrete office building. A single LoRa transmitter was placed on the 7th floor, centrally located. Multiple LoRa receiver nodes (air quality detectors with LoRa modules) were strategically deployed:

  • On the same floor (7th floor): Three receivers were placed in the easternmost, westernmost, and northernmost directions to assess signal penetration through walls and the impact of distance on the same level.
  • On different floors: Eight receivers were deployed across various floors to evaluate LoRa's ability to penetrate reinforced concrete structures.

The researchers systematically varied several parameters to understand their influence on RTT and PDR:

  • Transmit Power (SP): Ranged from 10 dBm to 20 dBm.
  • Payload Length (PL): Tested at 7 B, 23 B, 39 B, and 55 B.
  • Air Rate (AR): Varied from 1.2 kbps to 19.2 kbps.
  • Position: Receivers were placed at different locations within the building.

The experimental setup utilized specific LoRa modules (Semtech SX1278) and custom software for data acquisition and configuration.

Datasets

This paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it relies on real-world experimental measurements collected within a specific office building environment. The "dataset" consists of the recorded RTT and PDR values obtained under various controlled experimental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LoRa's Penetration Capability: LoRa demonstrates a notable ability to penetrate cement walls, achieving high PDRs (often >95%) on the same floor even with multiple walls between the transmitter and receiver. However, penetration through reinforced concrete floors is significantly more challenging, with PDRs dropping considerably on different floors, especially in "far" zones.
  • RTT is Relatively Stable: Round-trip times were found to be relatively consistent across different locations and transmit power settings, generally fluctuating between 570-600 ms. This suggests that while signal strength might vary, the latency for successful transmissions remains within a predictable range.
  • Air Rate and Payload Length are Key Drivers for RTT: Increasing the air rate (AR) significantly reduces RTT, but higher rates can lead to communication instability. Conversely, increasing payload length (PL) increases RTT, though the trend moderates for larger payloads.
  • Transmit Power Has Limited Impact on RTT: Varying transmit power (SP) had a minimal effect on RTT, indicating that for successful transmissions, other factors are more dominant.
  • PDR is Highly Sensitive to Location and Obstructions: PDR drops sharply in "far" areas of the building, particularly on lower floors or when significant reinforced concrete barriers are present. The "near" zones (closer to the transmitter) consistently show much higher PDRs.
  • 433 MHz Band Shows Promise: The study utilizes the 433 MHz ISM band, which is noted as having better penetration performance than the more commonly studied 868 MHz band for building applications.

Key Results

  • Same Floor Performance: On the same floor, LoRa achieved excellent PDRs, often exceeding 99.5% on average, even when penetrating up to nine cement walls.
  • Different Floor Performance: PDRs on different floors were significantly lower. In "far" zones (e.g., B2, 15F, 16F), PDRs were close to 0%. In "near" zones (e.g., 3F, 6F, 8F, 12F), PDRs were still below 80% in some scenarios.
  • Parameter Impact on RTT:
    • Increasing PL increased RTT.
  • Increasing AR decreased RTT, with the trend slowing down above 9.6 kbps.
  • SP had little effect on RTT.
  • Location had a minor impact on RTT, with variations generally within 30 ms.
  • Parameter Impact on PDR:
    • PDR generally increased with SP and decreased with PL and AR.
  • Payload length and air rate had a greater influence on PDR than transmit power.
  • The easternmost measurement point (with more walls) consistently showed lower PDRs compared to the northernmost point.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Power Consumption Not Considered: The study focused solely on communication performance and did not evaluate LoRa's power consumption, which is a critical factor for battery-powered IoT devices.
  • Building Specificity: The experiments were conducted in a single, specific reinforced concrete office building. The results may vary in buildings with different construction materials, layouts, and interference levels.
  • Single Transmitter: The experiments used a single transmitter. The performance in a multi-transmitter or mesh network scenario was not investigated.
  • AQD as Receiver: While practical, the use of AQDs as receivers might introduce specific characteristics not inherent to all LoRa receivers.

The authors suggest future work could focus on:

  • Investigating LoRa performance in mesh networking conditions.
  • Exploring performance in conjunction with other technologies like Zigbee or Wi-Fi.
  • Designing low-power wireless communication systems for scenarios with inconvenient power supply.
  • Further research into the impact of different building materials and complex environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liang2020performance,
  author = {Ruobing Liang and Liang Zhao and Peng Wang},
  title = {{Performance Evaluations of LoRa Wireless Communication in Building Environments}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20143828},
}
Figure